Best Broadband Provider???
Author
Discussion

Sammo123

Original Poster:

2,204 posts

212 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
I'm sure this has been asked before but I'm asking again.

Due to BT increasing their prices I've got the opportunity to negotiate my deal or change broadband providers. We've had BT Infinity for the last few years and while it's been ok it's also had its issues. It drops out quite frequently, struggles to get the wifi signal all the way through the house (a regular sized 1930's ex council house) and can't seem to handle the amount of devices we have connected.

What I want to know is if anyone can offer information about some of the other broadband providers. Sky, TalkTalk and Plusnet I guess are the other big ones. Need to get on with it a bit sharpish so any information will be helpful.

Cheers.

Turn7

25,790 posts

252 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
VM BB has always been very good for me, but they are fast becoming as big a group of shysters as Sky these days.

Ive been with Virgin since dial up and can count the number of days of zero internet on one hand.

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
It's essentially down to who has workable customer support.

BT were difficult to get any sense out of, moved to Plusnet. Had a couple of disconnects, their online help (at 8:01 am) was very good.

Then they whacked up their prices. Moved to NowTv (Sky). Appears to be run by children. No disconnects so far though.

You can also get cashback from Quidco and the like if you go through them.

If I had to do it again, PlusNet were the least worst.

As to whole-house wifi, the usual trick is to add in a repeater or two. About £15 each.

ashleyman

7,284 posts

130 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
Sammo123 said:
It drops out quite frequently, struggles to get the wifi signal all the way through the house (a regular sized 1930's ex council house) and can't seem to handle the amount of devices we have connected.
This sounds like a router / wireless issue, not a broadband issue.

You'll probably be able to solve your issue by buying a better wireless router or some repeaters.

As for who's the best. I've had PlusNet for the last 3 years. It shot up last year but I managed to negotiate a better rate - £31.98. It's just shot back up again this month but we're moving anyway. They do charge £30 for cancellation when not moving the line to a new property. They're not the fastest but the speeds were good and reliable. My dedicated IP cost me a one time fee of £5. The support has been ok but you do have to hold for longer than is acceptable.

curlyks2

1,076 posts

177 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
ashleyman said:
This sounds like a router / wireless issue, not a broadband issue.

You'll probably be able to solve your issue by buying a better wireless router or some repeaters.
This. Drop-outs on the WiFi network, and its ability to handle the requisite devices, could easily be more down to the router/access-point rather than the broadband itself. I have Plusnet (a subsidiary of BT entirely using BT infrastructure) as provider, but rather than using their (very cheap!) standard supplied router/access-point, have a Draytek (Vigor 2850n I think) which covers the whole 1930s house (and most of the long back garden) and many devices very reliably.

In terms of providers, Zen Internet always seem to get decent customer service write-ups, and I've not personally had any problems with Plusnet. The worst I've ever had was some years ago from NTL, which in 2006 became part of Virgin and was rebranded so.

Crumpet

5,514 posts

211 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
I’ve stuck with Sky as they price matched the cheapest offer I could find.

If you’ve got signal and range issues with the current router I guarantee Sky’s Q hub will be worse. It genuinely struggles to travel 10m in the same room through nothing other than a kitchen island!

Can’t complain about the speed and service though, they’ve always been pretty good.

hairyben

8,516 posts

214 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
I moved it away from sky due them arbitarily deciding to charge me for products I hadn't asked for, had no use for and didn't use.

Won't ever put business BTs way, cable is a nightmare if you ever have an issue requiring customer services, zen were brilliant but are like twice the price now (might pay it if it was a business essential which is their core target market) settled on Vodafone fibre which seems to work.

stuarthat

1,109 posts

249 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
Don’t laugh I left bt infinity ,to expensive and not great reliability ,and tried vodaphone £25 all in seems ok stream films no bother whilst four people using WiFi as well .

eccles

14,416 posts

253 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
I've been with AOL, then TalkTalk since I've had a computer (20 years), and despite the standard replies, I've not had any issue with them.
I'm currently on fibre to the cabinet broadband, with my own router (TP link), there 's usually two of us browsing the internet and streaming Netflix etc at the same time in various parts of a three bedroom fairly modern house with no issues at all.
I pay £34.50 a month for anytime calls and unlimited fibre broadband and it just works, all the time with no issues.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
The only choice here is Virgin, or any of the myriad of Openreach provided such as BT/Sky/Vodafone/etc
If your openreach line is good, all pretty much the same. My line is rubbish, so pay Virgin £40 a month for 200mbps fibre/coax
Great speed / service / wifi for me
No landline, dumped that as only 2 real people ever called me on it !

SCEtoAUX

4,119 posts

112 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
I have John Lewis Broadband, which is just Plusnet repackaged I think. However, the support (very rarely needed) is excellent, and every time my 12 month special offer is up they just roll me on to a different deal. It's like always getting an introductory offer.

Under £28.00/month for landline and unlimited fibre at around 70Mb/s

Weirdly they wanted to upgrade my hardware (Fibre modem and separate Wifi Router) and sent me a new (free) box to replace the two. It didn't work. They sent another one and that didn't work either. So I've stuck with the original hardware and all remains just fine.

stemll

5,665 posts

231 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
Uno Communications

£33 (on BT LLU 12 month contract) or £35 (TTB LLU 1 month contract), drops to £32 if you take a 12 month contract. That's up to 80Mb unmetered no shaping or traffic management. 40Mb is £5 cheaper.

Line rental £10.39 and calls 1.47p with no call set up. We still save money even taking into account not having the included "up to an hour" calls from the old BT package. Things like Caller Display and 1571 are 60p rather than BT £1.75

Been with them a two and a bit years, speed is the same as it was on BT Infinity 2, never had an outage and their support is good and fast (at least it was when I needed them but that was around setup 2 years ago and never needed to use them since).

No affiliation,just a very satisfied customer.

dontfollowme

1,192 posts

264 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
Sky have always had very good uptime for me. I use my own TP Link router with them. They always do a deal at renewal too.

stemll

5,665 posts

231 months

Saturday 4th August 2018
quotequote all
dontfollowme said:
Sky have always had very good uptime for me. I use my own TP Link router with them. They always do a deal at renewal too.
This "always do a deal" is exactly why I left BT. I got fed up with them hiking prices and hoping that, like many, I wouldn't bother to question it. I got bored with the annual charade and ridiculous phone calls and am happy on a monthly plan which has not changed price since May '16 other than a minuscule line rental uplift (40p/m) in response to Openreach increasing their prices. My monthly broadband is unchanged 2 and a bit years on.

They have already said that if line rental costs drop in 2019 as expected then they will pass on that reduction.

Just need an equivalent for TV to save me annual charade with Sky over their increases.

ETA
Tell a lie, calls also went up from 0.9 to 1.45p (again in response to BT Wholesale increases) but that was 2 years ago (BT 13p/m + 22p set up).

Edited by stemll on Saturday 4th August 21:30


Edited by stemll on Saturday 4th August 21:31

dontfollowme

1,192 posts

264 months

Sunday 5th August 2018
quotequote all
The way it goes for me is they usually waive the cost of the line rental so I just pay for the broadband which is approx £20/month. Sometimes they add some credit to the account. I usually get it agreed in one phone call.

Cliftonite

8,754 posts

169 months

Sunday 5th August 2018
quotequote all

Zen.


PF62

4,065 posts

204 months

Sunday 5th August 2018
quotequote all
Sammo123 said:
Due to BT increasing their prices I've got the opportunity to negotiate my deal or change broadband providers.
I have only been with BT a couple of months (joined for £29.99 Infinity 1 with £150 gift card) and just renegotiated with their price rise down to £19.99 staying with Infinity 1 (unlimited including line rental).


Sammo123 said:
We've had BT Infinity for the last few years and while it's been ok it's also had its issues. It drops out quite frequently, struggles to get the wifi signal all the way through the house (a regular sized 1930's ex council house) and can't seem to handle the amount of devices we have connected.
BT Whole Home WiFi solved the problem for me.

jjones

4,493 posts

224 months

Sunday 5th August 2018
quotequote all
Cliftonite said:
Zen.
Excellent, if expensive, first class support and no throttling/limits.

nmd87

839 posts

221 months

Monday 6th August 2018
quotequote all
I was in the same boat but rang up BT and they waived the price increase if I re-contracted. I've been happy with it (except for the poor WiFI from the router) so I went for it.

Mike335i

6,097 posts

133 months

Monday 6th August 2018
quotequote all
If been with BT since Moses was a lad and I have 18 month contracts now. Not as cheap as some, but it is unlimited and about 72mbs speeds, so I'm happy. As for renegotiation, one call every 12-18 months doesn't bother me too much. It's not as bad as car insurance!

We have had 2 instances of no Internet in the last 10 years, neither of which would have been avoided by having a different provider.