will an iMac be better than my current pc (spec listed)?
will an iMac be better than my current pc (spec listed)?
Author
Discussion

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
My current PC is my home office set up to work from home (garden office) - normal office use.

Now starting to edit some drone and go pro stuff on it for youtube, etc and wondering if it's ideal.

Option 1: Get an iMac in the house - means I can work on stuff "out" of the office and iMacs rule for mejia stuff right?

Option 2: Upgrade my office PC with something? The monitor in the office is twin 27" screens - great for work but they are not very expensive.

Budget is £2k (ish)


Current office set up:

Processor (CPU) Intel® Core™i5 Quad Core Processor i5-7600 (3.5GHz) 6MB Cache

Motherboard ASUS® H110M-R: Micro-ATX, DDR4, LG1151, USB 3.0, SATA 6GBs

Memory (RAM) 16GB Corsair VENGEANCE DDR4 2133MHz (2 x 8GB)

Graphics Card 2GB AMD RADEON™ RX 460 - HDMI, DP, DVI - DX® 12

1st Hard Disk 250GB Samsung 850 2.5" EVO SSD, SATA 6Gb/s (upto 540MB/sR | 520MB/sW)

2nd Hard Disk 1TB SEAGATE FIRECUDA 3.5" SSHD - UP TO 5X FASTER THAN HDD!

Power Supply CORSAIR 350W VS SERIES™ VS-350 POWER SUPPLY

Processor Cooling INTEL STANDARD CPU COOLER

Sound Card ONBOARD 6 CHANNEL (5.1) HIGH DEF AUDIO (AS STANDARD)

Operating System Genuine Windows 10 Professional 64 Bit - inc DVD & Licence

mmm-five

12,403 posts

315 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Not sure what you mean as 'out of the office' as the iMac needs mains power supply and is not particularly portable.

Even the iMac I take to clients (an upgraded 2012 model) weighs about 25kg in its bag and is a pain carting it around the tube when I'm working in London. I only use the iMac (which dual boots OSX and Windows 10) as some of my jobs are single day jobs where there's no computer kit available, or what is available doesn't have the software licences, or a 14" VGA screen.

If I had the choice of one operating system only, then I'd be using a W10 all-in-one or micro/NUC box with an i7, decent GPU, 1tb SSD and 32gb RAM.

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
sorry - I just meant out of the office in the sense I could work on fun movie stuff in the house.....not sat in my work office at the end of the garden. I like to keep work/fun separate where i can. I have a perfect spot in my dinning room for a 27" imac!!

alorotom

12,797 posts

218 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
For longevity I would say the Mac is a better investment and will last longer for what you want it to do.

The PC will of course be a better numbers spec £4£

I’d go the Mac route personally, but there again I have a couple of macs and an MBA, iPads, iPhones, etc... and despise W10 on my works laptop so invariably use my MBA and cloud the files

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
I suppose my issue was looking the spec (that i understand!!!) the imac 27" doesnt lok much better than my office rig?

£1700 gets you - 2017 Apple iMac 27" Retina 5K Display, Intel Core i5, 8GB RAM, 1TB Fusion, Radeon Pro 570

Is that much better than what I have?

If it is - I'll buy! But would I be better dropping £1k on a big ass 4K monitor and the rest in more RAM...or whatever...for mine?

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
There's nothing wrong with your current PC that would stop you from editing videos effectively. If you really wanted, you could get a bigger SSD and slap in some more RAM but that's just tinkering round the edges.

In terms of hardware, don't forget that an iMac is effectively a laptop bolted onto a screen with all the compromises that implies. Your PC is likely to be 'better' in terms of raw performance than most.

However, the tone of your email implies that you're really looking for an excuse to buy an iMac. In which case, you absolutely definitely need one. Your PC just won't cut it. Buying an iMac will change your life and make you more attractive to women so stop asking questions and go and get one now.

biggrin

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
But will the iMac be worse than my current set up? I’d be gutted if I got one for all the amazing lifestyle improvements it will bring-and then it took longer to render my videos than the current set up!

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Chances are that an iMac with the spec you posted will be worse than your PC; the CPU clock speed is lower, a Fusion drive isn't the same as an SSD particularly if you have a large amount of volatile data, and the lesser amount of RAM won't help at all. You would need to go for the i7 and up-spec both the storage and the memory to be in with a shout of seeing any meaningful performance increase over your current system.

But as above, any price/performance comparison between a Mac and a Windows PC is never going to look pretty for the Mac.

alorotom

12,797 posts

218 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Tiggsy said:
But will the iMac be worse than my current set up? I’d be gutted if I got one for all the amazing lifestyle improvements it will bring-and then it took longer to render my videos than the current set up!
you cant really draw such direct comparisons based on spec alone as MacOS is tailored for the specs and optomisation - id wager that the mac would perform better for what you want

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
so...just thinking - what do I upgrade on the mac? go to i7? more ram? processor speed?

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
One thing the PC has in it's favour is that you can upgrade parts of it, unlike the iMac.

colonel c

8,059 posts

270 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
If you already have a decent PC and are comfortable with Windows. Why start faffing around with an iMac. Sure they are great if you are into the whole Apple ecosystem or whatever Apple users like to call it.
Splash out on a snazzy new big 4K monitor instead.

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
OK - spoken with the guys that built my PC and they have offered this:

Option 1 - Go spend £2,500 on an imac in the apple store.

or

Option 2- they will fit my existing PC with an i7 8700 cpu, new motherboard to run that - leave the rest alone as it's ok anyway and I then get a 4K dell screen for £1k off Scan - total cost £1500.

They reckon it will beat the iMac for editing (and be a lot cheaper) - I'll keep my twin 27" screens for work and mount the 32" Dell on the opposite wall for video editing when I'm switching to that task.

Bikerjon

2,211 posts

192 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
But you'll still be stuck in the office!

One thing about the iMac is the truly excellent 5k display. I don't know how it compares to the Dell but I've never worked on a PC that has a display as good as my iMac. Even the higher end Ultrasharps look slightly grainy in comparison.

Tiggsy

Original Poster:

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
You arent helping!!!

Alucidnation

16,810 posts

201 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
I would say Mac every time but that upgrade to your existing pc does sound worthwhile.

But as said, apple stuff is optimised to work more efficiently etc, so while it might be a lower spec, it could outperform the pc.


Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Alucidnation said:
I would say Mac every time but that upgrade to your existing pc does sound worthwhile.

But as said, apple stuff is optimised to work more efficiently etc, so while it might be a lower spec, it could outperform the pc.
Benchmarks would seem to disagree

https://www.pugetsystems.com/labs/articles/Premier...

Alucidnation

16,810 posts

201 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Is there a performance test between two similarly priced computers at a more affordable price point?

Phunk

2,102 posts

202 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
I'd go for an iMac, then you can use Final Cut Pro X.

It's super fast and can handle anything you throw at it. My work laptop is a 2013 13" MacBook Pro and it edit's video perfectly well, with no issues.

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Wednesday 29th August 2018
quotequote all
Phunk said:
I'd go for an iMac, then you can use Final Cut Pro X.
This is probably the most important point so far. What software do you want to use, is it available on either platform, and does the OP have the requisite licenses?