Help for a nervous father
Author
Discussion

boyse7en

Original Poster:

8,249 posts

196 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
So my little girl is going to start secondary school next week...

A first mobile phone is on the cards - school don't allow them to be used on site during the day, but advise the kids have them to contact parents in case they leave late/get ill/have a sporting fixture cancelled etc.

So my 11 year old daughter is very excited about getting her hands on her new phone (which I haven't bought yet)

Any advice to share on how best to equip and monitor her usage? She's a sensible kid so I'm not too worried about her having one in some ways, but I'd like to be able to keep an eye on the apps she installs and who she is chatting to in the future.

I'm thinking to buy a cheapish second hand phone (something like a Motorola G5) and then get a sim only contract with Tesco for around £10 a month. Won't have masses of data, but that's a bonus as far as I'm concerned smile

Scabutz

8,927 posts

111 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
My 10 year old daughter just got her first phone. She was desperate for an iPhone so we got her one. On that you can set up her iTunes account as a childs account. So if she wants to install an App or buy anything I have to approve it so I can see what she is installing. Not sure if there is an equivalent on Android.

There is a children's SIM car, forget the name but sure it will come up in google. Partly it sounded good as it uses all the main mobile networks so gives much better coverage, e.g. if she was in an area with O2 coverage but not Vodaphone ti would use the O2. In the same way 999 calls work. It also had safe numbers which they can always call even without credit.

The downsides are that it was very expensive in comparison. Plus it had huge amount of monitoring which I didn't think was great. It record calls and all text message which can read/hear on an online portal. In the end I got a GiffGaff SIM and I can monitor what numbers she is dialing.

We also have set her phone up for her and know the pin. We have said to her that we will check her phone regularly

p1stonhead

30,707 posts

198 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
IOS12 (out soon) possibly saves the day? It has a new section for monitoring and limiting usage.

https://www.apple.com/uk/newsroom/2018/06/ios-12-i...

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
I was in a similar situation about a month ago.

I went with Apple as well but an IPhone SE. Yes it’s small, but the internals are very good and importantly for her, it takes good photos.

For me, it’s got more parental controls than Android baked in (IMHO) and I can also use ‘Find my Friends’ in my iPhone to check where she is.

It was only £170 brand new which is great value for the spec and little 11 year old hands are fine with the smaller screen. It’s also Apple which when you’re 11 is like heroin I guess...

In terms of SIM, I bit the bullet and got a Three contract SIM. Unlimited texting and calling and also lots of data so I don’t get any shocks further down the line. Also parental controls on the Three contract so she can’t access any ‘adult’ sites using her SIM data. It was £13/month with 12GB data a month as I’m also with Three. If you’re a new customer, it would cost £15/month.

Good luck.

okenemem

1,495 posts

225 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
SE a good choice

the only reason I disagree with this choice is that phone may be deemed "uncool" as it resembles the older models

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Get a £20 month contract with insurance (£70) through Tesco mobile. Resign yourself to it getting lost or broken. Make sure she uses a hard shell case and screen protector and tell her if she breaks or loses it, it comes of her birthday/Xmas money. Works for both my kids who are well into their teens.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
okenemem said:
SE a good choice

the only reason I disagree with this choice is that phone may be deemed "uncool" as it resembles the older models
And they are a bit crap. Go for a 6 at least.

p1stonhead

30,707 posts

198 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
wormus said:
okenemem said:
SE a good choice

the only reason I disagree with this choice is that phone may be deemed "uncool" as it resembles the older models
And they are a bit crap. Go for a 6 at least.
SE has 6S intervals. Way faster than a 6. Screen size vs speed.

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Worth pointing out, I think, that any parental control feature showing which numbers have been called is frankly useless unless it includes numbers called through WhatsApp and the like.

I don't think my kids (15,12 & 10) have ever actually used the phone dialer on their phones!

treetops

1,189 posts

189 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Plusnet SIM £7pm

2.5gb data, unlimited texts and free minutes I forget how many.

Bargain deal when we got it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
p1stonhead said:
SE has 6S intervals. Way faster than a 6. Screen size vs speed.
Try watching Netflix or using Insta/Snapchat on one. They are too small for what a teenage kid will use it for and they look ancient. If he only wants her to be able to make calls he should get her a Nokia 6210. She can enjoy playing snake whilst all her fiends laugh at her. The battery lasts ages though! smile

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Does she actually want a smartphone?

Both our kids have no interest, they have iPads, games consoles, PCs but just have a £9.99 boggo phone for school.

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
UpTheIron said:
Does she actually want a smartphone?

Both our kids have no interest, they have iPads, games consoles, PCs but just have a £9.99 boggo phone for school.
That's interesting. How old are they?

Mine and all their friends are very much more into phones. They did have tablets, but they never use them any more. They're too big to fit in a pocket, too impractical if wi-fi only, too expensive with a SIM, and most smartphones these days are large enough for Netflix and the like.

In fact, I'm the only person in the family who still uses a tablet, and that's because I'm often away overseas on business and want something decent for watching downloaded Netflix. I'll have bags with me anyway, so I'm not fussed about the size and weight.

WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
wormus said:
p1stonhead said:
SE has 6S intervals. Way faster than a 6. Screen size vs speed.
Try watching Netflix or using Insta/Snapchat on one. They are too small for what a teenage kid will use it for and they look ancient. If he only wants her to be able to make calls he should get her a Nokia 6210. She can enjoy playing snake whilst all her fiends laugh at her. The battery lasts ages though! smile
SE should be fine for a first phone, very easy to replace broken screens too...

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Kermit power said:
That's interesting. How old are they?
Girl the same age as yours, boy just about to start year 10. He's got an old iPhone that he thought he might want, never used it.

Both seemingly permanently attached to iPads when at home but happy with "feature" phones that they rarely use.

Smartphones have been offered and declined. Apart from that they appear to be perfectly normal :-)

Fallingup

1,749 posts

129 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
You're doomed mate. Just like all parents these days. It's a virus that can't be stopped.

boyse7en

Original Poster:

8,249 posts

196 months

Wednesday 29th August 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for all the help. I'm not sure that an iPhone is ideal (I know they are "only" £170, but that is way more than my phone cost and is way way more than i can afford to pay for something to take to school).

Yes she is keen to get a phone, I'm not sure why really as she's got a Kindle Fire tablet that she see a lot for games but she doesn't do anything else with it. Her friends don't currently have phones either but it seems to be a right of passage that they get one when going to Secondary School.
She won't be using her phone for Netflix as we haven't got it.

At this stage I think that any phone will be cool enough - it doesn't need to be the latest and greatest model.

I want to be able to make sure that any data usage comes as part of her contract, so if she runs out of data/calltime she has to wait rather than me being given an extra bill at the end of the month.

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Wednesday 29th August 2018
quotequote all
Have a look at the cheaper Androids like the Nokia 1 (£70 - small) or Nokia 2/3. Then the Motorolas etc. About £100. Add a gel case and a screen protector. (Amazon/Ebay) Kid's phones get knocked about, sat on, dropped in toilets, smeared in ketchup etc.

As to tariffs: stuff like the Google Store needs to be locked down so apps can't be bought.

Kids use a lot of data, and tend to leave it on all the time for WhatsUpp, SnapperGram, ttter, etc so more data is possibly better than more calls/text allowances.

  • Turn off the mobile data and connect to Wifi when setting the phone up, or leave the sim card out until it's fully updated to avoid monster data costs.
There's a useful guide to parental controls on Android here:

https://www.techadvisor.co.uk/how-to/google-androi...

The other option is a feature phone like the new Nokia 8110 slider, which will have Whatsapp 'real soon'; a smartphone will have more features/apps/ data slurping but shorter battery life.



Edited by Slushbox on Wednesday 29th August 09:27

KrazyIvan

4,341 posts

206 months

Wednesday 29th August 2018
quotequote all
OP I am in the same situation as you, my eldest lad started secondary school today. We got him a phone in the summer so that he wasn't quite as excited to get a new phone on his 1st day. He has a Samsung Galaxy A8, apparently for the lads bigger is better. I have Kaspersky safe kids installed. But we also drew up a contract for his phone, about when he can have it, what happens if he goes over his data minutes, and so on. We discussed each part of the contract, so he was able to give his input and asked questions, when he understood all of it we each signed it. Might sound a little silly but made him feel grown up and made sure we all knew the rules going forward.

A bit like this

https://medium.com/decent-dads/creating-a-teenage-...

Edited by KrazyIvan on Wednesday 29th August 09:39

Scabutz

8,927 posts

111 months

Wednesday 29th August 2018
quotequote all
Kermit power said:
Worth pointing out, I think, that any parental control feature showing which numbers have been called is frankly useless unless it includes numbers called through WhatsApp and the like.

I don't think my kids (15,12 & 10) have ever actually used the phone dialer on their phones!
Yep good point. WhatsApp is encrypted end to end so can't be monitored by any app. Which is why we said to our daughter we would check the phone regularly. I guess though at some point when she is older that will become intrusive and we will have to stop.