Synology - migrating disks after hardware failure
Synology - migrating disks after hardware failure
Author
Discussion

Order66

Original Poster:

6,740 posts

280 months

Friday 31st August 2018
quotequote all
So my just over 3yr old Synology DS415+ has died. The irony of this being my backup soluton to a number of other machines all of which are still happily running is not lost on me.

A little googling would suggest this is a well-known and common Intel Atom fault/failure, and regardless it being a design flaw it will seem I'm on the hook for the bill (I possibly could have a long argument with the retailer under consumer rights laws about being fit for purpose, but that doesn't get my data back this week).

So, the question. Given there is no issue with the disks, can I simply buy a newer Synology unit (say the DS 918+), stick the disks in and it all magics itself back into business? Or indeed, could I do the same with a competitors offering (which given the short lifespan of this unit I wouldn't mind voting with my cash and going somewhere else).

At the end of the day, the quickest way to resume service is important, and if it means grudgingly handing cash to synology to get going I'll do it (while putting them on my st list for future planned upgrades)


mikef

6,158 posts

282 months

Saturday 1st September 2018
quotequote all
Bummer

It looks as though Synology did extend their standard two-year warranty for consumer products to three years ( link), in response to this CPU issue

Did you manage to report the fault within three years, or had it gone over?

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Saturday 1st September 2018
quotequote all
I would re-evaluate whether you actually need a 4 disk NAS. Two 2 disk boxes would give you redundancy of all hardware. They can be configured to sync with each other, either live for ultimate hardware protection, or weekly/monthly for corruption/user-error protection.

I personally run a single NAS with external USB disks, that can be read directly via any other computer.

mikef

6,158 posts

282 months

Saturday 1st September 2018
quotequote all
My 2c on that - after advice on this forum, I invested in a DS415play in RAID 10. I've had one WD red disk go bad and it took the best part of day to rebuild an 8TB disk. If that had been a two drive unit I'd have been bricking it during that rebuild.

Order66

Original Poster:

6,740 posts

280 months

Saturday 1st September 2018
quotequote all
alock said:
I would re-evaluate whether you actually need a 4 disk NAS. Two 2 disk boxes would give you redundancy of all hardware. They can be configured to sync with each other, either live for ultimate hardware protection, or weekly/monthly for corruption/user-error protection.

I personally run a single NAS with external USB disks, that can be read directly via any other computer.
I couldn't disagree more. With a 2-disk setup one of the disks can fail while no-one is around to fix it (like holiday/weekends) and for some stuff we would be dependent on that single remaining disk until we can order up and physically have a new drive inserted, this would leave us very exposed - not good enough.

So back to the actual question - can I take the 4 disks and simply stick them in a new host unit?

Order66

Original Poster:

6,740 posts

280 months

Saturday 1st September 2018
quotequote all
mikef said:
Bummer

It looks as though Synology did extend their standard two-year warranty for consumer products to three years ( link), in response to this CPU issue

Did you manage to report the fault within three years, or had it gone over?
About 3yrs 4mnths. Synology have so far told us to get bent, however its an ongoing discussion.

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Saturday 1st September 2018
quotequote all
Order66 said:
I couldn't disagree more. With a 2-disk setup one of the disks can fail while no-one is around to fix it (like holiday/weekends) and for some stuff we would be dependent on that single remaining disk until we can order up and physically have a new drive inserted, this would leave us very exposed - not good enough.

So back to the actual question - can I take the 4 disks and simply stick them in a new host unit?
I must be missing something. Your current architecture has failed in a way that you yourself has said would leave you very exposed if it happened again, and you want to do it again in the same way? My suggestion would involve you switching to a different URL to connect directly to the second Nas if this scenario happens again.

I've had 3 raids completely fail over the last 15 years. Once was due to simultaneous disk failures so data was lost, the other 2 times were due to the raid card failing. In both these cases I failed to remount the data on new raid cards. Both times I had to start again and restore from backup.

Murph7355

42,097 posts

287 months

Saturday 1st September 2018
quotequote all
Order66 said:
So my just over 3yr old Synology DS415+ has died. The irony of this being my backup soluton to a number of other machines all of which are still happily running is not lost on me.

A little googling would suggest this is a well-known and common Intel Atom fault/failure, and regardless it being a design flaw it will seem I'm on the hook for the bill (I possibly could have a long argument with the retailer under consumer rights laws about being fit for purpose, but that doesn't get my data back this week).

So, the question. Given there is no issue with the disks, can I simply buy a newer Synology unit (say the DS 918+), stick the disks in and it all magics itself back into business? Or indeed, could I do the same with a competitors offering (which given the short lifespan of this unit I wouldn't mind voting with my cash and going somewhere else).

At the end of the day, the quickest way to resume service is important, and if it means grudgingly handing cash to synology to get going I'll do it (while putting them on my st list for future planned upgrades)
You need to check with Synology.

I run ReadyNAS units at home. Had some old ones (>12yrs) that failed but the ReadyNAS architecture changed at a point in time that meant straight disk swaps were not possible.

I bought an old diskless chassis off eBay, spun the disks up, copied the data off, put a new unit in place and then copied the data over etc. I intend to flog the eBay one and will recover most/all/more than I paid I'm sure.

I tend to copy really important stuff to 2x separate units by way of backup, in part to give access to versioned files in the event that a backup unit fails (which it obviously can do).

Order66

Original Poster:

6,740 posts

280 months

Saturday 1st September 2018
quotequote all
alock said:
I must be missing something. Your current architecture has failed in a way that you yourself has said would leave you very exposed if it happened again, and you want to do it again in the same way? My suggestion would involve you switching to a different URL to connect directly to the second Nas if this scenario happens again.

I've had 3 raids completely fail over the last 15 years. Once was due to simultaneous disk failures so data was lost, the other 2 times were due to the raid card failing. In both these cases I failed to remount the data on new raid cards. Both times I had to start again and restore from backup.
Sorry, I missed the "two" in your original post. Still not convinced by it, as I'd now have to manage and ensure the "sync" is working properly, otherwise its effectively a single 2-disk solution which wouldn't be acceptable. So while it perhaps reduces risk of the NAS failing, it has its own alternative issues which I don't see as an advantage. In theory these NAS units should be fairly reliable (more than 3 fking years anyway) and prefer the simplicity of a single box.