Current Smartphone options
Author
Discussion

Lazadude

Original Poster:

1,740 posts

192 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
My current android (LG G5) has decided to brick itself overnight. Was working all day, then random reboot and an error that it "May be corrupt and cannot be trusted". Now it wont turn on / recovery boot etc.

I haven't been following the smartphone market, whats the current go to? I don't want an apple, happy to stay in the Android sphere..

Current leader still Samsung? S9/Note 9?

Lord Pikey

3,258 posts

246 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
I just got a Huawei P20 Pro.


Fantastic camera and it doesnt have the horrible Samsung UI (imo)

Iv had it 3 days now and cannot fault it

rednotdead

1,259 posts

257 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
Had a moto G6 for a month or so now - great phone for the price.

nmd87

839 posts

221 months

Tuesday 4th September 2018
quotequote all
Pixel 2 is fantastic. Fast and superb camera. I've taken some great shots on it.

My wife broke her iPhone so I gave her the Pixel 2 and I now have a Moto G6. Only got it today but seems good so far as a slightly cheaper option. Camera is worse than the Pixel 2 though.

Lazadude

Original Poster:

1,740 posts

192 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
Been reading overnight, and the Pixel 3 should be released in about a month.

Borrowed an old S6-edge until I get my phone sorted, I think I'm going to need a 3.5mm jack which is discounting lots of phones.

Are modern Samsungs as bad as this S6 with bloatware? Literally full of crap I don't want pre installed even after a factory reset.

HTP99

25,449 posts

171 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
Love my S9+, sure Samsung have their take on Android but it's far lighter and less intrusive than Samsungs of old; funny as someone mentioned the bloatware on Samsungs and their P20 Pro is far better for it, however many of the reviews criticise Huawei's version of Android.

If you want a high end phone and the 3.5mm jack then it'll have to be a Samsung

Both of my daughters have recently moved over from Apple to the Sumsung S+ series of phones.

Just had a thought, the Nokia's get decent reviews and I'm pretty sure they are almost stock Android too, plus they all have the headphone jack aswell.

Edited by HTP99 on Wednesday 5th September 07:39

Lord Pikey

3,258 posts

246 months

Wednesday 5th September 2018
quotequote all
HTP99 said:
Love my S9+, sure Samsung have their take on Android but it's far lighter and less intrusive than Samsungs of old; funny as someone mentioned the bloatware on Samsungs and their P20 Pro is far better for it, however many of the reviews criticise Huawei's version of Android.

Edited by HTP99 on Wednesday 5th September 07:39
That was me. Ill be honest and my opinion of Samsungs UI is probably a few years out of date. My phone history over the last 3 years has been pretty close to stock android as i could get. I had a oneplus one, Sony X5 then a Xioami Mi 5s. Eventually they all had cyanagen mod (now lineage) installed as the original roms were slowing down and not updated.

Iv had the P20 only a few days and there is nothing about the stock UI that really bugs me, and thats about as high a praise as i can give to anything thats not pure google. However i will say that the apps that come pre installed are more than i would like. Its annoying to have two instances of Calendar, Email, Calculator etc.

I should probably give Samsung a second chance when i change my phone next time.

5150

760 posts

286 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
I’ll second the Samsung downsides. Have an S7 Edge, and while it’s a decent phone, I won’t be going back again.

Certainly staying on Android tho, and the Pixel 3 is most definitely on the wish list, come October.

A friend has a Pixel 2, he said it’s the best phone he’s ever had, and the 2 gets rave reviews about its camera.....

nmd87

839 posts

221 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
5150 said:
I’ll second the Samsung downsides. Have an S7 Edge, and while it’s a decent phone, I won’t be going back again.

Certainly staying on Android tho, and the Pixel 3 is most definitely on the wish list, come October.

A friend has a Pixel 2, he said it’s the best phone he’s ever had, and the 2 gets rave reviews about its camera.....
I'd definitely agree with that. Got some fantastic shots on mine. I've decided the best way to convert my wife from iPhone is to give her the Pixel 2.

Having said that, the Moto G6 I'm now using is an excellent phone considering the RRP is less than half that of a Pixel 2. If you're not as precious about camera quality, you'll be amazed with what £200 can buy these days.

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
The problem I have had in the past with Moto G and other cheaper phones is there longevity. They seem to slow down or brick themselves after a year or so. My last G4 plus had some weird bug with a "ghost touch" phenomenon where it bought 74 bluetooth car adapters of ebay for me whilst in my pocket.

Anyway, I recently decided to have a go with a more premium device on a contract rather than own phone on sim only. Got a Huwei P20; I was very wary about anything other than stock android but it's absolutely not an issue once you get acclimatised. Even the P20 takes stunning photos, it's just the right size for your pocket and is just a lovely thing to own and use.

Carphone warehouse seem to be the cheapest place if you are up for getting a new contract btw.

Tuna

19,930 posts

315 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
I've got on relatively well with the Moto G series - a pragmatic phone, but you can't load it up with too much stuff. Dual sim is handy. Sensible size too.

Just switched to a P20 Lite and after a couple of months, really like it. All the modern features, a great screen, speedy and a decent camera (even if it's not the greatest of the greatest - it's still damn good). Can't see the point in paying the ridiculous price premium of a flagship model when you can get a decent phone like that for half the price.

TameRacingDriver

20,663 posts

303 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
Samsung phones are always full of bloatware and that hasn't changed with the latest models. Sure they run well enough but after a while they will start to 'rot' under the weight of updates, bloat and whatnot. Very predictable.

My pixel 2 xl is not perfect but the overall speed and leanness of the device is in another league to a Samsung. However its wrong of me to single out Samsung for this, most manufacturers have the same problems. LG, HTC, Huawei, etc all have heavy skins and lots of bloatware.

Motorola, OnePlus and Sony all make a fair fist of a lighter take on android so you might want to check them out.

I was one originally against wireless headphones but I've now replaced all my headphones with wireless ones. They're fine although having to keep them charged is a bit of a pain, especially the ear buds, although my b&w's are pretty good they only need charging about once a week. Dare I say it, I actually like being free of wires.

Foliage

3,861 posts

153 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all

Mr-B

5,146 posts

225 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
Had a Oneplus 5 since launch in June 2017, still as fast as the day I got it, no bloatware, stock android, camera, meh (despite all their pre launch hype of dual cameras) so overall I'd say worth looking at them unless you absolutely must have a great camera phone.

skinnyman

1,910 posts

124 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
The Samsung Android 'skin' is alot less intrusive than it used to be, but they still come with alot of bloatware crap than you don't want. Their own versions of existing android apps, that you just don't want/need. Their own mobile pay system, app store etc. Even the VR side, it runs on Oculus, but Samsung also have their own VR software, god knows why.

If you look outside the usual suspects though, there's alot of "flagship killers" being released by the Chinese companies for very reasonable money.

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
A friend has a Blackview 9000 and swears by it - I can't tear myself away from Apple at the moment as it's working, but seeing the prices is making me consider an alternative.

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Thursday 6th September 2018
quotequote all
Foliage said:
That looks excellent.

The Xiaomia A2 is similarly decent for the cash (ace camera). But.....neither seem to have NFC???

I'm a google pay fanboi so that's a deal breaker for me.

Lazadude

Original Poster:

1,740 posts

192 months

Friday 7th September 2018
quotequote all
Thanks, Think my current plan is to wait until Pixel 3 and the OP6T are released in the next month or so and make the choice from there.

Currently using an old S6 edge, and a couple of the preloaded stuff is already driving me nuts.

Funk

27,820 posts

240 months

Friday 7th September 2018
quotequote all
Pixel 2 XL user here, best phone I've ever had. Keen to see what they do with the 3 and might trade up.

I'm firmly of the opinion that you can't beat stock Android for speed and clean looks, plus the importance of timely security updates shouldn't be overlooked. This should get better as Google split out the security updates and push them themselves rather than relying on manufacturers (who don't have any real incentive to update old or legacy kit; they just want to sell new ones rather than extend the features/life of your old one).

TameRacingDriver

20,663 posts

303 months

Friday 7th September 2018
quotequote all
Funk said:
Pixel 2 XL user here, best phone I've ever had. Keen to see what they do with the 3 and might trade up.
I honestly wouldn't bother. I also own a 2xl but the 3 appears to have little in the way of improvements. Processor is only marginally faster, camera very similar, same RAM etc. And more critically, MUCH uglier. Really doesn't seem worth forking out however much (it will be a lot) for such small improvements and for a munter of a phone at that.

If I was gonna go pixel 3 I'd go for the standard model this time around.