New monitor. QHD, 4K, Ultrawide?
New monitor. QHD, 4K, Ultrawide?
Author
Discussion

AlexC1981

Original Poster:

5,861 posts

248 months

Saturday 8th September 2018
quotequote all
Hi All,

Having given away my 27" 1080p monitor I'm currently using a 32" 1080p TV as a monitor to play games on. I'm starting to realise that it's less than ideal, mainly because it's too reflective and possibly just too big.

I'm using a GTX 970 at the moment, but I will be upgrading this in a couple of months after the new graphics cards come out from Nvidea and the prices have stabilized. What I get won't be anything slower than what a GTX 1080 benchmarks at now.

There's a few things I just can't decide on. Should I get a regular 27" monitor or should I go for 35" ultrawide? Do you get a better gaming experience from ultrawide? I mostly play 1st person perspective Skyrim type games because I like the immersion that 1st person perspective brings. Is ultrawide too letterbox like? Real life vision if you look straight ahead is closer to widescreen.

Is 4K worth it over quad HD (2560 x 1440)? I think I would rather have better frame rates than the higher resolution. If I keep the new monitor and whatever new card I get for the next few years, the lower resolution of quad HD would be a benefit as I will still be able to play future games on ultra settings.

Are older 1080p games going to look better on a quad HD monitor than a 4K monitor because there is less scaling involved? Or is it the otherway around because 1080 to 4K is a whole number x4 increase?

Would I miss G-sync if I get a cheaper Freesync monitor and end up with an Nvidia card (or vice versa)? I can't say at this time what brand GPU I will end up with. Is G-sync or Freesync something I should even worry about?

Recommendations would be appreciated!

Thanks.

AlexC1981

Original Poster:

5,861 posts

248 months

Sunday 9th September 2018
quotequote all
Hey, I thought you clever lot would be all over this smile

One thing aspect I forgot to mention is, is it worth getting something beyond the normal 60Hz refresh rate? I always thought no as most games run under 60FPS on my hardwear anyway, but some people say they can really notice the difference. 144Hz seems to be most common after 60 Hz, though 75, 100, 120, 165, 170 and 200Hz monitors are also available.

My thoughts are that if an Oculus Rift or Vive needs to run at 90Hz to run smoothly to provide an acceptable VR experience, then 90Hz should also be ideal for a monitor.

I'm starting to think I'm better off chasing higher frame rates/Hz on high game graphics settings rather than ultimate resolution, so Quad HD on a 100Hz+ 27" monitor would be the way to go, ideally with G-sync as I'll probably end up with an Nvidea card again.

Are IPS screens better than TN panels still, or doesn't it matter as long as the monitor gets good reviews? Also, I'm thinking a curved screen would be better for 30"+ or ultrawide, but not 27".

So much to think about when buying a monitor these days. wobble

AlexC1981

Original Poster:

5,861 posts

248 months

Sunday 9th September 2018
quotequote all
So, I think it's pretty much comes down to these three. Is the ultrawide screen worth it? And if so, is the extra £100 worth it for G-sync over Free Sync? (G-sync only works with Nvidea cards and Free sync only with Radion cards) I think it probably is considering I will almost certainly buy an Nvidia card.

£500 to £840 is quite a jump though....and I don't know for sure if it will make for a better gaming experience anyway, especially as more processing power will be needed for the extra 33% pixels, which might reduce my FPS. I think I need to see some ultra wide monitors in operation.

£840 QHD 3440 x 1440 35" ultrawide, curved, 100Hz G-sync. Acer Predator Z35P

£740 QHD 3440 x 1440 35" ultrawide, curved, 100Hz Free Sync. Asus - ROG Strix XG35VQ

£500 QHD 2560 x 1440 27" regular widescreen, flat, 165Hz G-sync. Acer Predator XB271HU



AlexC1981

Original Poster:

5,861 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
Just a bump (sorry) for the lunchtime IT crowd. spin

techguyone

3,137 posts

173 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
you're doing a great job of discussing it by yourself OP biggrin

Is the rest of your set up capable of using all these features a ultra 4k mc spiffy monitor brings?

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
4k is worth it in bigger sizes IMO. Currently use a 40" 4k TV and I love it, would even go a tad bigger next time around. It's like a 34" ultrawide in width but with some extra height to it too. Amazon's deal today is for a 43" Sony that would be perfect, particularly as Sony are flicker-free including at lower brightness.

For mainly gaming use though I'd probably go for a 27" 1440p. Driving 4k properly seems like a huge step up in GPU performance required for not a lot of benefit.

MissChief

8,022 posts

199 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
So your main issue will be that while a 970 will drive a QHD 3440x1440p Ultrawide monitor, it won't do so very well. Sure stuff like Skyrim (without a dozen high-res texture modes!) will ruin OK and G-Sync will help smooth out the framerates, you'll struggle to take advantage of the higher refresh rates available on the monitor, especially with anything remotely graphically demanding like the latest Tomb Raider, Battlefield V or Cyberpunk when it comes out late next year (Personal estimate!).

So if you go for the high res Ultrawide you're really going to have to think about a graphics card upgrade if you plan to game on new titles. Personally I love Ultrawide and have a 29" LG 2560x1080 run by a GTX 1080 and it works very well indeed.

Screen size there's not a lot in it for your TV to 35" Ultrawide: http://www.displaywars.com/32-inch-16x9-vs-35-inch... But in resolution it's a massive difference. A 1080p monitor has 2,073,600 pixels to be pushed. A '4k' Ultrawide has 4,953,600 pixels, more than double.

Have you considered a 35" 2560x1080? While the PPI isn't as high as the 1440p it still looks amazing and isn't a huge difference over the 1080p pixel wise, only 2,764,800. Your 970 should run very well and the size difference is the same as above.

Edited by MissChief on Tuesday 11th September 12:43

AlexC1981

Original Poster:

5,861 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
Yay I got replies hehe

I've ruled out 4K now. Future games are just going to get more and more detailed on ultra settings and I would rather play the future games on ultra settings at 1440p than medium settings at 4K. I want a monitor to last 5 years minimum, maybe even 10 years, so I want something better than 1080p to futureproof it. The monitor will probably get 10 hours per week usage so it should last me a couple of graphics card upgrades over the years.

The GTX 970 will go soon, so it will only need to drive the new monitor for a couple of months. The new card will be at least as good as a GTX 1080. It might even be a GTX 1080, it all depends on pricing when the new cards come out and how well the new cards benchmark against the old ones. I'll probably spend £500-£600 on the card, which with price drops owing to the new cards coming out, that might even put me in GTX 1080 Ti performance territory.

If the GTX 1080 or equivalent can't run current games on ultra settings on a 1440p screen, that would be a disaster!

With my 32" TV I have pushed it further back on the table as it feels more comfortable that way. In terms of immersion it would not be any different to a 27" closer up, so I'm not worried about going back down to 27". I think a 32" set further back is better for your eyes though.

So 27" widescreen vs 35" ultrawide.......seems the general consensus is that the ultrawide is a better playing experience?


MissChief

8,022 posts

199 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
AlexC1981 said:
Yay I got replies hehe

I've ruled out 4K now. Future games are just going to get more and more detailed on ultra settings and I would rather play the future games on ultra settings at 1440p than medium settings at 4K. I want a monitor to last 5 years minimum, maybe even 10 years, so I want something better than 1080p to futureproof it. The monitor will probably get 10 hours per week usage so it should last me a couple of graphics card upgrades over the years.

The GTX 970 will go soon, so it will only need to drive the new monitor for a couple of months. The new card will be at least as good as a GTX 1080. It might even be a GTX 1080, it all depends on pricing when the new cards come out and how well the new cards benchmark against the old ones. I'll probably spend £500-£600 on the card, which with price drops owing to the new cards coming out, that might even put me in GTX 1080 Ti performance territory.

If the GTX 1080 or equivalent can't run current games on ultra settings on a 1440p screen, that would be a disaster!

With my 32" TV I have pushed it further back on the table as it feels more comfortable that way. In terms of immersion it would not be any different to a 27" closer up, so I'm not worried about going back down to 27". I think a 32" set further back is better for your eyes though.

So 27" widescreen vs 35" ultrawide.......seems the general consensus is that the ultrawide is a better playing experience?
£600 will get you a GTX1080ti if you can buy/order now. It's reckoned that stock will start to wind down towards the end of the year and could even drive the price up once the shortage becomes acute so you may not get a new one for that amount any time soon.

Regarding Ultrawide, I LOVE mine and couldn't ever see myself going back to a 16:9 monitor. There are the occasional Ultrawide issues with some games, generally from devs and publishers that don't particularly care for the PC market such as Capcom. Anything AAA from Ubisoft or EA for example will support it very well with little tweaking required. The Division even had options to move the HUD icons out to the corners of the screen.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
I have a 34" ultrawide and I cannot imagine going back to a normal monitor. It runs everything with all or most options ticked, using a 1080 GTX. The extra field of view enhances games enormously.

AlexC1981

Original Poster:

5,861 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
Looks like ultrawide will be the one to go for.

There's a video here of a guy playing the game I am playing at the moment and he's using a 1440 ultrawide monitor on a GTX 1080Ti.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2rNwz0opW-I

His FPS are between 50-70, which is quite disappointing really. I'd expect the 1080Ti to sit somewhere between the new RTX 2070 and RTX 2080 performancewise. It looks like the RTX 2070 will be priced £570 and the RTX 2080 at £750, so I think i'll just wait and see for the benchmarks and final pricing before I upgrade my card.

I'm not liking this budget creep. I'm looking at £840 for the monitor and maybe £700 or so for the card. I suppose at least the monitor could last 10 years.....

Baron Greenback

7,862 posts

181 months

Tuesday 11th September 2018
quotequote all
Been struggling fending off buying ultrawide but waiting for HDR tech to catch up. The whole nvidia and amd freesync/Gsync drive me nuts! There are a few things you can do to get nvidia working on freesync monitor but they will be patched by nvidia to stop that! 4K tru HDR hardware cost atleast £250 ontop of monitor price as well as the price of more expensive gpu so monitor/gpu combo is a pricey decision and you are stuck with it.

https://www.144hzmonitors.com/
"Monitor list" and "Best Gaming Monitor" is worth a read!

https://www.monitornerds.com/
Is another site I ponder over also!

I am not a FPS gamer so I want better colour and brightness and atleast HDR600 and 4ms GTG at 3440x1440res! For that its new tech and atleast £1k+ so I am waiting a bit!

judas

6,251 posts

290 months

Wednesday 12th September 2018
quotequote all
Zod said:
I have a 34" ultrawide and I cannot imagine going back to a normal monitor. It runs everything with all or most options ticked, using a 1080 GTX. The extra field of view enhances games enormously.
This. I have an Acer Predator X34/GTX 1080 combo and it's just brilliant. The only thing I'm not 100% on is the premium for the curve. It's nice, but not wholly convinced it was worth the extra cost.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Wednesday 12th September 2018
quotequote all
judas said:
Zod said:
I have a 34" ultrawide and I cannot imagine going back to a normal monitor. It runs everything with all or most options ticked, using a 1080 GTX. The extra field of view enhances games enormously.
This. I have an Acer Predator X34/GTX 1080 combo and it's just brilliant. The only thing I'm not 100% on is the premium for the curve. It's nice, but not wholly convinced it was worth the extra cost.
I see absolutely no point to curved TVs, but I have to say that I find the curve on a computer monitor helps. It keeps the edges in your periphery. I was playing Doom last night and I just felt I could see demons moving at the edge of the screen.

judas

6,251 posts

290 months

Wednesday 12th September 2018
quotequote all
Zod said:
I see absolutely no point to curved TVs, but I have to say that I find the curve on a computer monitor helps. It keeps the edges in your periphery. I was playing Doom last night and I just felt I could see demons moving at the edge of the screen.
It does increase your immersion a fair old bit, but I think the curve on the X34 is a little too shallow.