How can I extend my wifi in this scenario
How can I extend my wifi in this scenario
Author
Discussion

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,798 posts

224 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
I've got a BT router with two plug in extensions around the house. They all seem to work reasonably well, but I have an out building that I'd like the signal to reach. The problem is the house walls are 2ft thick stone and the signal doesn't get very far through it. I can't relocate the router as it's near the phone socket and don't want to compromise the signal within the house as there are stone walls internally too and it's easy to lose the signal strength when moving the router about. So I'm wondering whether there's a gadget that plugs into the router via an ADSL lead that can be situated nearer the outbuilding but within the house still. i.e in the loft which then negates stone wall issues. I could get power to it via a lighting circuit which is bound to be more than suitable for a gadget like this if it exists, but I can't hook up to a ring for sockets such as the ones that my wifi extenders are plugged into.

Anyone have any ideas? Cheers

mizx

1,586 posts

216 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
If I'm following right - Get a second router to act as a slave connected to the master, set up the wifi with exactly the same SSID and password, set it to use the master router for DHCP, job jobbed. https://www.techadvisor.co.uk/how-to/network-wifi/...

I had a similar scenario with a new outbuilding, no thick walls, just very low or no wifi signal. I looked into lots of different range extenders, including those that can connect to a master router by cable, and things like the Devolo Gigagate, but the easiest and cheaper way is just to use a slave router. it's doing essentially the same thing. I have cat5 running from a faceplate by my VDSL router, to another faceplate in the outbuilding.

Edited by mizx on Sunday 23 September 13:44

Penelope Stopit

11,209 posts

140 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
Can you not hard wire from the router to the out-building?

thebraketester

15,852 posts

169 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
How far away is the outbuilding?

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,798 posts

224 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
mizx said:
If I'm following right - Get a second router to act as a slave connected to the master, set up the wifi with exactly the same SSID and password, set it to use the master router for DHCP, job jobbed. https://www.techadvisor.co.uk/how-to/network-wifi/...

I had a similar scenario with a new outbuilding, no thick walls, just very low or no wifi signal. I looked into lots of different range extenders, including those that can connect to a master router by cable, and things like the Devolo Gigagate, but the easiest and cheaper way is just to use a slave router. it's doing essentially the same thing. I have cat5 running from a faceplate by my VDSL router, to another faceplate in the outbuilding.

Edited by mizx on Sunday 23 September 13:44
This sounds promising. I'm useless with tech so don't always understand the terminology, but will have a read through of the website suggested.
The outbuilding is only about 6ft from the house so I expect the signal would be fine, but a hard wire set up would be a nuisance to run.

NDA

25,840 posts

256 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
Does your outbuilding work off the same fusebox as the main house?

If it does, use home plugs. Easy and very reliable.

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,798 posts

224 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
NDA said:
Does your outbuilding work off the same fusebox as the main house?

If it does, use home plugs. Easy and very reliable.
Sadly not.

NDA

25,840 posts

256 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
Dang.

Is it a PC or regular laptop that you want to work out there - or 'everyone'?

The reason I ask is that a few years ago when I ran PC's (now Apple), I used a Yagi Aerial. Brilliant - super strong signal and super fast.... but they don't work with Apple stuff.

If it's a regular PC or laptop, then you could try this route. If it's iPhones and any device, then this won't work either.

I know others have asked, but could you run a cable out there? A data cable would not be too tricky and then you can have so many more options.

Bikerjon

2,211 posts

192 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
bernhund said:
The outbuilding is only about 6ft from the house so I expect the signal would be fine, but a hard wire set up would be a nuisance to run.
6ft? Does it have a window that faces the house? If it does then you might be able to setup a wifi point in the house and another in the outbuilding and bridge wirelessly without running cable.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
Adding a second router and using it as a wifi repeater is extremely easy and very effective. I've just added another. Some products actually make it easier for you:

i.e. TP Link N450 Cable Router £25

The handy thing about the TP link, is when setting it up you can select it's "mode" as "wifi router only". This does a lto of what I'm about to type below for you (including disabling DHCP server).

Anyhow, lets assume you have a new wifi router that doesn't have the option above,

1) Plug your new router into a PC or laptop directly with a network cable.

2) Manually set the IP address of your PC/Laptop to be on the same net as the router (this will be in the router setup sheet). So, for example, TPLink routers default to 192.168.0.1 - so in your computer network settings for your LAN / Ethernet adapter, set the IP address manually as 192.168.0.somthingotherthan1 - i.e. 192.168.0.99. Subnet mask = 255.255.255.0, default gateway = 192.168.0.1 (not always needed).

TIP: You are configuring TCP/IP v4. Ignore TCP/IP v6

3) Now you have set your laptop on the same network as your new router, so you can access it by going into a web browser and typing 192.168.0.1 in the address bar. You can now configure your new router through it's web interface.

NOTE: You can avoid a lot of the above by just plugging your computer into the router with a lan cable and letting the DCHP server in your router give your PC an IP address that is on the same network . I have spelt it out because it is good to know how to force your computer onto a network if you mess things up. I always do it manually. Old habit. NOTE: if doing this on a laptop you'll need to switch the wifi off / disable it, or your laptop won't know which network to join.

4) In your new routers settings:
- Ignore the ADSL / Cable setup - all irrelivent
- Go into "DHCP" settings and disable DHCP SERVER- this is VITAL - this stops your new router handing out IP address. You don't want this, it will cause chaos. Your existing router will do that for you.
- Go into wifi and give your new network exactly the same ID as your existing one (if you want seamless transition from one router to another). This is case sensitive. Give it exactly the same password too.

TIP: If you are confident enough, give your new router a fixed IP address - this might involve reserving one on your old router, or looking at the DHCP table on the old router and seeing which addresses are free/excluded. This just makes it easier to access your new router once on your existing network as you'll know it's IP address. NOTE2: If the address you give it is on a different subnet - i.e your existing network is on 192.168.99.x (more likely 192.168.1.x but the "99" should draw your eye to the difference more easily!) - the moment you click "save changes" you will lose access to the web interface until the next step.

5) Now plug your new router into your existing router's LAN port (not WAN) with a cable

Done!

What will now happen is your new router will get an IP address from the old router, join your existing network, and happily repeat your wifi network.

If you want to configure your new router some more (and you surely will) then you'll need to know what IP address it was given (if you didn't give it a fixed one) - you can find this by looking in the DHCP table on your existing router.

If this all sounds tricky, the router I suggested does nearly all fo this for you when you select "Wifi repeater mode" - it switces off its internal DHCP Server, the ADSL interface, and any other irrelivent options.

The key to all this is understanding that you will need to be on the same subnet (that's the 192.168.X. part - the third number) as the router to configure it, and that means you need to be plugged directly into it to set it up.

If you plug a new router into your existing lan without doing this, it will either be invisible to you, or , if it's on the same subnet, it will start conflicting with your existing router.


Edited by anonymous-user on Sunday 23 September 18:55

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,798 posts

224 months

Sunday 23rd September 2018
quotequote all
RogerDodger said:
Adding a second router and using it as a wifi repeater is extremely easy and very effective. I've just added another. Some products actually make it easier for you:

i.e. TP Link N450 Cable Router £25

The handy thing about the TP link, is when setting it up you can select it's "mode" as "wifi router only". This does a lto of what I'm about to type below for you (including disabling DHCP server).

Anyhow, lets assume you have a new wifi router that doesn't have the option above,

1) Plug your new router into a PC or laptop directly with a network cable.

2) Manually set the IP address of your PC/Laptop to be on the same net as the router (this will be in the router setup sheet). So, for example, TPLink routers default to 192.168.0.1 - so in your computer network settings for your LAN / Ethernet adapter, set the IP address manually as 192.168.0.somthingotherthan1 - i.e. 192.168.0.99. Subnet mask = 255.255.255.0, default gateway = 192.168.0.1 (not always needed).

TIP: You are configuring TCP/IP v4. Ignore TCP/IP v6

3) Now you have set your laptop on the same network as your new router, so you can access it by going into a web browser and typing 192.168.0.1 in the address bar. You can now configure your new router through it's web interface.

NOTE: You can avoid a lot of the above by just plugging your computer into the router with a lan cable and letting the DCHP server in your router give your PC an IP address that is on the same network . I have spelt it out because it is good to know how to force your computer onto a network if you mess things up. I always do it manually. Old habit. NOTE: if doing this on a laptop you'll need to switch the wifi off / disable it, or your laptop won't know which network to join.

4) In your new routers settings:
- Ignore the ADSL / Cable setup - all irrelivent
- Go into "DHCP" settings and disable DHCP SERVER- this is VITAL - this stops your new router handing out IP address. You don't want this, it will cause chaos. Your existing router will do that for you.
- Go into wifi and give your new network exactly the same ID as your existing one (if you want seamless transition from one router to another). This is case sensitive. Give it exactly the same password too.

TIP: If you are confident enough, give your new router a fixed IP address - this might involve reserving one on your old router, or looking at the DHCP table on the old router and seeing which addresses are free/excluded. This just makes it easier to access your new router once on your existing network as you'll know it's IP address. NOTE2: If the address you give it is on a different subnet - i.e your existing network is on 192.168.99.x (more likely 192.168.1.x but the "99" should draw your eye to the difference more easily!) - the moment you click "save changes" you will lose access to the web interface until the next step.

5) Now plug your new router into your existing router's LAN port (not WAN) with a cable

Done!

What will now happen is your new router will get an IP address from the old router, join your existing network, and happily repeat your wifi network.

If you want to configure your new router some more (and you surely will) then you'll need to know what IP address it was given (if you didn't give it a fixed one) - you can find this by looking in the DHCP table on your existing router.

If this all sounds tricky, the router I suggested does nearly all fo this for you when you select "Wifi repeater mode" - it switces off its internal DHCP Server, the ADSL interface, and any other irrelivent options.

The key to all this is understanding that you will need to be on the same subnet (that's the 192.168.X. part - the third number) as the router to configure it, and that means you need to be plugged directly into it to set it up.

If you plug a new router into your existing lan without doing this, it will either be invisible to you, or , if it's on the same subnet, it will start conflicting with your existing router.


Edited by RogerDodger on Sunday 23 September 18:55
Now that's an answer! I don't understand it, but it's still AN ANSWER! I will order said device tonight from Amazon.

So basically I plug it into my BT Hub 6, press a button and away we go?

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
Hahaha -you can try that buy your network will crash :-)

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
Orbi

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
To switch the router to "wifi extender mode" - is in the router settings. Its not a physical button.

You need to follow steps 1-3, and then once in the web interface for the router, go to the "Working Mode" menu on the left, and select "Access Point". Save it, and then you can plug it into your BTHub.

WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

270 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
bernhund said:
RogerDodger said:
Adding a second router and using it as a wifi repeater is extremely easy and very effective. I've just added another. Some products actually make it easier for you:

i.e. TP Link N450 Cable Router £25

The handy thing about the TP link, is when setting it up you can select it's "mode" as "wifi router only". This does a lto of what I'm about to type below for you (including disabling DHCP server).

Anyhow, lets assume you have a new wifi router that doesn't have the option above,

1) Plug your new router into a PC or laptop directly with a network cable.

2) Manually set the IP address of your PC/Laptop to be on the same net as the router (this will be in the router setup sheet). So, for example, TPLink routers default to 192.168.0.1 - so in your computer network settings for your LAN / Ethernet adapter, set the IP address manually as 192.168.0.somthingotherthan1 - i.e. 192.168.0.99. Subnet mask = 255.255.255.0, default gateway = 192.168.0.1 (not always needed).

TIP: You are configuring TCP/IP v4. Ignore TCP/IP v6

3) Now you have set your laptop on the same network as your new router, so you can access it by going into a web browser and typing 192.168.0.1 in the address bar. You can now configure your new router through it's web interface.

NOTE: You can avoid a lot of the above by just plugging your computer into the router with a lan cable and letting the DCHP server in your router give your PC an IP address that is on the same network . I have spelt it out because it is good to know how to force your computer onto a network if you mess things up. I always do it manually. Old habit. NOTE: if doing this on a laptop you'll need to switch the wifi off / disable it, or your laptop won't know which network to join.

4) In your new routers settings:
- Ignore the ADSL / Cable setup - all irrelivent
- Go into "DHCP" settings and disable DHCP SERVER- this is VITAL - this stops your new router handing out IP address. You don't want this, it will cause chaos. Your existing router will do that for you.
- Go into wifi and give your new network exactly the same ID as your existing one (if you want seamless transition from one router to another). This is case sensitive. Give it exactly the same password too.

TIP: If you are confident enough, give your new router a fixed IP address - this might involve reserving one on your old router, or looking at the DHCP table on the old router and seeing which addresses are free/excluded. This just makes it easier to access your new router once on your existing network as you'll know it's IP address. NOTE2: If the address you give it is on a different subnet - i.e your existing network is on 192.168.99.x (more likely 192.168.1.x but the "99" should draw your eye to the difference more easily!) - the moment you click "save changes" you will lose access to the web interface until the next step.

5) Now plug your new router into your existing router's LAN port (not WAN) with a cable

Done!

What will now happen is your new router will get an IP address from the old router, join your existing network, and happily repeat your wifi network.

If you want to configure your new router some more (and you surely will) then you'll need to know what IP address it was given (if you didn't give it a fixed one) - you can find this by looking in the DHCP table on your existing router.

If this all sounds tricky, the router I suggested does nearly all fo this for you when you select "Wifi repeater mode" - it switces off its internal DHCP Server, the ADSL interface, and any other irrelivent options.

The key to all this is understanding that you will need to be on the same subnet (that's the 192.168.X. part - the third number) as the router to configure it, and that means you need to be plugged directly into it to set it up.

If you plug a new router into your existing lan without doing this, it will either be invisible to you, or , if it's on the same subnet, it will start conflicting with your existing router.


Edited by RogerDodger on Sunday 23 September 18:55
Now that's an answer! I don't understand it, but it's still AN ANSWER! I will order said device tonight from Amazon.

So basically I plug it into my BT Hub 6, press a button and away we go?
Don't! You want a wireless extender in one of it's guises, not another router!

sgrimshaw

7,587 posts

281 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
bernhund said:
NDA said:
Does your outbuilding work off the same fusebox as the main house?

If it does, use home plugs. Easy and very reliable.
Sadly not.
Not being on the same fusebox is not an issue with the modern Homeplugs.

I have three consumer units across my property and my TP Link Homeplugs work faultlessly across all of them.

Essentially, if the outbuilding is on the same meter as the rest of the property then Homeplugs should work as long as the wiring is reasonable.





bernhund

Original Poster:

3,798 posts

224 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
sgrimshaw said:
bernhund said:
NDA said:
Does your outbuilding work off the same fusebox as the main house?

If it does, use home plugs. Easy and very reliable.
Sadly not.
Not being on the same fusebox is not an issue with the modern Homeplugs.

I have three consumer units across my property and my TP Link Homeplugs work faultlessly across all of them.

Essentially, if the outbuilding is on the same meter as the rest of the property then Homeplugs should work as long as the wiring is reasonable.
Are we talking about something different to the usual BT Mini Hub plug in jobs? Only I have 2 of these in the house and they constantly drop out and drive me mad! I'm about ready to drown my Alexa in a bowl of water as she only seems to be able to tell me she's lost connection. I did have a plug in in the out building (which has its own board but fed from the main board) but it didn't find any signal.

skilly1

2,913 posts

226 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
Pothole said:
Orbi
Yes - these are awesome, sorted all wi-fi issues instantly all over the house with no technical knowledge.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
sgrimshaw said:
Not being on the same fusebox is not an issue with the modern Homeplugs.

I have three consumer units across my property and my TP Link Homeplugs work faultlessly across all of them.

Essentially, if the outbuilding is on the same meter as the rest of the property then Homeplugs should work as long as the wiring is reasonable.
Not true. My garage is on the same meter and doesn't work with homeplugs (that work in my house)

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 24th September 2018
quotequote all
WinstonWolf said:
Don't! You want a wireless extender in one of it's guises, not another router!
The catch with a wireless exteder is this:

You lose at least half the bandwidth as everything is repeated over the same wifi network ( rather than your lan, which a second wired router would use) . This is fine if you just want to browse the web, but it fails badly when you try and stream video (iplayer etc). Trust me, I've tried over the years .

Orbi and the likes solve this problem by using a totally seperate wifi network to establish the data link, leaving the wifi network that you connect to free of all the traffic needed to keep the link working. They basically replace the ethernet cable with an independent wireless network. What's the catch? - 1) The price - try going "Orbi" for £25 2) you are still streaming over wireless, and if your connection is less than optimal then it won't be as fast as a wired repeater. The main issue is 1) - the price.

Homeplugs work well enough when close enough, and you can get homeplugs that extend wifi too - and they work well in some cases. It is all down to your cabling quality, the distance, and how muc electrical "noise" there is on the relevant mains circuits.

I use a homeplug to feed one of my wifi routers (extending my wifi to my bathroom) a network connection. It gets around a 100Mb link (which is fine for TV streaming). I also use one to feed a remote printer. Fast enough for that too.

In my garage homeplugs won't work at all, and wifi extenders work, but don't have enough for TV streaming, and struggle to feed my IPCam data back from my garage. I ran a Cat5e cable to my garage in the end and put the above mentioned TPLink router on the end and it works a charm.

Take it or leave it, but it is sound, professional advice. There are £££ solutions - like Orbi, and there are Homeplug solutions which are a compromise, but often effective enough. But you'll never beat a hard wired wifi router for extending wifi. reliable and cheap.