Installed Mojave on mac, very slow boot from ext ssd drive
Installed Mojave on mac, very slow boot from ext ssd drive
Author
Discussion

andygo

Original Poster:

7,422 posts

286 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
My boot time has gone from 30secs to 2 mins since I installed Mojave on my 2014 imac.
Restored to previous os via time machine, boot time back to sub 30 secs.

I suspect that the issue is the compulsory APFS file system on my 480gb SSD drive. Is there a way to install Mojave on the SSD drive and then reload all my files back onto the SSD drive without invoking the APFS file system?

Or is there another reason/fix to sort the painfully slow boot up?

Tried all the Pram stuff, to no avail.



andygo

Original Poster:

7,422 posts

286 months

Wednesday 26th September 2018
quotequote all
Can't believe its just me on here, I think its something to do with the APFS file system forced onto the target ssd drive when installing.

Bikerjon

2,211 posts

192 months

Wednesday 26th September 2018
quotequote all
Is the boot drive set to external? You could always confirm your theory by running High Sierra on APFS.

andygo

Original Poster:

7,422 posts

286 months

Wednesday 26th September 2018
quotequote all
I have had the external %500gb Samsung drive for a couple of years and always enjoyed 30 second boot up times. Put Mojave on and its now 2 mins plus.

Restored via Time machine backup, and boot times were back to 30 secs. Reinstalled Mojave and its back to more than 2 mins.

Not overly chuffed. Must be other people having the same issue, and Google agrees. No simple resolution though, which is disappointing from Apple.

Bikerjon

2,211 posts

192 months

Wednesday 26th September 2018
quotequote all
Running your boot drive from an external is far from a typical configuration though. Surely this would have happened in High Sierra too if it was an APFS issue? It's still very early days for Mojave so maybe it will get fixed in an update.

goldieandblackie

273 posts

125 months

Wednesday 26th September 2018
quotequote all
And thats one reason why I always wait a few weeks to see if there are any problems with updates before upgrading.

andygo

Original Poster:

7,422 posts

286 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
From what I see on Google, there are numerous instances of a similar situation with High Sierra that hasn't been easily resolved.

Vaud

60,047 posts

186 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
I just ran a test on a clean Mojave installed to a 120gb SSD, mounted via USB 3 on a Macbook Pro 2015.

From boot (and timing from the click of selecting the external drive to boot from) to login screen was 30.5 seconds, similar to my Sierra local install (internal SSD)

JamieBeeston

9,294 posts

296 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
I reboot my macs maybe once a year?

Do you need that 90 seconds a year so badly ?

Vaud

60,047 posts

186 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
JamieBeeston said:
I reboot my macs maybe once a year?

Do you need that 90 seconds a year so badly ?
Some people switch between bootcamp and OSX smile

On my main mac, I reboot it weekly - I find OSX can get a bit lazy with caches, etc.

JamieBeeston

9,294 posts

296 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
Vaud said:
JamieBeeston said:
I reboot my macs maybe once a year?

Do you need that 90 seconds a year so badly ?
Some people switch between bootcamp and OSX smile

On my main mac, I reboot it weekly - I find OSX can get a bit lazy with caches, etc.
Hmm, never noticed any slowdowns on my iMac 5k, iMac Pro or MBP despite literal years of uptime!

I suppose, those times I've ever seen people need windows, they tended to simply run it in a VM.

As a (used to be) MS fan boy (beta tester for windows 98 onwards) I cant say Ive felt any reason to touch windows in maybe a decade.

Still, 90 seconds once a week on a 4 yr old Mac, I could stomach for a later OS with all the security it offers, but hey, we're all different wink

andygo

Original Poster:

7,422 posts

286 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
I realise that its not a huge issue, but having got an SSD drive to speed up reboots, might as well aim to have it working.

Its the same scenario as modding my car to go faster, only for another mod causing it to slow down. It might only be an increase of 2 seconds 0-60, not a big deal, blah blah, but I guess most people would rather have the benefit having paid for it!

JamieBeeston

9,294 posts

296 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
andygo said:
I realise that its not a huge issue, but having got an SSD drive to speed up reboots, might as well aim to have it working.

Its the same scenario as modding my car to go faster, only for another mod causing it to slow down. It might only be an increase of 2 seconds 0-60, not a big deal, blah blah, but I guess most people would rather have the benefit having paid for it!
I get you, however I would say the following :-

I suspect you got the SSD to improve daily usage performance, which I'd imagine its still doing on the new OS.
Is the new OS slower in of itself when in use? or simply the boot time is irking you (and again, I can understand why!)

Sounds like you've poured a few hours in to this already with Upgrade/Downgrades, so I'm sure a resolution would be cathartic smile

My 2p would be, the old OS is old, the new OS is new, the new OS can only get better right smile

PS just rebooted the iMac Pro - 36.15 seconds from pushing the button to the login screen, on Mojave.

HTH.

andygo

Original Poster:

7,422 posts

286 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
haha, please dont keep reminding me of your rapid reboots!

Bikerjon

2,211 posts

192 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
Alternatively do a proper job and fit the SSD where it should be...inside the iMac!

Vaud

60,047 posts

186 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
Bikerjon said:
Alternatively do a proper job and fit the SSD where it should be...inside the iMac!
Sod of a job on an iMac. Plus having multiple boot drives can be handy. I run mine from a Thunderbolt caddy.

andygo

Original Poster:

7,422 posts

286 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
My SSD drive is really comfy running from its cable tied perch on the rear of my macs stand, has been for 4 years now. Doubt it has any bearing on my (perceived) issue.

No performance gain (or loss) from finding a space inside the complicated to access inner Mac.

Bikerjon

2,211 posts

192 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
andygo said:
No performance gain (or loss) from finding a space inside the complicated to access inner Mac.
No performance gain unless you want to run Mojave...

It's really not that difficult to do, but you have to take much care not to crack the glass.

andygo

Original Poster:

7,422 posts

286 months

Friday 28th September 2018
quotequote all
Why would putting the SSD drive inside the computer give a performance gain?

Warmfuzzies

4,382 posts

284 months

Friday 28th September 2018
quotequote all
Bikerjon said:
andygo said:
No performance gain (or loss) from finding a space inside the complicated to access inner Mac.
No performance gain unless you want to run Mojave...

It's really not that difficult to do, but you have to take much care not to crack the glass.
Some IMac models are easy, some less so. My 2009 model was a snap, two suckers, lift the screen, a dozen screws and there you go, my slimline 2011, is a sealed screen, needs a different approach and new gasket afterwards, I’d use a thunderbolt drive on it if I could afford it.
Internal drives are better I feel for neatness alone, might be other benefits, I don’t know