Help diagnosing network issue
Author
Discussion

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
Afternoon. We recently upgraded our internet connection speed from 100Mbps to 300Mbps supplied by gigaclear fibre to the house. I can get 250 ish at the router through a cat5e cable to my laptop which is fine. However, in the office at the bottom of the garden I'm only getting just under 100Mbps. I was happy with this before as I thought I was getting all or most of the capacity that was available.

I have tested the network by removing all the connections to switches and other devices on the network. With the laptop plugged in to the router I get 250Mbps as I said before. If I plug the network cable connecting the router to the shed in to the router and then plug that cable in to the laptop in the shed (same one, same speed checking software) I get about 90Mbps up and down.

Therefore I'm assuming it's the cable. I thought I'd ordered 'outdoor' cat 5e cable but this was a few years back and I can't find the order details. The cable is roughly 50m long (certainly not longer). I have a sample of the cable I haven't used and the only identifier on it says 'outdoor cca'. The cable looks like this...



...and the individual core are solid. The outer cover looks like pvc and there's no shielding I can see, just the transparent film you can see in the picture. Is that cat 5 cable and therefore is that the reason I'm not getting speeds higher than I'm seeing? The cable is not being routed near the power supply for the shed and even enters the shed on the other side.

Any advice would be gratefully received, thanks.

Mark

Edited by dern on Thursday 27th September 16:56

thebraketester

15,852 posts

169 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
Looks like exterior grade cat 5 to me. Ive just bought some and it looks identical to that.

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
Sorry, just reduced the insane picture size.

Damn, I thought that might be the case. I'll have to work out if I can be arsed to install another cable.

Thanks.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
Your problem is staring you in the face :-) "outdoor CCA". CCA = copper coated Aluminium.

It's a way of cost saving - your wires are aluminium with a thin coating of copper. I can even see it in yoru picture (though without your info, it could have just been a reflection!).

Alu doesn't conduct anywhere near as well as copper.

Cat 5 will happily cary your data but you want copper. All copper.

I use cat 5e STP (shielded twisted pairs) copper - and it is cable tied for 30m along a huge power cable :-)

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/External-SHIELDED-CAT5e...

STP = FTP (foil twisted pair). You wopn't need the sheilding if you are not going near noisy cables.

The great thing about the above cable, apart from being all-copper and UV resistant, is it has a drain wire.

Connect this at one end to earth. Leave the other disconnected. Now you have lightening/surge protection whihc you really want when cabling outbuildings, as you end up with a potential difference at each end, which can be bad when there are electrical storms.

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
Ah, very much an amateur so didn't know what CCA meant. Thank you smile

Didn't even see the light bits but can confirm that I can scrape more off so you must be right.

Thanks for the link, I'll get that ordered and do the job again. Huge pain but I'll reap the benefit next time unreal engine updates wink

Cheers

megaphone

11,723 posts

282 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
As said CCA cable is not made the the Category 5 standards, it should not be called or sold as CAT5, when ever I've bought it it's been called 'Network Cable' .

Do you really need more than 90mb/s?

Edited by megaphone on Friday 28th September 07:56

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
If it's a huge pain you can go better. Cat 6, cat 6e etc. Worth a little research on the differences, though the cable I linked is good for 1Gb over your distance

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
I'm sure that cable will be fine, it'll be a lot better than I have. It's only a huge pain compared to doing nothing wink

No, don't need more than 90Mbps but as it's available at the router it would be a shame not to have it. It'll make some of the larger software updates a bit quicker too.

buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Thursday 27th September 2018
quotequote all
CCA is a pain in the ass to terminate, I always end up doing it like 3 times before I get a good one.

100 meg needs the orange and green pairs working, 1000 meg needs all 4 pairs working

Problem is almost certainly an issue with the termination of the blue or brown pairs. Check that the switch in the shed is gigabit too.

Cable length / quality issue usually gives you no link or a link but no data flow, if you're getting a steady 100 meg then it's just the extra pairs needed for gig aren't connected properly.

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Friday 28th September 2018
quotequote all
That's interesting, thanks, I'll check that.

I upgraded the switch in the shed.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 28th September 2018
quotequote all
You can buy cheap ethernet connection testers that will confirm all wires are connected, this would be the first thing to try.

If this is all good then it is highly likely to be the CCA wire in the cable having higher loss than copper over a longer distance, probably be fine for a 5m or 10m run. Before you decide to rip it out and replace I would try forcing the network connection to gigabit speed rather than let it auto-negotiate and see what happens, you may need to set this at both ends of the network.

a7x88

795 posts

179 months

Friday 28th September 2018
quotequote all
90mbps is around the max you will see (considering overhead) on a fast ethernet (100mbps) connection.

As above - only 2 cores are needed for 100 whereas 4 are required for gigabit.

My bet is on either the switch being Fast Ethernet only or there is a bad termination meaning not all 4 cores are connected

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Saturday 29th September 2018
quotequote all
The switch I bought was a NETGEAR GS108UK 8-Port Gigabit Ethernet Unmanaged Switch.

geeks

11,900 posts

170 months

Saturday 29th September 2018
quotequote all
Also worth checking your router can do gig ethernet. Some don't, so like the early BT Home Hubs for example only had 1 gig port!

Gary C

15,377 posts

210 months

Saturday 29th September 2018
quotequote all
dern said:
The switch I bought was a NETGEAR GS108UK 8-Port Gigabit Ethernet Unmanaged Switch.
So only one port light lit ?

I used outdoor cat6 bought from kenable, will even give 10 gig over 50 meters if you ever need it.

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Saturday 29th September 2018
quotequote all
Yes, just one light lit on each port. I put the cable in to the pc skipping the switch so I now the switch isn't the problem.

The port on the router gives nearly 250Mbps on a short known cable.

I'll get a cable tester.

JustALooseScrew

1,154 posts

98 months

Saturday 29th September 2018
quotequote all
dern said:
Yes, just one light lit on each port. I put the cable in to the pc skipping the switch so I now the switch isn't the problem.

The port on the router gives nearly 250Mbps on a short known cable.

I'll get a cable tester.
Given what you've said it does look like a cable issue, before buying any new kit I'd look at just remaking the cable endpoints.

You have to consider the Gigabit transmission speeds are nearing microwave frequencies where a cable acts as a wave guide not just a 'true' conductor - hence the bend radii we experience with CAT6.

Remake the RJ45 connections again - carefully - and see how you get on. If that doesn't sort it then full copper versus CCA copper clad aluminum [sic] will surely help, don't run the cable around any tight bends.

dern

Original Poster:

14,055 posts

310 months

Saturday 29th September 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for all the advice, really appreciate it and have learned a lot.

Figured it out, I bought a cable tester and the blue and white wire is broken somewhere (number 5). I've remade both ends a couple of times just in case and it's definitely number 5.

New cable time and until then it still works at a pretty good speed.

Many thanks.

a7x88

795 posts

179 months

Saturday 29th September 2018
quotequote all
I've found solid core a right pain to terminate into RJ45 correctly. It's not really meant for it and should go to a patch panel or similar with stranded being left for the end device connection via RJ45.

All my patch panel connections and wall socket connections were fine with solid - the ceiling drops for access points that I wanted to terminate into RJ45 took multiple attempts or plain didn't work. Even with multiple different types and makes of connector. In the end I terminated them into keystones, tucked them into the ceiling and ran a short patch cable to the AP. Much more reliable and neater as the cable was more flexible so could be routed out of the ceiling and into the AP port tighter.

thebraketester

15,852 posts

169 months

Saturday 29th September 2018
quotequote all
Admittedly I have only terminated about 10-15 rj45 and never had one issue with solid core.. maybe I got lucky.