New laptop recommendations please
New laptop recommendations please
Author
Discussion

sider

Original Poster:

2,061 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
Hi All,

Looking for a new laptop (or other device!) recommendation.

Generally for business use, Microsoft Excel and Word really with the occasional specialist bit of software thrown in, with usual web browsing etc.

Current laptop is old (2012 ish) and works fine - other than battery which last 20 mins or so and it's quite big. When no mains power available find myself rushing things before power goes. Likewise, a bit crap when meeting clients and have to sit in a coffee shop near to a power socket!

Wasn't really looking until i saw a lady on a train with a Macbook (something or other) which looked tiny and i could really get bits of work done whilst waiting to pick kids up from their activities rather than just playing on my phone. Current laptop is too big to carry around to do this (don't get me wrong, it's not huge but just not Macbook size!).

Have looked at a MS Surface Pro with keyboard cover but not really sure if they're a laptop or a tablet. Had a look at Currys and appears to fold down to not much more than a tablet, even with keyboard. I have an Office 365 account which i could use to access relevant software if it is just a tablet.

For business use so will be going through the books but still not looking to spend millions!

Would appreciate any suggestions / recommendations, and also an idea on best places to buy be it online or instore.

sider

Original Poster:

2,061 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
Just spotted another post on here about Lenovo Yoga. Looks another interesting option.

megenzo

329 posts

167 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
i replaced my windows lappy a couple of years ago and needed a new one that had a smaller footprint so bought a secondhand 13" MacBook air (2012 model). Its been fab, small, light, fast and reliable. There may be a newer version of the air due out soon, they're pricy but I couldn't go back to a PC anytime soon.

sider

Original Poster:

2,061 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
megenzo said:
i replaced my windows lappy a couple of years ago and needed a new one that had a smaller footprint so bought a secondhand 13" MacBook air (2012 model). Its been fab, small, light, fast and reliable. There may be a newer version of the air due out soon, they're pricy but I couldn't go back to a PC anytime soon.
Thanks.

Can i ask a possibly stupid question though - do they work ok with likes of MS Excel? Would i need to purchase MS Office or does iOS provide compatible software to open and work on docs created in MS Office.

IanJ9375

1,638 posts

247 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
I saw this the other day (and it being PH) thought it be appropriate to mention it here

https://www.ebuyer.com/824770-porsche-design-book-...

It's vastly overpriced originally and now more reasonable, for business I'd suggest sticking to a regular laptop format rather than something like the Surface type devices which are not the easiest to use in tight spaces or on your knee, that's the feedback we've had from managers we've provided both to where I work anyhow.

sider

Original Poster:

2,061 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
IanJ9375 said:
I saw this the other day (and it being PH) thought it be appropriate to mention it here

https://www.ebuyer.com/824770-porsche-design-book-...

It's vastly overpriced originally and now more reasonable, for business I'd suggest sticking to a regular laptop format rather than something like the Surface type devices which are not the easiest to use in tight spaces or on your knee, that's the feedback we've had from managers we've provided both to where I work anyhow.
Thanks. So, these 2-in-1s - are they a laptop with a detachable screen??

Spec wise, is that Porsche one any good?? (Never thought i'd ask that...!)

Just looking actually - is it fundamentally one of the 'Surface type devices' to which you refer?

Mr Pointy

13,444 posts

190 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
sider said:
Can i ask a possibly stupid question though - do they work ok with likes of MS Excel? Would i need to purchase MS Office or does iOS provide compatible software to open and work on docs created in MS Office.
See here:
https://products.office.com/en-US/mac/microsoft-of...

I'm not sure the programmes are 100% the same but I think any differences are quite small.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
sider said:
Thanks.

Can i ask a possibly stupid question though - do they work ok with likes of MS Excel? Would i need to purchase MS Office or does iOS provide compatible software to open and work on docs created in MS Office.
Another vote for Mac here. My personal computers are Macs. My works issued laptop is windows.

MS office is available on a Mac and works 100% the same and full compatibility. Apple do offer some included office like apps which can open and save to Excel formats too. Maybe not quite as rich as MS Office but by and large just as capable. And of course there are things like Google sheets these days. Which work on almost anything.

Apart from high end gaming and a few, mostly historic applications. You can do almost everything on a Mac that you can on a Windows machine. And plenty of things that are better or Mac only or included for free on Mac OS that you have to pay to get similar apps on Windows.

IanJ9375

1,638 posts

247 months

Thursday 11th October 2018
quotequote all
sider said:
Thanks. So, these 2-in-1s - are they a laptop with a detachable screen??

Spec wise, is that Porsche one any good?? (Never thought i'd ask that...!)

Just looking actually - is it fundamentally one of the 'Surface type devices' to which you refer?
Yep detachable touch screen, spec is pretty reasonable at the sale price as it stands.
Yes some of the "surface" type devices don't really work well on your lap - we have some HP devices which have been swapped out - http://totalreview.net/upload/icon/20160614/x2-2-6...

Plenty of reviews out there (based on the full RRP mind) https://www.laptopmag.com/reviews/laptops/porsche-...
No pre-installed bloat is always a bonus

craig_emp

80 posts

220 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
If you have an office365 subscription you can download the windows or Mac versions of office.

pmanson

13,388 posts

284 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
I'm thinking about getting one of these HP ENVY x360

It's £999 on HPs site but with a longer warranty (3 yrs vs. 2)

AJB88

16,019 posts

202 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
I've just got a 13" Dell XPS with i7 processor, I bought the Ubuntu version but they do a Windows 10 version as well.

it replaced my 2010 Macbook Pro.

NDA

25,838 posts

256 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Another vote for Mac here. My personal computers are Macs. My works issued laptop is windows.

MS office is available on a Mac and works 100% the same and full compatibility. Apple do offer some included office like apps which can open and save to Excel formats too. Maybe not quite as rich as MS Office but by and large just as capable. And of course there are things like Google sheets these days. Which work on almost anything.

Apart from high end gaming and a few, mostly historic applications. You can do almost everything on a Mac that you can on a Windows machine. And plenty of things that are better or Mac only or included for free on Mac OS that you have to pay to get similar apps on Windows.
Yep.

I switched to a MacBook 5 years ago - it's been used day and night, continually, since then without a glitch. The battery is just starting to show its age, but it's been a bargain when measured against the countless laptops that I've had that have crashed and burned along the way.

Pages and Numbers (the Apple version of Word and Excel) work in just the same way - unless you're a heavy/deep user there's no real difference. I receive (for example) quite complex management accounts on my Mac sent from Excel and they work absolutely fine.

sgrimshaw

7,587 posts

281 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
pmanson said:
I'm thinking about getting one of these HP ENVY x360

It's £999 on HPs site but with a longer warranty (3 yrs vs. 2)
My HP Envy x360 runs like a total dog, and has done from day one - hate it with a vengance.

Jinx

12,023 posts

291 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
It's Friday so head over to Dell outlet as they'll have plenty of "refurbished" (pretty much unused) stock (plus 20% off inspirons until Sunday).

I mention them so often I should really get commission hehe

I've been buying from Dell outlet since 2009 and that machine is still running as my HTPC




Vaud

60,047 posts

186 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
Excel on a Mac is 99% same as PC; unless you are needing bespoke plugins it will be fine.

I have a MacBook Pro (Retina, 13-inch, Early 2015) and it's an excellent machine. I use Office 365 and have been very happy.

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
"MS office is available on a Mac and works 100% the same and full compatibility."

Oh! Not quite! No Publisher/Access on Mac Office, no pivot chats, no embedded fonts, Outlook advanced features missing, no document inspector for privacy, etc. Mostly advanced stuff that many people don't use though.

There's a list of Office Mac v. PC variations here:

https://www.howtogeek.com/340435/whats-the-differe...

There's a move to HDMI ports, from DisplayPort and VGA on 'commercial' PC laptops, if you have a desktop monitor.

As to RAM size/Office uses, we've got some hefty 1 million word Doc files, and huge spreadsheets here, Office 2016/Windows 10 doesn't use above 4GB ram including the OS, with them loaded. So 8GB seems optimal.


Edited by Slushbox on Friday 12th October 10:51

leglessAlex

7,517 posts

172 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
AJB88 said:
I've just got a 13" Dell XPS with i7 processor, I bought the Ubuntu version but they do a Windows 10 version as well.

it replaced my 2010 Macbook Pro.
Snap, although I got the previous generation due to the port selection.

I'd recommend it, a Dell XPS 9360. Nice screen, battery that lasts ages and very compact. Dodgy webcam placement though if that matters to you.

It replaced a MacBook Pro, and it's been great. Apple laptops are just too expensive for me to justify these days, and then in addition to that they have keyboard problems and the ports are hassle for my usage case.

If buying new USB-C cables or dongles and possible keyboard problems doesn't bother you, then the MacBook really is lovely to use with it's size. But very expensive.

Bear in mind that the rumours say that Apple might release an updated MacBook Air at the end of this month. It will most likely have the pain in the ass* USB-C ports, but apparently the third-gen keyboard has been largely fixed and it should be at a more reasonable price point. For Apple, at least.



  • I've never actually used a USB-C only laptop. Maybe it isn't as much of a pain as I think it is. I don't particularly want to fidn out though, I can think of some very irritating issues that would crop up.

ZesPak

26,165 posts

227 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
MS office is available on a Mac and works 100% the same and full compatibility.
As someone who uses excel way to often on both platforms, I stopped reading after this.

You are full of it.


As for the OP, if you can stretch your budget to Dell XPS, they are very very good machines without any compromise.

Edited by ZesPak on Friday 12th October 11:19

Vaud

60,047 posts

186 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
Slushbox said:
"MS office is available on a Mac and works 100% the same and full compatibility."

Oh! Not quite! No Publisher/Access on Mac Office, no pivot chats, no embedded fonts, Outlook advanced features missing, no document inspector for privacy, etc. Mostly advanced stuff that many people don't use though.

There's a list of Office Mac v. PC variations here:

https://www.howtogeek.com/340435/whats-the-differe...
Erm, Mac has Pivot Tables (bit not charts). And embedded fonts. And Digital Ink. That article is out of date.

Agree on Access, which is a continued gap, but is it that widely used by most O365 users? Publisher is no loss, it's a horrible dated POC.

It isn't like for like, but it is much closer than many years and I think their goal is convergence on a common binary.

Edited to correct on Pivot Tables vs Charts.

Edited by Vaud on Friday 12th October 11:21