slightly different new car (PCP) question
slightly different new car (PCP) question
Author
Discussion

rykard

Original Poster:

447 posts

201 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
I have two cars both for around the same monthly and deposit, one is a diesel and one petrol. Most of our journeys are short with longer trips being done at weekends. - max 7000 a year.

the diesel has a better spec than the petrol and if we wanted the same spec petrol it woul dbe £100-£150/m more.

Would you take the chance that we will do enough miles to allow the diesel to regen etc. or would you stick to petrol?

What will the trade in be in 3-4 years?

rykard

Original Poster:

447 posts

201 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
to add..
it's a Alfa Stelvio Super(Petrol) + 4/5 options vs. a Stelvio Speciale (Diesel) + 1 option.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

218 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
Unless the car breaks down why would you care if it regenerates or not?

You are a short term owner the impact would/might be future owners. Plus your covered by warranty so it’s only the inconvience IF it did go wrong.

PistonBroker

2,681 posts

246 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
Different for me as I'm leasing, so it will go back in 2021 regardless and I don't need to worry about what it's worth. But I had similar concerns when ordering our Disco Sport. I've plumped for diesel, but it's needed a regen about 4 times already I think in the space of 6 months. Which doesn't seem ideal.

I worked on the basis that the Tiguan it replaced had only required a regen about twice in its 2 years with us. Though I'm told by an indie VW client of mine that newer and software-updated ones seem to be requiring more regens.

I think if I was PCPing I'd be inclined towards the petrol.

Ninja59

3,691 posts

132 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
I would have to agree with the above.

The only issue might be you need to take it on the odd motorway run for 30 minutes if you do not do your long journey. In recent years though DPF's have become better at regenerating over short time spans and at critically lower speed. Revs is not an issue, but you need to run at a constant decent speed above usually above 40 mph for many to do it.

Does the petrol version have a GPF anyway?

rykard

Original Poster:

447 posts

201 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
Don't know about a gpf though. The diesel has better seats, and lights but does cost a little more and I am concerned about the ultra clean emission zones etc though it will be euro 6 so should be fine. I am starting to lean towards the speciale tbh