Link Aggregation and a NAS
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
I've been thinking about upgrading my Netgear NAS (Raid) to benefit from link aggregation as Gg ethernet is limiting transfer speeds to around 100mbps, or less than half if I'm copying NAS-PC-NAS (nas to nas via PC).

On the NAS side that seems easy. Connect a dual LAN NAS to a managed switch with LAG, such as the Netgear GS108T v2
On the Win 10 side, can I do the same (assuming I buy a second LAN port card) - or do I need to do something on the Win 10 side as well? (i.e. is it not just a case of relyign on the switch to do all the work). I'm guessing something needs doign or the PC won't know what IP to put on what card etc.

Gary C

15,376 posts

210 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
Only 100mbps over a gig link ?

Sounds as if the bottle neck is somewhere else.

johnnymiller

164 posts

208 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
Gary C said:
Only 100mbps over a gig link ?

Sounds as if the bottle neck is somewhere else.
Megabytes vs megabits. A 1 gigabit lan connection will return up to 125 megabytes per second in theory. https://www.gbmb.org/mbps-to-mbs

You need teamed network cards, the software came with the ones I used and effectively You tell the lan switch the ports are an aggregated bundle together to the same device and then team the network cards in the windows driver utility. Works fine, but I’ve only done it on an enterprise level servers and switches at work.

Gary C

15,376 posts

210 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
johnnymiller said:
Gary C said:
Only 100mbps over a gig link ?

Sounds as if the bottle neck is somewhere else.
Megabytes vs megabits. A 1 gigabit lan connection will return up to 125 megabytes per second in theory. https://www.gbmb.org/mbps-to-mbs

You need teamed network cards, the software came with the ones I used and effectively You tell the lan switch the ports are an aggregated bundle together to the same device and then team the network cards in the windows driver utility. Works fine, but I’ve only done it on an enterprise level servers and switches at work.
He stated Mbps which is normally translated to mean bits per second as against MBps which is normally translated as Bytes per second.

I have lags between the switches in the house, but mainly as I ran two cables for reliability (I'm not crawling through that eave again !) but as you say, without the capacity in the device to use it, it doesn't give me anymore speed.

So yes, you need to setup the PC Cards as lags, but I've not don't that. smile

And Windows 10 doesn't have lag so you either need Windows server or third party drivers.

Edited by Gary C on Sunday 14th October 13:54


Edited by Gary C on Sunday 14th October 13:57

bitchstewie

68,529 posts

241 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
What model/spec is the source/destination NAS and what type of files and what are you using to do the copy?

Depends on the specifications but I'd be a little surprised if the network is the bottleneck on gig ethernet.

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
OP, check out the read/write speeds for the drives in your NAS. As above, particularly for writes and particularly particularly if your drives are RAIDed, your bottleneck is most unlikely to be the network.

BTW, if you're doing a NAS-NAS copy then either use a file manager app on the NAS, or learn a few basic Unix commands. Doing it NAS-PC-NAS is...inefficient smile

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
Cheers. I'll look into compatible network cards.

I often have to copy NAs-PC-Nas. Just the way it is.

Defo a lan bottleneck. When I do Nas-PC-Nas it slows down considerably. I'm also looking at a new NAS that will easily fill a 2Gb link.

My xfer speed is the one windows shows. Varies up to 80Mb/s/whatevers.

So, if I "team" my PC lan cards, I guess I still need to tell the managed switch?

bitchstewie

68,529 posts

241 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
If you team your NICs you need to pay attention to the way both they and the NAS are teamed.

Teaming is often intended to balance bandwidth amongst multiple clients rather than to allow a single client to use the capacity of multiple NICs.

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
Those speeds look more like 10/100 ethernet. :-)

Sure it's not MB/s? If it's Windows 10 displayed speeds it's MB/s.

NAS to PC generally runs up to about 800 MB/s over gig ethernet. So there's a problem somewhere. Probably wise to fix that before springing for more hardware. 5200 rpm drives? A 10/100 port or link somewhere? RAID corrupted? 10/100 switch/hub/router?

Link aggregation PC-NAS will need four ports in the managed switch. There are also Netgear routers with LAG.

It's probably better to buy an ex-server 2 or 4 port Intel NIC rather than trying to twin the PC's embedded LAN port, assuming you can find the correct teaming drivers.

The Netgear domestic switches look something like:







Edited by Slushbox on Sunday 14th October 18:38


Edited by Slushbox on Monday 15th October 07:58

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
its the Win 10 number. I'm rarely at my desktop when replying here. Defo 1Gb. I know what 100 feels like!

Copying a 12ish Gig file NAs-PC-Nas takes a few minutes.

Harpoon

2,553 posts

245 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
If you team your NICs you need to pay attention to the way both they and the NAS are teamed.

Teaming is often intended to balance bandwidth amongst multiple clients rather than to allow a single client to use the capacity of multiple NICs.
That was my first thought as well - don't assume you just enable everything and see speeds double for a single client...