Forum software that is pc and mobile friendly?
Forum software that is pc and mobile friendly?
Author
Discussion

AstonZagato

Original Poster:

14,296 posts

241 months

Saturday 20th October 2018
quotequote all
I am on the committee of a rowing club. We currently communicate in an ugly, chaotic mess of emails, attachments, whatsapp chats and text messages.

There are lots of different areas of communication - coaching, sponsorship, admin, alumni fundraising, squads, men, women, openweight, lightweight. Some areas would be private from other areas. Some would be open.

Lots gets lost in the blizzard of emails/messages and searching for a relevant message is a nightmare. All history is pretty much lost except in the memories of the current or past committee members.

I feel that there has to be a better way to do this. I'm a big user of forums, so a secure forum would seem to be an obvious way to allow the different subcommittees to interact and to allow us to communicate to the wider student athlete body in a consistent way. If there is a better solution than a forum, I'd be open to that.

It also has to be cheap - we have no spare money - and simple to set up, customise and operate (it would probably be down to me to manage it).

Some threads would span different areas so a tagging facility (say, "sponsorship" and "alumni") would be useful. Assigning threads to members would be good too (like tagging a person in Facebook). However, I am mindful that I am a dinosaur so I need everyone to engage with the platform. The student body would probably only look at it on their phone. The old alumni will be PC based - possibly at work - and not necessarily tech savvy.

Would need to be searchable and have a "My stuff" like way of seeing what is happening in threads that you are following and possibly a way of emailing out once a week a summary of the busiest threads.

tl;dr
Need some software to help a broad team co-operate
Must be secure and section-able
Must be cheap and easy
Must be searchable
Must be mobile friendly


Scobblelotcher

1,724 posts

143 months

Saturday 20th October 2018
quotequote all
Sounds like Slack would be perfect for your team.

https://slack.com/

It’s used in the type of context you mention and there is a free tier to use. It’s brilliant on mobile as well.

DocJock

8,722 posts

271 months

Saturday 20th October 2018
quotequote all
https://www.proboards.com

Secure.
Free.
Search function.
Bookmark function.
Mobile app available.
Customise it to your heart's content if you don't want one of their available themes.

AstonZagato

Original Poster:

14,296 posts

241 months

Saturday 20th October 2018
quotequote all
Thanks. Both look interesting.

Slack looks a bit like a more flexible, structured WhatsApp - which might appeal to the student body. Not sure I quite "get it" yet and how we'd use it.

The Proboard is more conventional. No obvious tagging ability but maybe an extension allow that (might be beyond me). It looks like the mobile apps require paying for somewhere.

Scobblelotcher

1,724 posts

143 months

Saturday 20th October 2018
quotequote all
AstonZagato said:
Thanks. Both look interesting.

Slack looks a bit like a more flexible, structured WhatsApp - which might appeal to the student body. Not sure I quite "get it" yet and how we'd use it.

The Proboard is more conventional. No obvious tagging ability but maybe an extension allow that (might be beyond me). It looks like the mobile apps require paying for somewhere.
Slack is very widely used in business and also in activities groups.

So for your example all of the areas you mention like coaching, sponsorship and admin would be channels. Each channel can be set to be open or requiring an admin to admit people who request access. Alerts can be dynamically triggered by using an alert trigger or otherwise members of the channel can see updates using the web or mobile clients.

Search history is simple and attachments can be added to channels.

Anyway this video will hopefully help explain it better! https://youtu.be/9RJZMSsH7-g

For me the power of slack is it’s flexibility, integration with other systems and it’s such an easy thing to do, especially on mobile!

Scobblelotcher

1,724 posts

143 months

Saturday 20th October 2018
quotequote all
Microsoft teams is another one to consider but maybe outside of your budgetary requirements as it requires a monthly subscription.

https://products.office.com/en-us/microsoft-teams/...

mouseymousey

2,642 posts

268 months

Saturday 20th October 2018
quotequote all
As a user I like forums running on Discourse which has tagging.

No idea on cost though I'm afraid but it's very slick software.

AstonZagato

Original Poster:

14,296 posts

241 months

Monday 22nd October 2018
quotequote all
Bump for the weekday crowd.

Solid candidates already but I'd love to see some others please.

maffski

1,905 posts

190 months

Monday 22nd October 2018
quotequote all
mouseymousey said:
As a user I like forums running on Discourse which has tagging.

No idea on cost though I'm afraid but it's very slick software.
The Discourse software is free - https://blog.discourse.org/2014/04/install-discour... - you only need to pay if you want Discourse to run everything for you (there's also a discount if you fit their definition of a non-profit)

Craikeybaby

12,179 posts

256 months

Monday 22nd October 2018
quotequote all
Forums are great if people are proactive at checking them, or are used to forums.

I expect that something like Slack would be more suitable for what you need though.

JustALooseScrew

1,154 posts

98 months

Monday 22nd October 2018
quotequote all
Scobblelotcher said:
Sounds like Slack would be perfect for your team.
Do you know if you can host and run Slack on your own server?

I'm so wary these days of solutions that are 'cloud' based subscriptions.

For one club I'm involved with, day to day everything is done via Whats App.

Whilst this works ok for notifying parents of training and match schedules etc some of the more serious coaching and back room chats exist only in the realm of Whats App.

Being able to pull aspects of these chats out of one channel and push them into say a Committee channel would be ideal.

Thanks

Scobblelotcher

1,724 posts

143 months

Monday 22nd October 2018
quotequote all
JustALooseScrew said:
Scobblelotcher said:
Sounds like Slack would be perfect for your team.
Do you know if you can host and run Slack on your own server?

I'm so wary these days of solutions that are 'cloud' based subscriptions.

For one club I'm involved with, day to day everything is done via Whats App.

Whilst this works ok for notifying parents of training and match schedules etc some of the more serious coaching and back room chats exist only in the realm of Whats App.

Being able to pull aspects of these chats out of one channel and push them into say a Committee channel would be ideal.

Thanks
Not entirely however there are various security controls that can be put into place to help, it maybe worth reading their security page here: https://slack.com/security

JustALooseScrew

1,154 posts

98 months

Monday 22nd October 2018
quotequote all
Scobblelotcher said:
Not entirely however there are various security controls that can be put into place to help, it maybe worth reading their security page here: https://slack.com/security
Thanks for the reply, but that wasn't quite what I was asking.
I'm more concerned about running their code on our own server and there fore having root access to the data we put into their software/database.

From a personal point of view I would want their code running on my server, not on their hosted server.

There's a heap of reasons for adopting this approach which I'm sure you are aware of, just look at some of the fk ups that are occurring in the JavaScript CDN domain.

My concern would be, beside the usual panic of 'Woo hoo they are selling our emails init', I would be advising a club that yes you might need some technical people to maintain this code, but at the end of the day, if you are not going to run with a big player like Google or Facebook etc, then you might lose all your data one day.

Thoughts?


Bullitt Five-Oh

876 posts

98 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Typical hipster from silicon valley: Hey grandpa, it's you who is the problem not the revolutionary, magical software that is valued at 30000billion bitcoinz. If it wasn't good do you think the valuation would be this high?