Help needed with Electro acoustic guitar selection
Help needed with Electro acoustic guitar selection
Author
Discussion

The jiffle king

Original Poster:

7,481 posts

287 months

Saturday 20th October 2018
quotequote all
I'm an occasional guitar player and really enjoy my Simon & Patrick Acoustic which I've had for a number of years. Its full bodied and I like playing it, but I've promised my self an electro acoustic for some time and I'm in a position to buy one.

What I'm looking for is an electro-acoustic cutaway which is no more than 500GBP, but ideally less. What I'd like to play on it is Nick Drake songs, 90's indie like the Wonder Stuff, and classics such as Del Amitri

I'd like a smallish amp to go with it as it's for personal use rather than playing with others although we live away from others, so I can make as much noise as I like.

Musical likes have changed from Neds Atomic dustbin, to The Boo Radleys, I am arrows, Oasis, Tired Pony, The Manics, The Smiths, Barnaby Bright, Nick Drake, so reasonable eclectic

I've thought about a Yamaha APx600 or an Yamaha FGX800C

What I'm looking for are some suggestions on what to go and try at a shop. I've not been in a guitar shop in nearly 20 years and so would like an idea of what might work with what I want to play before going in.

Many Thanks in advance



otherman

2,265 posts

194 months

Sunday 21st October 2018
quotequote all
Come and join us over at thegearpage.net

You'll get plenty of answers over there. This isn't my department, but there'll be people.

ChrisPackit

274 posts

152 months

Monday 22nd October 2018
quotequote all
I did a similar thing a few years ago, albeit my budget was £1500. I spent a few hours playing Martins, Taylors, Takemines etc and chose what I thought sounded best, which ended up being a Taylor 314ci.

I'd possibly go a play a few under £1000 mark at your local store and would then consider looking out for used versions of these guitars and see if you can get one closer to your budget. There seems to be a big difference in price between laminate backs and solid backs and I think a new £500 laminate back wouldn't be as good as a used solid wood.

Just my thoughts...

rolo0151

276 posts

192 months

Thursday 25th October 2018
quotequote all
I worked for a large music store for a while.
Those Yamaha apx are terrible in my opinion. Sound really thin unless they’re plugged in & have a very generic electro acoustic tone when plugged in.

The Taylor 114ce is a cracking all rounder as is the Yamaha ls16.

If you’re looking for that Nick Drake tone try out an all Mahogany. I’ve got a guild m120e & it is very much the tone Nick had. Sounds stunning with his alternate tunings. Admittedly it’s not as nice a tone once plugged in, few are though.


The jiffle king said:
I'm an occasional guitar player and really enjoy my Simon & Patrick Acoustic which I've had for a number of years. Its full bodied and I like playing it, but I've promised my self an electro acoustic for some time and I'm in a position to buy one.

What I'm looking for is an electro-acoustic cutaway which is no more than 500GBP, but ideally less. What I'd like to play on it is Nick Drake songs, 90's indie like the Wonder Stuff, and classics such as Del Amitri

I'd like a smallish amp to go with it as it's for personal use rather than playing with others although we live away from others, so I can make as much noise as I like.

Musical likes have changed from Neds Atomic dustbin, to The Boo Radleys, I am arrows, Oasis, Tired Pony, The Manics, The Smiths, Barnaby Bright, Nick Drake, so reasonable eclectic

I've thought about a Yamaha APx600 or an Yamaha FGX800C

What I'm looking for are some suggestions on what to go and try at a shop. I've not been in a guitar shop in nearly 20 years and so would like an idea of what might work with what I want to play before going in.

Many Thanks in advance

The jiffle king

Original Poster:

7,481 posts

287 months

Friday 26th October 2018
quotequote all
Many thanks, I'll go to a store and try. I might increase the budget a little as well to bring more into my range

rolo0151

276 posts

192 months

Friday 26th October 2018
quotequote all
The cork sniffers out there will insist an “all solid” guitar is the only way to go but I just go of how each individual instrument feels.

I’d trade a bit of tone for a more playable guitar.

Just try them all. Different body shapes, necks, woods & don’t led by the brand name. Let us know how you get on 👍🏻



The jiffle king said:
Many thanks, I'll go to a store and try. I might increase the budget a little as well to bring more into my range