Windows XP machine doing something odd
Windows XP machine doing something odd
Author
Discussion

red_slr

Original Poster:

20,986 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
I run a windows XP machine for taking orders at our trade counter. Its pretty simple its got nothing fancy on it just an old IBM machine from 15 years ago.

It runs XP and normally no issues. About 2 weeks ago it kept crashing, now it suddenly changes its appearance.

Its gone from the normal XP look to windows 98. Then it flips back on its own. It did it this morning.

I assume that's a major problem? Has it maybe been hacked? Or is it a known issue. I have looked on google and cant see anyone else asking about it.

red_slr

Original Poster:

20,986 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
So from this



To this, and then back again


WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
red_slr said:
I run a windows XP machine for taking orders at our trade counter. Its pretty simple its got nothing fancy on it just an old IBM machine from 15 years ago.

It runs XP and normally no issues. About 2 weeks ago it kept crashing, now it suddenly changes its appearance.

Its gone from the normal XP look to windows 98. Then it flips back on its own. It did it this morning.

I assume that's a major problem? Has it maybe been hacked? Or is it a known issue. I have looked on google and cant see anyone else asking about it.
It's time to buy a new machine, XP went unsupported years ago. I'd use the time you have available to get a backup of whatever you need before it dies completely.

I wouldn't trust a fifteen year old HDD to run a business function smile

red_slr

Original Poster:

20,986 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
It does not hold any data, everything is on the cloud all it does is act as a terminal basically.

WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
That *looks* like it's logged on using a different profile/user account as there are different icons on the desktop etc.

HRL

3,361 posts

250 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
Can’t you get a new PC with Win 10 and then run XP in a VM if you really must?

I’d think any PC now running XP is probably fit for the bin anyway.

red_slr

Original Poster:

20,986 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
WinstonWolf said:
That *looks* like it's logged on using a different profile/user account as there are different icons on the desktop etc.
Sorry its just examples I found on the web.

WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
red_slr said:
WinstonWolf said:
That *looks* like it's logged on using a different profile/user account as there are different icons on the desktop etc.
Sorry its just examples I found on the web.
Well I was bloody right then tongue out

Honestly, it's really not worth bothering with. You've had your money's worth if it isn't a hardware issue it will be shortly.

jamoor

14,506 posts

246 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
I am not one for upgrading for the sakes of upgrading, but its possible that your computer has reached the end of its working life, considering they are so cheap just purchase a new one.

daddy cool

4,108 posts

260 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
red_slr said:
Its gone from the normal XP look to windows 98. Then it flips back on its own. It did it this morning.
It flips back of its own volition while using it? Or if you restart during the working day?
I wonder if the hearing aid battery embedded in the motherboard is dead, and its forgetting the profiles overnight while switched off? They tend to only last ~10 years...

Jakeztx

85 posts

137 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
What is happening here as far as i can tell, is Windows is auto switching to the Classic theme (Right click desktop, Properties, Change the theme)

It may be doing this automatically based on Power consumption or performance. I would suggest maybe the GPU (I-GPU?) is going wobbly and when it drops in performance XP determines it doesnt have the Horsepower to drive the themes, switching you automatically to the more power-friendly Classic theme....

That being said. I am 22, I was 10 when XP was replaced.

4x4Tyke

6,506 posts

163 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
That looks like Windows safe mode, that could be due to an intermittent hardware problem or software corruption.

Given this is 15 years old, it is probably not worth fixing, it would likely cost more than it is worth.

Since you are only using this as a terminal, You could pick up a very cheap desktop that would do this for under £150 or so.

REFURBISHED Dell Optiplex 780 SFF Desktop

https://www.ebuyer.com/760715-refurbished-dell-opt...

Or £200 or so for something brand new.

https://www.ebuyer.com/store/Computer/cat/Desktop-...

TheAngryDog

13,315 posts

240 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
Exposing a Windows XP machine to the internet isn't good. As the machine holds no data and is just used to access a website then I would suggest just buying the cheapest desktop you can with Windows 10 on it.

Lemming Train

5,567 posts

103 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
He doesn't want to buy a new one! He wants to fix the one he's got that was working fine up until recently. Why does everyone jump in straight away with the same default "chuck it in the bin, buy a new one" answer? It could be something really simple and easy to fix if someone happens to see the thread that's had the exact same issue themselves. Changing all your hardware just because MS has deemed it to be obsolete is nonsense and ridiculously wasteful.

OP if you're anywhere near Bradford I have a Compaq tower here with XP Pro on it that you can have if it helps. No crapware on it and only had light use so it'd be fine for your needs. It has a gig of RAM and an 80 gig HDD iirc. I should have thrown it in bin a decade ago according to the 'experts' here.

WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
Lemming Train said:
He doesn't want to buy a new one! He wants to fix the one he's got that was working fine up until recently. Why does everyone jump in straight away with the same default "chuck it in the bin, buy a new one" answer? It could be something really simple and easy to fix if someone happens to see the thread that's had the exact same issue themselves. Changing all your hardware just because MS has deemed it to be obsolete is nonsense and ridiculously wasteful.

OP if you're anywhere near Bradford I have a Compaq tower here with XP Pro on it that you can have if it helps. No crapware on it and only had light use so it'd be fine for your needs. It has a gig of RAM and an 80 gig HDD iirc. I should have thrown it in bin a decade ago according to the 'experts' here.
29 years of experience in my case, but what do I know tongue out

red_slr

Original Poster:

20,986 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
Cheers all, thanks LT that's a kind offer.

So long as its not a virus / hacker trying anything weird I am happy to leave it as it is.



4x4Tyke

6,506 posts

163 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
Lemming Train said:
He doesn't want to buy a new one! He wants to fix the one he's got that was working fine up until recently. Why does everyone jump in straight away with the same default "chuck it in the bin, buy a new one" answer? It could be something really simple and easy to fix if someone happens to see the thread that's had the exact same issue themselves. Changing all your hardware just because MS has deemed it to be obsolete is nonsense and ridiculously wasteful.

OP if you're anywhere near Bradford I have a Compaq tower here with XP Pro on it that you can have if it helps. No crapware on it and only had light use so it'd be fine for your needs. It has a gig of RAM and an 80 gig HDD iirc. I should have thrown it in bin a decade ago according to the 'experts' here.
So you don't know what the problem is but still feel entitled to state it is easy to fix, that is classic example of Dunning Kruger. It might be an easy fix, it might not. The OP has show by asking here that his skills in diagnosing this are limited, he recognises his limits, you do not. It could be a duff cmos battery, a £5 part, but diagnosing that will cost £60 at PC world and perhaps £50 at an indy.

As to experience I have seen similar issues, the dropping into and out of safe mode is actually very telling. It has nearly always been failing hardware, typically the MB or Graphics card, but could also be intermittent read errors on the HD. To be certain replacing any of these parts with their legacy equivalent will be more pricey than replacing the whole thing. Legacy parts get more expensive again after they've passed out of mainstream usage.

Finding out and fixing it is very likely to cost more than the £100 replacement I suggested and quite possible more than the £200 option.

Finally as others have mentioned XP is riddled with security holes, look at the NHS hack last year. The options I suggested included Windows 10 which would avoid this risk and still come in less than a cheap fix plus consumer OS upgrade.


Funk

27,819 posts

240 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
Lemming Train said:
He doesn't want to buy a new one! He wants to fix the one he's got that was working fine up until recently. Why does everyone jump in straight away with the same default "chuck it in the bin, buy a new one" answer? It could be something really simple and easy to fix if someone happens to see the thread that's had the exact same issue themselves. Changing all your hardware just because MS has deemed it to be obsolete is nonsense and ridiculously wasteful.

OP if you're anywhere near Bradford I have a Compaq tower here with XP Pro on it that you can have if it helps. No crapware on it and only had light use so it'd be fine for your needs. It has a gig of RAM and an 80 gig HDD iirc. I should have thrown it in bin a decade ago according to the 'experts' here.
It's a security risk, that's why. Especially where a business is concerned. Also it's not worth the time or money to try and 'fix' it.

TheAngryDog said:
Exposing a Windows XP machine to the internet isn't good. As the machine holds no data and is just used to access a website then I would suggest just buying the cheapest desktop you can with Windows 10 on it.
Is the correct answer.

4x4Tyke said:
So you don't know what the problem is but still feel entitled to state it is easy to fix, that is classic example of Dunning Kruger. It might be an easy fix, it might not. The OP has show by asking here that his skills in diagnosing this are limited, he recognises his limits, you do not. It could be a duff cmos battery, a £5 part, but diagnosing that will cost £60 at PC world and perhaps £50 at an indy.

As to experience I have seen similar issues, the dropping into and out of safe mode is actually very telling. It has nearly always been failing hardware, typically the MB or Graphics card, but could also be intermittent read errors on the HD. To be certain replacing any of these parts with their legacy equivalent will be more pricey than replacing the whole thing. Legacy parts get more expensive again after they've passed out of mainstream usage.

Finding out and fixing it is very likely to cost more than the £100 replacement I suggested and quite possible more than the £200 option.

Finally as others have mentioned XP is riddled with security holes, look at the NHS hack last year. The options I suggested included Windows 10 which would avoid this risk and still come in less than a cheap fix plus consumer OS upgrade.
Is also a correct answer.

red_slr

Original Poster:

20,986 posts

220 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
OK thanks again guys lets not get into keyboards at dawn, we don't do a lot of counter work between now and the new year so it will do for now will then look to replace it in the new year. Thanks smilesmile

Jinx

12,023 posts

291 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2018
quotequote all
4x4Tyke said:
Legacy parts get more expensive again after they've passed out of mainstream usage.
Agreed with most but not necessarily the above. I have a box of DDR memory (512MB sticks) that he can have for postage costs smile and plenty of second hand stuff you can find for cheap .