Help me with my network set up
Discussion
So i'm having some new plugs put into my lounge which will require the floorboards to come up in an area which has given me an opportunity to move some IT equipment around.
I want to move my NAS, Virgin Modem & PI onto a shelf in a cupboard under the the stairs so i have more room behind my TV. My question is can I have two switches on the same network? I plan on having a 4 port switch behind the TV for Sky, Linksys router, TV & sonos speaker & then another 4 port switch under the stairs for Virgin modem, PI & NAS but i am just wondering if this could become an issue and am i better having 1 switch and then running multiple cat 6 cables to over 10m to the TV unit? My dad has two switches in his house and they seem to work fine but just want to check really.
i've drawn a very crude drawing to show what i'm after.

I want to move my NAS, Virgin Modem & PI onto a shelf in a cupboard under the the stairs so i have more room behind my TV. My question is can I have two switches on the same network? I plan on having a 4 port switch behind the TV for Sky, Linksys router, TV & sonos speaker & then another 4 port switch under the stairs for Virgin modem, PI & NAS but i am just wondering if this could become an issue and am i better having 1 switch and then running multiple cat 6 cables to over 10m to the TV unit? My dad has two switches in his house and they seem to work fine but just want to check really.
i've drawn a very crude drawing to show what i'm after.
You can have as many switches as you want, but you cannot create a loop.
That setup to me looks like it has a loop.
Although there are only 2 switches, your router most likely has a built in switch, and since both other switches connect to it and connect to each other there is a loop.
So you should probably lose the link between the 2 switches although depending or usage it might be more efficient to daisy chain the 2 switches by removing one of the links to the router instead.
That setup to me looks like it has a loop.
Although there are only 2 switches, your router most likely has a built in switch, and since both other switches connect to it and connect to each other there is a loop.
So you should probably lose the link between the 2 switches although depending or usage it might be more efficient to daisy chain the 2 switches by removing one of the links to the router instead.
Edited by ging84 on Tuesday 30th October 20:41
Edited by ging84 on Tuesday 30th October 20:42
ging84 said:
You can have as many switches as you want, but you cannot create a loop.
That setup to me looks like it has a loop.
Although there are only switches, your router most likely has a built in switch, and since both other switches connect to it and connect to each other there is a loop.
So you should probably lose the link between the 2 switches although depending or usage it might be more efficient to daisy chain the 2 routers by removing one of the links to the router instead.
Thanks for the feedback. So my Virgin box is in modem mode and my router only had two ethernet ports so it would be Virgin > to router >router to switch and then switch > switch if that makes sense. Then on switch one will be my router, TV, sky box then on the other switch NAS & pi. That setup to me looks like it has a loop.
Although there are only switches, your router most likely has a built in switch, and since both other switches connect to it and connect to each other there is a loop.
So you should probably lose the link between the 2 switches although depending or usage it might be more efficient to daisy chain the 2 routers by removing one of the links to the router instead.
Yes that makes sense.
Modem to router, as that needs to happen.
Then router to switch (which you can hang anything off)
Then switch to switch, to switch, to switch , and so on. All of which you can hang anything off. You can have switched off each switch too going in other directions.
All you have to avoid is a loop. No switch can connect to another switch more than once. No device (router - which you can think of as a switch too, or pc with multiple lan ports) can connect to the network anywhere more than once (unless you are setting up network teaming which you don't need to worry about).
My network is like this (an example for you). (Gb = Gigabit , all other is 100Mb)
BT Socket - WiFi router with 4 Gb ports (model built in) - connected to this are:
- desktop pc (Gb)
- Nas raid (Gb)
- Smart things hub
- 4 port gigabit switch (call this switch A)
- off the switch are:
-Three @ home box
- Homeplug Ethernet over power adapter
-another Homeplug in my office. Off this is :
--a WiFi router with the router disabled so it is just a WiFi extender . Off this: any WiFi devices.
Switch A goes to an 8 port Gigabit switch behind my TV). Call this switch B
Off switch B are :
- TV
- You view
- WD TV (Gb)
- Sonos
- Slingbox (Gb)
- Logitech. Harmony hub
- 50ft cable to my garage / workshop to another WiFi router in WiFi mode only (router disabled) call this switch B
Off switch B in my garage (Gb)
- WiFi devices - any
- ipcams x2
- Sonos
The Sonos in the garage has 4 LAN ports, 3 free, which are all usable at 100Mb.
As you can see my routers and switches are daisy chained, but it also has a star element where switch A spurs off via Homeplug to my office WiFi router (which you can think of as another switch)
Modem to router, as that needs to happen.
Then router to switch (which you can hang anything off)
Then switch to switch, to switch, to switch , and so on. All of which you can hang anything off. You can have switched off each switch too going in other directions.
All you have to avoid is a loop. No switch can connect to another switch more than once. No device (router - which you can think of as a switch too, or pc with multiple lan ports) can connect to the network anywhere more than once (unless you are setting up network teaming which you don't need to worry about).
My network is like this (an example for you). (Gb = Gigabit , all other is 100Mb)
BT Socket - WiFi router with 4 Gb ports (model built in) - connected to this are:
- desktop pc (Gb)
- Nas raid (Gb)
- Smart things hub
- 4 port gigabit switch (call this switch A)
- off the switch are:
-Three @ home box
- Homeplug Ethernet over power adapter
-another Homeplug in my office. Off this is :
--a WiFi router with the router disabled so it is just a WiFi extender . Off this: any WiFi devices.
Switch A goes to an 8 port Gigabit switch behind my TV). Call this switch B
Off switch B are :
- TV
- You view
- WD TV (Gb)
- Sonos
- Slingbox (Gb)
- Logitech. Harmony hub
- 50ft cable to my garage / workshop to another WiFi router in WiFi mode only (router disabled) call this switch B
Off switch B in my garage (Gb)
- WiFi devices - any
- ipcams x2
- Sonos
The Sonos in the garage has 4 LAN ports, 3 free, which are all usable at 100Mb.
As you can see my routers and switches are daisy chained, but it also has a star element where switch A spurs off via Homeplug to my office WiFi router (which you can think of as another switch)
Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 31st October 08:25
Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 31st October 08:26
That's true, and if you have the opportunity, then cables are always best direct, but in most households, a Gb backbone is plenty as long as you are not maxing it out with multiple devices at the same time.
Only time I max mine out is large file transfers from NAS to PC, and that's only going through one switch.
Hence my Desktop & NAS are on the same switch (my internet router/AP).
Just takes a little planning as to your expected needs. Nothing else on my LAN can max out a Gb connection, even through 2 switches.
Only time I max mine out is large file transfers from NAS to PC, and that's only going through one switch.
Hence my Desktop & NAS are on the same switch (my internet router/AP).
Just takes a little planning as to your expected needs. Nothing else on my LAN can max out a Gb connection, even through 2 switches.
Nothing you'd ever notice. Bear in mind you are most likely using Gigabit switches, and even the best fibre broadband is around 80Mbs (your Gb switch is 1000Mbs). You are not even touching 1/10th of the bandwidth, and the negotiations of a couple of switches is such a small overhead it would not be noticable.
Then there is your broacast domain - which grows more quickly on series (daisy chain ) networks, and creates a traffic burden - but again - on a domestic installtion it just isn't an issue. It effects big networks.
Put it this way, I use to create office LANs, you'd have backbone Gb switches, and each of these ports fed a distributor switch that then fed 6-10 desks. No one even noticed any slow down. Of course modern office buildings have cat5 run to every desk which terminate in a cabinet that you fill with switches, that then feed back to the server room to master switches via fibre cables.
Even in a reasonly well designed commercial setup you can end up with Server to Gb Switch, then Gb switch to floor switch, then floor switch to desktops. So you are already hopping through two switches (floor and server) before you reach the server.
In a domestic environment, cabling cat 5 all over the place from a central location is a nice luxury of you can, but really totally unnecessary and expensive unless you plan running server farms :-)
We are talking home lans here, so daisy chain away - it'll be perfectly fine. I'm a heavy and rather techy user, and it's good enough for me!
Then there is your broacast domain - which grows more quickly on series (daisy chain ) networks, and creates a traffic burden - but again - on a domestic installtion it just isn't an issue. It effects big networks.
Put it this way, I use to create office LANs, you'd have backbone Gb switches, and each of these ports fed a distributor switch that then fed 6-10 desks. No one even noticed any slow down. Of course modern office buildings have cat5 run to every desk which terminate in a cabinet that you fill with switches, that then feed back to the server room to master switches via fibre cables.
Even in a reasonly well designed commercial setup you can end up with Server to Gb Switch, then Gb switch to floor switch, then floor switch to desktops. So you are already hopping through two switches (floor and server) before you reach the server.
In a domestic environment, cabling cat 5 all over the place from a central location is a nice luxury of you can, but really totally unnecessary and expensive unless you plan running server farms :-)
We are talking home lans here, so daisy chain away - it'll be perfectly fine. I'm a heavy and rather techy user, and it's good enough for me!
Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 31st October 15:30
Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 31st October 15:33
RogerDodger said:
lol - yeah - switches. When you can get a 4 port switch for £15 I can't even imagine hubs exist any more? You can get an 8 port managed switch for £32.50 (and no, I don't bother with managed switches in my home :-) )
The first switch I ever put in was a 10Mb Kalpana Etherswitch, it cost circa £10K for an eight port AUI device 
Thanks everyone I have got my set up planned now and have my dad coming up next weekend to help me take up the floor boards so I can run the wires through to the cupboard. Going to put the modem, router, NAS, and switch in there. I'm also going to run 4 cat6 cables from.thr lounge and plug the devices in the lounge into that and then into the switch to hook everything up. I was going to run a 10m hdmi cable to the TV but from advice I'm just going to stick it behind the TV now.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



