Best Antivirus *for small business*, with central management
Discussion
What's thought to be the best Antivirus (and Antimalware too) for a small business of about 40 computers (almost all Windows 10) and approx 5 win2012+ servers these days?
I know that the built in Windows Defender is quite well regarded, however what's important in this case is I want some sort of central management/admin console that can report/email on detections and successful definitions updates, and let me set and adjust various policies in one place, rather than have to go and modify each individual computer.
I know I can set some of the Windows Defender behaviours through Group Policy but that's no good when a lot of the client machines are frequently out of the office, and there's no central reporting to speak of. Also I don't believe Defender works on servers.
It would be ideal if the central management console is web/cloud based but being installed to an internal server would be OK too.
Currently use McAfee's small biz suite, their previous SMB products were excellent but these days they force you to manage things with a version of ePO, which might be great when you've got thousands of client machines and full time staff to manage it but it's way over the top for a small business. Also the McAfee company is a total nightmare to deal with at renewal time or to get support from when necessary.
Someone recommended Webroot to me, I had a look at that and it did have a fairly reasonable central cloud-based management and reporting portal, but the product itself on the end computers is just dire, ranging from troublesome to install, through simply not working, to downright making some PCs unusable.
What should I look at next for a 40 computer installation, Sophos is one that I've heard reasonable comments on?
Thanks
I know that the built in Windows Defender is quite well regarded, however what's important in this case is I want some sort of central management/admin console that can report/email on detections and successful definitions updates, and let me set and adjust various policies in one place, rather than have to go and modify each individual computer.
I know I can set some of the Windows Defender behaviours through Group Policy but that's no good when a lot of the client machines are frequently out of the office, and there's no central reporting to speak of. Also I don't believe Defender works on servers.
It would be ideal if the central management console is web/cloud based but being installed to an internal server would be OK too.
Currently use McAfee's small biz suite, their previous SMB products were excellent but these days they force you to manage things with a version of ePO, which might be great when you've got thousands of client machines and full time staff to manage it but it's way over the top for a small business. Also the McAfee company is a total nightmare to deal with at renewal time or to get support from when necessary.
Someone recommended Webroot to me, I had a look at that and it did have a fairly reasonable central cloud-based management and reporting portal, but the product itself on the end computers is just dire, ranging from troublesome to install, through simply not working, to downright making some PCs unusable.
What should I look at next for a 40 computer installation, Sophos is one that I've heard reasonable comments on?
Thanks
I would go Eset or Sophos. Eset’s management is a locally installed app or VM which is the only downside there (or upside...) Sophos has more cloudy management. They’re both solid non-cheesy programs.
PS, I did an EPO to Eset migration a few months ago, I remember it being a bit of a PITA to bulk remove the management agents, which would then reinstall all the mcafee stuff randomly a few hours after you removed it. There’s a procedure.
eta, just to clarify, eset management is web based, it's just installed on-prem.
PS, I did an EPO to Eset migration a few months ago, I remember it being a bit of a PITA to bulk remove the management agents, which would then reinstall all the mcafee stuff randomly a few hours after you removed it. There’s a procedure.
eta, just to clarify, eset management is web based, it's just installed on-prem.
Edited by buggalugs on Wednesday 14th November 09:22
I have pm'd you.
I went through the same selection process when deciding not only what solution to use in house, but as an IT company, which to recommend & sell.
You will hear good and bad experiences about all the AV vendors. Two examples you mention that split opinion are Windows Defender & EPO.
Some people run Defender with no problems, and love it, while others do not think it is as good as the solutions from other leading vendors. My own caution comes from the surprisingly small number of security focussed organisations that use it, and the opinion of technical AV developers that I know. Similarly with EPO - some people (often those that have had the time to learn how to use it to best effect) love it, and appreciate the granularity it gives, others find it to difficult for what they require. (I like it, but think that it is best suited to larger organisations, that have the appropriate resources to manage it effectively).
There is usually a choice in approach (I'll probably get flamed for this!). Do you go with one of the 'leading' vendors (Symantec, McAfee, Sophos etc), the cheap vendors (AVG, ESET, BullGuard etc), or the new runners (CarbonBlack, Cylance etc). The answer to that will depend on your approach to security, cost, etc,
The other thing to consider is performance. Extra functions carried out by the AV engine(s) on a client will usually result in better protection, but higher overhead. So if you are already running machines that are old and struggling on performance, you may need to consider carefully. Because all of the vendors bundle their solutions in different ways, with different names, it can be difficult to do a like for like comparison. But, the cheaper vendors will usually sell based on performance, because they know their engines perform better than the leading vendors, who are often doing more.... This is where the 2nd Gen' vendors try to solve a problem a different way, eliminating this issue altogether.
Back to your question - Sophos build an enterprise solution, targeted your size of businesses. They invest heavily in their solutions, both through internal development and acquisition which means they have the requirements of their target audience well covered. As is typical with Sophos, they came to market quite late with their cloud console, but when they did, it is very good. It allows the management of the AV, and the majority of their other solutions to all be managed from the same console (Thier Firewall, Envryption, Mail Gateway, Web Gateway, Wi-Fi etc). This joined up approach also offers some security benefits (such as the ability for a device to be isolated by the firewall in the event of an infection) .
Yes- I am biased because we sell, install and support Sophos, however, the reason we sell Sophos because I believe it is the best at meeting the needs of their target customer.
All very subjective, but PM me if you would like to talk this through any further.
I went through the same selection process when deciding not only what solution to use in house, but as an IT company, which to recommend & sell.
You will hear good and bad experiences about all the AV vendors. Two examples you mention that split opinion are Windows Defender & EPO.
Some people run Defender with no problems, and love it, while others do not think it is as good as the solutions from other leading vendors. My own caution comes from the surprisingly small number of security focussed organisations that use it, and the opinion of technical AV developers that I know. Similarly with EPO - some people (often those that have had the time to learn how to use it to best effect) love it, and appreciate the granularity it gives, others find it to difficult for what they require. (I like it, but think that it is best suited to larger organisations, that have the appropriate resources to manage it effectively).
There is usually a choice in approach (I'll probably get flamed for this!). Do you go with one of the 'leading' vendors (Symantec, McAfee, Sophos etc), the cheap vendors (AVG, ESET, BullGuard etc), or the new runners (CarbonBlack, Cylance etc). The answer to that will depend on your approach to security, cost, etc,
The other thing to consider is performance. Extra functions carried out by the AV engine(s) on a client will usually result in better protection, but higher overhead. So if you are already running machines that are old and struggling on performance, you may need to consider carefully. Because all of the vendors bundle their solutions in different ways, with different names, it can be difficult to do a like for like comparison. But, the cheaper vendors will usually sell based on performance, because they know their engines perform better than the leading vendors, who are often doing more.... This is where the 2nd Gen' vendors try to solve a problem a different way, eliminating this issue altogether.
Back to your question - Sophos build an enterprise solution, targeted your size of businesses. They invest heavily in their solutions, both through internal development and acquisition which means they have the requirements of their target audience well covered. As is typical with Sophos, they came to market quite late with their cloud console, but when they did, it is very good. It allows the management of the AV, and the majority of their other solutions to all be managed from the same console (Thier Firewall, Envryption, Mail Gateway, Web Gateway, Wi-Fi etc). This joined up approach also offers some security benefits (such as the ability for a device to be isolated by the firewall in the event of an infection) .
Yes- I am biased because we sell, install and support Sophos, however, the reason we sell Sophos because I believe it is the best at meeting the needs of their target customer.
All very subjective, but PM me if you would like to talk this through any further.
buggalugs said:
I would go Eset or Sophos. Eset’s management is a locally installed app or VM which is the only downside there (or upside...) Sophos has more cloudy management. They’re both solid non-cheesy programs.
PS, I did an EPO to Eset migration a few months ago, I remember it being a bit of a PITA to bulk remove the management agents, which would then reinstall all the mcafee stuff randomly a few hours after you removed it. There’s a procedure.
eta, just to clarify, eset management is web based, it's just installed on-prem.
ESET is very good and easy to manage.PS, I did an EPO to Eset migration a few months ago, I remember it being a bit of a PITA to bulk remove the management agents, which would then reinstall all the mcafee stuff randomly a few hours after you removed it. There’s a procedure.
eta, just to clarify, eset management is web based, it's just installed on-prem.
Edited by buggalugs on Wednesday 14th November 09:22
Another few to consider - Webroot - as generally their product is sold and managed by partners if you want it to be.
Symantec have SEP Cloud - easy to set up and then forget- it does it's thing very well and is comprehensive in capabilities.
I've used Sophos in the past - very simple to use console, but not too impressed by detection rates, or more to the point, what it didn't stop.
I concur with the Mcafee removal issues - it's a pain. Seek help before you start.
Some of the other vendors have AV agent removal tools - which can offer a cleaner uninstall than using the current vendors own tool.
EPO is another matter though.
Symantec have SEP Cloud - easy to set up and then forget- it does it's thing very well and is comprehensive in capabilities.
I've used Sophos in the past - very simple to use console, but not too impressed by detection rates, or more to the point, what it didn't stop.
I concur with the Mcafee removal issues - it's a pain. Seek help before you start.
Some of the other vendors have AV agent removal tools - which can offer a cleaner uninstall than using the current vendors own tool.
EPO is another matter though.
Many thanks for the comments and opinions (and Australiam for your PM - my customer for this already has a good software reseller that they'll want to stick with but I'll keep your details in case same comes up with any of my other customers).
Sophos and Eset are the two that I keep hearing recommended, both here and other security people I've asked, so I'm going to check them out in the next few days and see how I get on.
Sophos and Eset are the two that I keep hearing recommended, both here and other security people I've asked, so I'm going to check them out in the next few days and see how I get on.
A lot of the new ones mentioned like CarbonBlack, Cylance, Avecto, Sentinel One etc have a minimum order quantity that rules out small businesses. Not sure on Webroot, always thought that was the bottom of the market for cost and capability.
Don't know anything about Eset but hear good stuff about Sophos in general, wouldn't touch McAfee or Symantec - they're more enterprise based and anybody looking at Kaspersky needs their head examined.
Make sure you do a lot of the other basics that small businesses often neglect, CIS basic controls, remove local admin and please use 2FA where possible inc cloud services, it's not expensive.
Don't know anything about Eset but hear good stuff about Sophos in general, wouldn't touch McAfee or Symantec - they're more enterprise based and anybody looking at Kaspersky needs their head examined.
Make sure you do a lot of the other basics that small businesses often neglect, CIS basic controls, remove local admin and please use 2FA where possible inc cloud services, it's not expensive.
Really wish there was a clear winner for this as it's a particularly unimpressive area of software in my opinion. Many products cause problems/slowdowns or just constantly alert the user with messages that they don't understand.
I've been using Bitdefender gravity zone for some smaller businesses. It seems to perform well but I still think there are far too many options to configure. Quite a nice web dashboard though.
I've been using Bitdefender gravity zone for some smaller businesses. It seems to perform well but I still think there are far too many options to configure. Quite a nice web dashboard though.
Bikerjon said:
Really wish there was a clear winner for this as it's a particularly unimpressive area of software in my opinion. Many products cause problems/slowdowns or just constantly alert the user with messages that they don't understand.
I've been using Bitdefender gravity zone for some smaller businesses. It seems to perform well but I still think there are far too many options to configure. Quite a nice web dashboard though.
ESET ticks most of those boxes. You can run it silently if you want, you can define how accessible the UI is and it reports back to a central web console. You can also define global exceptions on scanning if you need to.I've been using Bitdefender gravity zone for some smaller businesses. It seems to perform well but I still think there are far too many options to configure. Quite a nice web dashboard though.
We run a central console here, our clients report to that and we set policies per company. It's pretty much set and forget, it emails me if I need to interact otherwise I only have a look about once per week to get a feel for what's going on out there.
I'm sure the other products can do similar but product familiarity is important. You can only get the best out of something if you know it inside out, ESET is quite straightforward to learn to the required level.
Bikerjon said:
Really wish there was a clear winner for this as it's a particularly unimpressive area of software in my opinion. Many products cause problems/slowdowns or just constantly alert the user with messages that they don't understand.
I've been using Bitdefender gravity zone for some smaller businesses. It seems to perform well but I still think there are far too many options to configure. Quite a nice web dashboard though.
I tried quite a few different AV's before going back to BitDefender. The interface is nice & setting policies is pretty easy. Moving from Kaspersky, it's like a breath of fresh air.I've been using Bitdefender gravity zone for some smaller businesses. It seems to perform well but I still think there are far too many options to configure. Quite a nice web dashboard though.
WinstonWolf said:
ESET ticks most of those boxes...
I know ESET has a strong following but I've tried using the standalone version a couple of times over the years and I've found it to be horribly over-complex. The Mac version destroyed performance on my own machine. The small business edition for just windows clients is possibly a much better prospect though.Bikerjon said:
WinstonWolf said:
ESET ticks most of those boxes...
I know ESET has a strong following but I've tried using the standalone version a couple of times over the years and I've found it to be horribly over-complex. The Mac version destroyed performance on my own machine. The small business edition for just windows clients is possibly a much better prospect though.Anything's better then EPo

Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


