HDDs for external storage - advice sought
HDDs for external storage - advice sought
Author
Discussion

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,027 posts

279 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
I used to be up to speed on such matters, but I’ve fallen behind of late. Can anyone help with a little query?

I record a fair bit of video as well as lots of images. I have websites as well.

I backup various files weekly to two external hdds and vital stuff to cloud storage as well. I need more storage and want to buy a 4TB hdd. Should I buy an hdd recommended for NAS? I note that some of these are 5400 rather than 7200 and I assume this is for life expectancy. Does this mean other aspects of the hdd are designed for longevity?

I’ve had two hdds, albeit over many years, have catastrophic failure. I’d put up with a lack of transfer speed for dependability.


mikef

6,158 posts

282 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
NAS disks are designed to work in multiple-disk RAID storage arrays, especially those with redundant disks for fail-over. They withstand more vibration than normal PC disks but on failure they retry fewer times before entering a fail state. If that’s not your setup I’d suggest a normal desktop disk with higher rotation speeds and more retry attempts before entering a fail state.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,027 posts

279 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
mikef said:
NAS disks are designed to work in multiple-disk RAID storage arrays, especially those with redundant disks for fail-over. They withstand more vibration than normal PC disks but on failure they retry fewer times before entering a fail state. If that’s not your setup I’d suggest a normal desktop disk with higher rotation speeds and more retry attempts before entering a fail state.
Thanks, mate. I appreciate the advice.


Penelope Stopit

11,209 posts

140 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
The problem with using a 4 Tb HDD is that if it fails there is possibly going to be a very high loss of data, it could be to your advantage to use 2 x 2 Tb HDD's
These are good https://www.icydock.com/goods_cat.php?id=112, they can be built into a desktop and allow the fitting and removing of a HDD as and when required

Off Topic - I'm nearly up and running here....it works.....cheers

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,027 posts

279 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
Penelope Stopit said:
The problem with using a 4 Tb HDD is that if it fails there is possibly going to be a very high loss of data, it could be to your advantage to use 2 x 2 Tb HDD's
These are good https://www.icydock.com/goods_cat.php?id=112, they can be built into a desktop and allow the fitting and removing of a HDD as and when required

Off Topic - I'm nearly up and running here....it works.....cheers
Thanks for that. I see what you are saying.

I've got a copy of everything so if the main one, in my desktop, dies on me, I've got the second one to get the data from. On top of that, for vital, cannot lose, stuff I also use cloud storage.

At the moment I've got a 2TB hdd for the OS, plus two x 3TB in my desktop. The backup hdds are switched off when I'm not transferring data so are on only overnight on a Saturday.

I'm a wee bit OTT with the way I go about it. I run a full scan with my virus protection software first, disconnect from the internet, scan the backup discs and then set things up, leaving the computer to do its thing. In the morning, everything's done.

On my first hdd failure I lost lots of data. One of the arms came adrift and scored one of the platters. Since then I've been suitably nervous. The second time an hdd failed it was much less of a problem. I had everything backed up. I lost a little but nothing that could not be replaced.

No system is perfect, but the chance of two hdds going down at the same time, and them being the two that are matched, is pretty low.

Mind you, if it happens tomorrow, I'm coming after you.


Penelope Stopit

11,209 posts

140 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
I reckon the majority of us aren't careful enough, your method in using AV scans and disconnecting from the internet is bomb proof
Should you need to come after me don't forget the Sun block