Phones are too big
Author
Discussion

HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I currently have an iPhone 6. Is it just me or are these 'phablet' shaped phones an ergonomic nightmare? Up until the iPhone 5, I could do most things one-handed without loosening my grip. It was narrow enough that I could reach most of the screen with my thumb while keeping my fingertips wrapped around the bezel. The thin, radiused edges of the 6 don't help either. It seems to want to leap out of my hand.

Anyway when phone manufacturers started deleting the bezel and the home button I thought 'great, that's going to make them a bit smaller while maintaining the screen size'. I went into Carphone Warehouse to look at my options.

Every current mid to high spec phone is the same size as the iPhone 6 or bigger. They've simply deleted the bezel and home button and made the screen an inch bigger instead!

I don't have small hands so surely I'm not alone in thinking phones are too big at the moment?

My iPhone is 4 years old now so I need to change it in the not-too-distant however I will hold off if anyone has a smaller phone in the pipeline?

Gary C

15,372 posts

210 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Strange the way things go

I used to have a phone that was only 2" by 1" and was almost to small to actually use smile

The flexible screen phones will probably be the answer

Du1point8

22,967 posts

223 months

h0b0

9,101 posts

227 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I went from iphone 6 to iphone 10S max. The transition to the new bigger phone was relatively painless compared to my expectations. I only went for the bigger phone due to the battery life. However, when I use my 6 for any reason it is then I realise how light it is.


I will say that the iphone 6 was the point that standard sized phones became uncomfortable. I used this in part to justify the Max I have now as the standard would not be ergonomically designed so now we are talking about 2 uncomfortable options I may as well get the one with the battery life.

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I'd say the 6 was about as big as a "phone" needs to be. Beyond that it's a tablet that makes calls. hehe

What I really want is them to be twice as thick, and that extra bulk to be all battery. And not an aftermarket add on, but nicely built into it. I can cope with the extra weight, that's not an issue. I want full brightness, playing games etc for many many hours, but still fit in a jacket pocket.

Luke.

12,049 posts

281 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I've got a Huawei Mate 20X Pro on it's way. 7.2" screen.... Can't wait.

MYOB

5,130 posts

169 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Yep they are far too big. Probably explains why Apple sales are falling. I'm on an 8, same size as the 6, after having an SE. I wished Apple released an upgraded SE and hope they will in the future.

boxst

3,806 posts

176 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I'm moving house and clearing out things and came across a box of old mobile phones. I remember being delighted at some of the really small phones. If I were a current drug dealer with no use for WhatsApp I would definitely be powering up my old 'v' phone.


HustleRussell

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
MYOB said:
Yep they are far too big. Probably explains why Apple sales are falling. I'm on an 8, same size as the 6, after having an SE. I wished Apple released an upgraded SE and hope they will in the future.
An updated SE would be perfect and there were rumours that there was one on the way but those rumours have fizzled out since the reveal of the XR and XS.

DaveTheRave87

2,155 posts

120 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
This explains everything:


SV_WDC

1,194 posts

120 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
A couple things most people don't seem to realise about the iPhone & using it one handed:

1. reachability. Look it up. Double tap of the home button brings the top half of the phone down to the bottom. Works on the new phones without Home button
2. One-handed keyboard (left or right) also supported on the iPhones

Am sure Android have similar features. The XS Max is definitely a two-handed phone though on account of how 'slippery' it is.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Phones have gotten so big I've had to change from jeans to cargo trousers for the bigger pockets smile

C0ffin D0dger

3,440 posts

176 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
V8covin said:
Phones have gotten so big I've had to change from jeans to cargo trousers for the bigger pockets smile
Soon be needing these bad boys:


otolith

69,715 posts

235 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Just bought my niece a cheap phone for her 12th birthday. Only important criterion - screen as large as possible. Got her a Huawei Y7 with a six inch screen. Technically inferior to many similarly priced offerings with smaller screens, but that was her only priority. Interestingly, brand wasn't important.

So maybe it's the yoof driving it.

Kewy

1,464 posts

125 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
It is funny how there was a time where phone companies were trying to make phones smaller and smaller, and then all of a sudden it flipped.

But as a user of 7 plus, and previously the 6 plus I think I have to disagree with it being an issue, at least for me. There are shortcuts (double click the button on iPhones) that mean you can still use them one handed, you just get used to it. It's not often I can't reach something on the screen and when I can't its just two clicks and it brings the page down so its reachable.

The trade off of having a bigger screen to watch videos and view/edit photos is much more important to me.

toon10

7,152 posts

188 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I went from a 4 to a 6S and thought it was too big. After a couple of weeks I couldn't even read the screen on the 4. I've just gone from my 6S to the XS Max last week and it's a revelation. I look at a lot more YouTube and video clips than I used to and the screen is so large I can comfortably watch a TV show on it. I'd not want to do that on my old 6S. In fact, once again, the 6S seems comically tiny now. There comes a point where a phone can be too large. I do find the XS is massive in my pocket and I'd certainly not want anything bigger. I have an iPad for that but having the larger screen is a huge upgrade to me. Then again, I've never tried to use my old iPhone single handed. It used to annoy me when I accidentally hit the home button in a certain way and the screen would shrink to allow single handed use. Pointless to me. My other half still uses the 5SE and I just laugh when she says "take a look at this on my phone." All I can see is colours and can't make anything else out! Then again, I'm a middle aged wreck and could probably do with an eye test.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
otolith said:
Just bought my niece a cheap phone for her 12th birthday. Only important criterion - screen as large as possible. Got her a Huawei Y7 with a six inch screen. Technically inferior to many similarly priced offerings with smaller screens, but that was her only priority. Interestingly, brand wasn't important.

So maybe it's the yoof driving it.
12 year girls are not driving the mobile phone screen size revolution.

otolith

69,715 posts

235 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Badda said:
otolith said:
Just bought my niece a cheap phone for her 12th birthday. Only important criterion - screen as large as possible. Got her a Huawei Y7 with a six inch screen. Technically inferior to many similarly priced offerings with smaller screens, but that was her only priority. Interestingly, brand wasn't important.

So maybe it's the yoof driving it.
12 year girls are not driving the mobile phone screen size revolution.
No, but I suspect that yoof in general are. Teens and 20-somethings.

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I've got a Moto G5+, which to within a couple of mm is the same size as the iPhone 6.

I don't have particularly large hands, and have no problem using it one-handed with just my thumb. I've just tried it out to see what I'm doing that's maybe different to the OP, and realised I don't feel the need to wrap my fingertips around it at all to prevent it from slipping out of my hands.

I then took the protective case off it - which obviously makes it slightly smaller - and nearly dropped it twice within 30 seconds!

This leads me to deduce that it's not the size of phones which is the problem, so much as using them without a case if they're made of slippery, shiny materials. smile

jonamv8

3,302 posts

197 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
I have a 7S and an SE, strangely prefer the SE great phone