Speeding Up Rural Internet
Author
Discussion

Doofus

Original Poster:

34,657 posts

204 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Imagine you have internet over a phone line and no fibre or OTA option. Ignore the costs, but if you installed a second line, and took on a second internet contract, and then split your devices between the two services, could you double your actual (not 'quoted maximum') speed, by reducing the 'load' by half, or would you be limited by some other factor?

In the past, I've used bonded ADSL in a commercial environment, but let's assume that's not available (and I'm not convinced it did any good anyway).

xjay1337

15,966 posts

149 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Doesn't work like that...

Doofus

Original Poster:

34,657 posts

204 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
xjay1337 said:
Doesn't work like that...
Brilliant. Thanks for the education.

xjay1337

15,966 posts

149 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Doofus said:
Brilliant. Thanks for the education.
Why waste the explanation?
At best you would double your total bandwidth capacity by connecting 2 devices to 2 routers which connect to the 2 different connections.

But you cannot double the speed for 1 device by utilising both .

You will have the same maximum speed.

Moving would be the best option.

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Doofus said:
Brilliant. Thanks for the education.
:-)

The 'last mile' to your property for ADSL is attenuated by the copper wire nailed to sticks. So adding a second ADSL line would only give the same Mbits/sec as the first, but you'd need a trick router to amalgamate both lines. You could then add more home devices before slow-down but the overall 'speed' would not increase but throughput would double. Monthly line rental costs would also double.

A lot of rural users are migrating to 3G/4G mobile broadband (MBB) into a wireless router. The router can be hooked up to external antennas and produce working broadband quite a long way from the cell-tower. Downside is the punitive data-capped tarrifs, but 100GB for £22 a month is around.

Three offer 100GB for £22, with bundled NetFlix and TV Player. ('Go Binge'):

http://www.three.co.uk/Discover/Devices/Huawei/Hom...

About £100 for the 3G/4G wifi router, £100 for an external wall mount or attic antenna, assuming there's some kind of mobile signal there. Vodafone and EE also have frequent MBB offers.

Getting MBB running on weak signals can be done, but it's a case of checking around the property with a mobile phone or a 3G/4G USB dongle and a handful of free PAYG sim cards.

3G gives around 10-20 Mb/s download over MBB with a 50% signal. 4G: up to 30-50Mb/s, or better.


So

28,176 posts

253 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Doofus said:
Imagine you have internet over a phone line and no fibre or OTA option. Ignore the costs, but if you installed a second line, and took on a second internet contract, and then split your devices between the two services, could you double your actual (not 'quoted maximum') speed, by reducing the 'load' by half, or would you be limited by some other factor?

In the past, I've used bonded ADSL in a commercial environment, but let's assume that's not available (and I'm not convinced it did any good anyway).
We are in the stocks and when we had a racy 1.5Mb service BT suggested a company that would do what you are suggesting. Helpfully I cannot recall who they were!



LotusMartin

1,127 posts

183 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
You can get bonded lines but it's very expensive, I opted for a 4g line in addition to my ADSL with a loadbalancer combining them, it's not as good as bonded but works well for me. Can route traffic to either line by IP address.

4g is as lot cheaper now than it used to be, I get 125gb for a little over £30 with EE and get almost 40mbps.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Be specific about what you are trying to do. Are you trying to connect 2 dial up modems because adsl is not available?

Doofus

Original Poster:

34,657 posts

204 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Thanks all. I wasn't expecting to go from, say, 1.5mb to 3mb. What I was saying is that in practice, each device is probably getting 0.8 or something, because they are all making demands on the same bandwidth.

Therefore, if the number of devices on the line was reduced, and the demand, say, halved then surely the actual speed attained would increase?

Doofus

Original Poster:

34,657 posts

204 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
xjay1337 said:
Why waste the explanation?

you cannot double the speed for 1 device by utilising both
Yeah, that's not what I asked.

Doofus

Original Poster:

34,657 posts

204 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Slushbox said:
:-)

The 'last mile' to your property for ADSL is attenuated by the copper wire nailed to sticks. So adding a second ADSL line would only give the same Mbits/sec as the first, but you'd need a trick router to amalgamate both lines. You could then add more home devices before slow-down but the overall 'speed' would not increase but throughput would double. Monthly line rental costs would also double.
That's what I was suggesting

Slushbox said:
A lot of rural users are migrating to 3G/4G mobile broadband (MBB) into a wireless router. The router can be hooked up to external antennas and produce working broadband quite a long way from the cell-tower. Downside is the punitive data-capped tarrifs, but 100GB for £22 a month is around.

Three offer 100GB for £22, with bundled NetFlix and TV Player. ('Go Binge'):

http://www.three.co.uk/Discover/Devices/Huawei/Hom...

About £100 for the 3G/4G wifi router, £100 for an external wall mount or attic antenna, assuming there's some kind of mobile signal there. Vodafone and EE also have frequent MBB offers.

Getting MBB running on weak signals can be done, but it's a case of checking around the property with a mobile phone or a 3G/4G USB dongle and a handful of free PAYG sim cards.

3G gives around 10-20 Mb/s download over MBB with a 50% signal. 4G: up to 30-50Mb/s, or better.
Wireless/4G etc isn't a workable option at present.

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Doofus said:
Wireless/4G etc isn't a workable option at present.
Why not?

Otherwise: ADSL bonding:

https://www.broadbandbuyer.com/features/2945-combi...


Edited by Slushbox on Thursday 10th January 18:58

Doofus

Original Poster:

34,657 posts

204 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Slushbox said:
Why not?

Otherwise: ADSL bonding:

https://www.broadbandbuyer.com/features/2945-combi...


Edited by Slushbox on Thursday 10th January 18:58
No signal.

I mentioned bonding, but I'm not convinced it made any difference when I had it in an office. It made things more stable, which probably equates to greater bandwidth, but nobody's connection seemed any faster.

ETA: isn't bonding essemtially what I described (splitting devices across miltiple lines) except that it would allow much dynamic adjustment (each device could only use the maximum capacity of one line rather tha of two or three)?


Sorry, lots of questions, mostly theoretical at this stage, but I have some experience of possible solutions, but almost no technical understanding of how they work...

Edited by Doofus on Thursday 10th January 19:04

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

228 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Doofus said:
Thanks all. I wasn't expecting to go from, say, 1.5mb to 3mb. What I was saying is that in practice, each device is probably getting 0.8 or something, because they are all making demands on the same bandwidth.

Therefore, if the number of devices on the line was reduced, and the demand, say, halved then surely the actual speed attained would increase?
I'm not sure you would notice the difference between 0.8 and 1.5 Meg. That would be your max anyway, and you are very unlikely to get that consistently across all websites/sources etc based on where their servers are. If you have 4G reception, your users are more likely to get a way better throughput using their phones (even using the phone as a hotspot).

xjay1337

15,966 posts

149 months

Friday 11th January 2019
quotequote all
Doofus said:
xjay1337 said:
Why waste the explanation?

you cannot double the speed for 1 device by utilising both
Yeah, that's not what I asked.
Ok mr Sassy pants.


TonyRPH

13,550 posts

199 months

Friday 11th January 2019
quotequote all
Your profile doesn't state where in the country you are, but here in Yorkshire we have Boundless Networks who offer broadband over wireless (proper wireless, not your domestic crap) and good speeds can be had, if not too far from one of their repeaters.

Maybe they offer a similar service in your region, or maybe there's some other company who does something similar.


Doofus

Original Poster:

34,657 posts

204 months

Friday 11th January 2019
quotequote all
TonyRPH said:
Your profile doesn't state where in the country you are, but here in Yorkshire we have Boundless Networks who offer broadband over wireless (proper wireless, not your domestic crap) and good speeds can be had, if not too far from one of their repeaters.

Maybe they offer a similar service in your region, or maybe there's some other company who does something similar.
I'm not 'in' the area in question yet, so as I said, it's largely theoretical at this stage, but as I understand it, there are no options other than copper phone lines. Poor 4G, no LoS or fixed wireless. It's phone line/s or satellite...

PugwasHDJ80

7,684 posts

252 months

Friday 11th January 2019
quotequote all
You used to be able to get routers for 56k dial-up modes called "shotgun" routers that did exactly this

you don't double the speed, but you certainly get a chunk of improvement in every day use

what you don't get is double the speed to a single request.

TonyRPH

13,550 posts

199 months

Friday 11th January 2019
quotequote all
Doofus said:
I'm not 'in' the area in question yet, so as I said, it's largely theoretical at this stage, but as I understand it, there are no options other than copper phone lines. Poor 4G, no LoS or fixed wireless. It's phone line/s or satellite...
A former colleague was in the exact same position as you (although 4G was available it was way to expensive for him) and that's how I got to know about Boundless Networks, as he got a connection from them, and is very happy with the speed.

But as you say, you have covered all the available options in your list.

Satellite works, but tends to be laggy, and if you want to use it for gaming it's a non starter. It may well struggle with streaming services too, I don't know for sure though, as I've no experience of it.

Shuvi McTupya

24,460 posts

278 months

Friday 11th January 2019
quotequote all
What area are you talking about moving too?

In Aberdeenshire where I am BT is woeful. We have just installed a little aerial that gets a signal from a mast that was erected in a village a mile or so away.

Our speed has gone from less than 1mb to about 12mb ( more speed is available). We have 100gb data but then it is just throttled rather than capped or stupidly pricey. It costs £25 a month.