Most fun? Sports car vs Hot hatch
Most fun? Sports car vs Hot hatch
Author
Discussion

300bhp/ton

Original Poster:

41,030 posts

221 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
If someone say you can drive the cars in group X for fun (B & C roads, occasion track day) or group Y, which group would you pick?


Group X:
-Mazda MX-5 (ND)
-Toyota GT86
-other rwd roadster/coupe focused on sporty handling and relatively lightweight produced in the last 5 years

Group Y:
-Fiesta ST
-Megane R.S.
-Polo GTI
-other fwd hot hatch focused on sporty handling and relatively lightweight produced in the last 5 years

grudas

1,417 posts

199 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
X

something like s2000, mx5 etc

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
For me personally, a sports car is generally more "fun" but by it's very nature it's an entirely subjective question.

otolith

69,773 posts

235 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
Y probably.

I can drive sports cars any time I like.

alex98uk

257 posts

104 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
Major advantage of a hot hatch when looking at track days is the ability to bring an extra set of wheels/tyres. I wouldn't think it's possible in an '86?

otolith

69,773 posts

235 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
alex98uk said:
Major advantage of a hot hatch when looking at track days is the ability to bring an extra set of wheels/tyres. I wouldn't think it's possible in an '86?
If I remember rightly, the ability to fit a set of wheels and tyres in the back seat was one of its design requirements.

JLC25

572 posts

153 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
Group Y for me.

CABC

6,320 posts

132 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
otolith said:
alex98uk said:
Major advantage of a hot hatch when looking at track days is the ability to bring an extra set of wheels/tyres. I wouldn't think it's possible in an '86?
If I remember rightly, the ability to fit a set of wheels and tyres in the back seat was one of its design requirements.
it was indeed.

i think 300's question is flawed. if just for b & c roads or track the only answer is X.
it's when you add in practicality, commuting, long distances and motorway the choice is more difficult.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
As CABC says, the real answer to this question concerns that of engineering compromises.

Sports car: A car designed first and foremost to entertain the driver, without primary regard for practicality; so in many senses a 'toy'. Practicality vs enjoyment and performance is a spectrum, with cars like the Caterham 7 at one end, and cars verging on GTs such as the SLK at the other end.

Hot hatch: A hatchback is a car designed first and foremost to be a practical 'do it all' car as a tool, not a toy. A hot hatch is such a car tweaked for driver enjoyment and performance.

Further to that, there's the old question of FWD vs RWD, which personally I think sits within the above categories with their pros and cons, with a scant few exceptions such as the 1980s Elan and Fiat Barchetta.

That's the theory. I think in practise this generally gives rise to sports cars being better to drive than hot hatches, although obviously there's some overlap. It's hard to measure cars by one criteria though, so for example although one might choose a 106 GTi over an MGF, there are individual things about each car that people will prefer over the other - RWD is always a big thing for me for example; it dominates much of the handling and if you don't like it, then no matter how good a car is, it'll always feel FWD or RWD depending on the layout.

Edited by RobM77 on Tuesday 19th March 17:11

spoodler

2,307 posts

186 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
I'd take a dedicated sports car over something built on a shared platform pretty much any day of the week... but, generally, I don't have to worry about practicality. Still maintain that after having driven hot rods, muscle cars, grand tourers, hot hatches etc., the best driving fun I've ever had was in a modern Morgan three wheeler.

Baldchap

9,639 posts

123 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
For a quick blast a sports car every time. Problem is, modern hot hatches are so good and modern conditions and traffic so poor that the sports car sees less and less use.

We used to have a fleet of all sorts. Now we've got a warm estate and a bus.

WJNB

2,637 posts

192 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
Sports car implies two seats & a roof that can be folded away - very liberating & 'implies' freedom from kids & responsibilities
Hatchback implies suburbia, pimply teenagers & winnable sports car owner or premium car ownership but no money.

Galveston

778 posts

230 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
If someone say you can drive the cars in group X for fun (B & C roads, occasion track day) or group Y, which group would you pick?

Group X:
-Mazda MX-5 (ND)
-Toyota GT86
-other rwd roadster/coupe focused on sporty handling and relatively lightweight produced in the last 5 years

Group Y:
-Fiesta ST
-Megane R.S.
-Polo GTI
-other fwd hot hatch focused on sporty handling and relatively lightweight produced in the last 5 years
The "last five years" condition alters this for me. I'd prefer the Mazda or Toyota to the hatches listed, but I'd rather drive a 205 GTi or a 172 Cup than any of them.

A proper normally aspirated, revvy, lightweight, chuckable and adjustable hot hatch wins the fun stakes for me.

Mr Tidy

31,919 posts

158 months

Tuesday 19th March 2019
quotequote all
I'd definitely go for a GT86 - 99% of the time it's only me in the car!

Plus it has got back seats if you ever need them (even if they're pretty tricky to get in and out of) and best of all it's RWD. laugh

samoht

7,325 posts

177 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all

Definitely group X (sports cars) for outright fun for me.

The hot hatches offer a broader spread of abilities as an only / everyday car, but for the B-road and trackday driving as you mention, the RWD dedicated sportscars are in their element.

Pericoloso

44,044 posts

194 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
X for me.
Bought my first convertible 6 Years ago.
Fun fun fun.

Toltec

7,179 posts

254 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
Must admit something like a Megan 280 does appeal to replace my wife's 325 compact when it dies. I'm considering a GT86, probably with a supercharger mod though, as an alternative to something expensive like a 911.

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
X for me. Hot hatches are dull and easy. And don't power oversteer.

No doubt they are faster and flatter the driver which many people want though.

Eric Mc

125,941 posts

296 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
Dob't forget that most sports cars are rear wheel drive and sometimes even mid engined. Hot hatches are almost invariably front wheel drive.

Gad-Westy

16,666 posts

244 months

Wednesday 20th March 2019
quotequote all
Not a big fan of modern hot hatches at all (despite currently driving one). So I'd go sportscar but I would say that there are certain 'fiddly' little roads, often moorland or up here across the ranges where a more traditional hot hatch (small, light, not necessarily very powerful) makes so much more sense. Where you're sitting a bit higher so can see a bit more, have a bit more compliance in the suspension and just a little bit friendlier in terms of balance. In those circumstances, I'd take a hot hatch (just not necessarily a fat turbo charged blob), rest of the time, a sportscar please.