Shorts Belfast
Author
Discussion

RichGault

Original Poster:

132 posts

145 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
Just gonna throw this one in here as I've just finished reading 'Tester Zero-One'.In it 'Bobby' Robinson describes his antics and testing procedures used on the Belfast and the long distance flying involved(the story on that is quite entertaining) and the messages sent by the crew over the Indian ocean.....

After finishing the book and doing some further reading on the aircraft it seems that after modifications to the tail section it seemed to perform rather well and the nickname 'Belslow' didn't seem to be so apt......looking on pprune the general opinion on the aircraft seems to be 'it needed 10% more of everything' but overall was quite a capable aircraft( 2 Puma's 69'ing was possible in one go)

There was even talk of taking the design further with C141 wings and RR Turbofans but never came to fruition.......(political reasons I believe)

So I suppose my point of discussion is....could this aircraft have been a 'world beater' along the lines of the Herc?...as opposed to now having only 2 examples left in the world......one at Cosford and another languishing at an Australian airport.....

Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Sunday 12th May 2019
quotequote all
It was a bit of a "bitser" - in that the wings and tailplanes/tail fin were derived from the Bristol Britannia. Short Brothers had built Britannias under licence for Bristol so they had all the jigs and toolings already in place.

Tony1963

5,808 posts

186 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Could it have been a world beater?

Yes.

If it had been a different aircraft.
With substantial support.
And a production line in the States.

Ayahuasca

27,560 posts

303 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Economies of scale meant it was never going to beat the C130, unless the US military establishment had a sudden and inexplicable urge to support a foreign manufacturer over one of their own.

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

285 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
RichGault said:
So I suppose my point of discussion is....could this aircraft have been a 'world beater' along the lines of the Herc?...as opposed to now having only 2 examples left in the world......one at Cosford and another languishing at an Australian airport.....
2 examples represents 20% of total production so not a bad survival rate.

As I recall the issue with the Belfast was that although it was good for bulky loads, the impressive sounding total payload was only achievable with 500 miles worth of fuel. Very useful for certain things, otherwise Heavylift wouldn't have gone to the trouble of getting them on a civil certificate of airworthiness, but a bit niche.

Although in hindsight the RAF should have kept using them at least until the Falklands war, some people reckon this would have been cheaper than chartering them for the occasion.

Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
I don't think it should be compared with the Hercules - which was designed as more of a tactical airlifter and was therefore quite a bit smaller. The nearest equivalent in period was the Lockheed C-133 Cargomaster.

CanAm

13,074 posts

296 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
I don't think it should be compared with the Hercules - which was designed as more of a tactical airlifter and was therefore quite a bit smaller. The nearest equivalent in period was the Lockheed C-133 Cargomaster.
Douglas? Lockheed would have called it the Cargostar surely smile

Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
CanAm said:
Douglas? Lockheed would have called it the Cargostar surely smile
Yes - got myself confused (easily done these days).

It had issues too and was retired prematurely due to fatigue problems.

We used to see Belfasts flying overhead Dublin going too and from the US or Canada back in the 70s. They made a very distinctive droning noise.

CanAm

13,074 posts

296 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Yes - got myself confused (easily done these days).
I'm older than you Eric. I know the feeling well.
beer

Tony1963

5,808 posts

186 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Dr Jekyll said:
Although in hindsight the RAF should have kept using them at least until the Falklands war, some people reckon this would have been cheaper than chartering them for the occasion.
I’m glad you said “hindsight” smile

Mr Pointy

12,876 posts

183 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
In a previous life I worked for a company that built TV OB vans & we had a couple destined for Nairobi. The only way to get them there on time was to fly them out so we used Heavylift who flew two Belfasts out of Stanstead (if I recall correctly).









Some genius in the company read the contract & discovered we were entitled to a passenger in each aircraft so decided it would save a couple of air fares. They bolted an old airline seat to the cargo deck & we flew for two days at a few thousand feet watching the truck bouncing up & down hoping it didn't hit the control lines running under the wing root.


Unbusy

934 posts

121 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
I’m pretty sure it was a Belfast that was used on my air experience flight when I was an Erk.
Regretfully I didn’t take any photos but I do remember that the flight deck was huge. Talking to the crew and enjoying the flight put the thought of being aircrew into my mind.
I’m surprised that so few were made. I really must get over to Cosford and check it out.

Tony1963

5,808 posts

186 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Mr Pointy said:
In a previous life I worked for a company that built TV OB vans & we had a couple destined for Nairobi. The only way to get them there on time was to fly them out so we used Heavylift who flew two Belfasts out of Stanstead (if I recall correctly).
Stansted!

Tony1963

5,808 posts

186 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Mr Pointy said:
In a previous life I worked for a company that built TV OB vans & we had a couple destined for Nairobi. The only way to get them there on time was to fly them out so we used Heavylift who flew two Belfasts out of Stanstead (if I recall correctly).
Stansted!

Eric Mc

124,939 posts

289 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Correct - although I have seen it spelled the other way too - so I think it is a valid spelling - just one not used much today.

Tony1963

5,808 posts

186 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Correct - although I have seen it spelled the other way too - so I think it is a valid spelling - just one not used much today.
Stanstead is a different place to Stansted. For the airport, it is only Stansted.

Baby Shark doo doo doo doo

15,078 posts

193 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
http://warbirdsnews.com/warbirds-news/short-belfas...

Potential resurrection of ‘Hector’ in Oz

Tony1963

5,808 posts

186 months

Monday 13th May 2019
quotequote all
Baby Shark doo doo doo doo said:
http://warbirdsnews.com/warbirds-news/short-belfas...

Potential resurrection of ‘Hector’ in Oz
A year ago, and I don’t think there has been any activity since.