£18-20k, what investable car would you have?
£18-20k, what investable car would you have?
Author
Discussion

Prohibiting

Original Poster:

1,918 posts

147 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
As per tread title, if you had £18-20k and wanted to grow that cash over a few years, what car would you invest in?

davek_964

11,213 posts

204 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
This kind of question has been asked a few times recently.

If you want ~£20k to grow over a few years, don't buy a car. Especially now, when even things that have been going up seem to be going down.

Even if you are lucky and buy something that appreciates - the amount it goes up in a few years is unlikely to be more than the cost of running it.

Zetec-S

6,860 posts

122 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Depends on how much you were going to drive it. Anything driven more than a couple of thousand miles a year will not really generate much return in the long run.

If I was going to buy something to garage and take out occasionally when the weather's nice then it would probably be a Focus RS. Completely standard. But that would be a waste of a car.

Shiv_P

3,036 posts

134 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
E36/E46 M3

bennno

15,228 posts

298 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
If you have a double garage I would get a 12k elise and a 6k Renault Clio 200.

If it has to be one car then perhaps as good an SLK55 AMG or flat 6 Cayman as you can find.

Or a Monaro VXR in decent nick.

Composite Guru

2,499 posts

232 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Lotus Elise.

If you can find a good S1 then that would be the safest but if not then S2 111R.

I bought a 2016 S3 Elise 220 Cup 2 years ago for £37k and they are still selling for similar money now in the dealers. It has the big aero kit on it so is a rarity over the new ones when Lotus took most of it off to save money.

Jcwjosh

963 posts

141 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Is this to stash away for a few years or to drive and maintain ?


Edited by Jcwjosh on Tuesday 4th June 09:37

davek_964

11,213 posts

204 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Why should any of these cars appreciate?

A Cayman - why would that go up in the next few years? The Elise which will sell for the same as you bought it two years ago also hasn't gone up.

I agree that some cars don't depreciate - I tend to target cars like that myself. But cars that are going to appreciate in the next few years that cost £20k are much harder to find I think.

p4cks

7,481 posts

228 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Clio V6

Phil Dicky

7,194 posts

292 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Most TVRs.... everyone I've had is worth 5K more than I paid.

Jcwjosh

963 posts

141 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
I would buy the best lupo gti i could (with low mileage) in any colour other than the 2 silvers for around 6-7k

I would also buy the cleanest mk1 TT 240 quattro sport i could find in any colour other than silver or black. 8-9k

I would hope they would appreciate in the next 5-10 years but im not sure this is what cars are about.

As the poster above mentions not losing money would be more my bag.

boobles

15,251 posts

244 months

ZX10R NIN

30,528 posts

154 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Firstly you have to be prepared to lose money, the car market can be fickle & if you want to cash out at the wrong time you may take a bath so your 20k car may end up being worth 10-15k, if you cant afford to take that kind of hit then don't buy a car put it towards a deposit on a rental home.

bennno

15,228 posts

298 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
davek_964 said:
Why should any of these cars appreciate?

A Cayman - why would that go up in the next few years? The Elise which will sell for the same as you bought it two years ago also hasn't gone up.

I agree that some cars don't depreciate - I tend to target cars like that myself. But cars that are going to appreciate in the next few years that cost £20k are much harder to find I think.
Because the flat 6 and the Caymans drivers car reputation may mean they appreciate gradually, I remember looking at 968 clubsports and a 911 club sport which are both now worth many multiples of figures from 15 years ago.

davek_964

11,213 posts

204 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
bennno said:
davek_964 said:
Why should any of these cars appreciate?

A Cayman - why would that go up in the next few years? The Elise which will sell for the same as you bought it two years ago also hasn't gone up.

I agree that some cars don't depreciate - I tend to target cars like that myself. But cars that are going to appreciate in the next few years that cost £20k are much harder to find I think.
Because the flat 6 and the Caymans drivers car reputation may mean they appreciate gradually, I remember looking at 968 clubsports and a 911 club sport which are both now worth many multiples of figures from 15 years ago.
Yep, and so are 911 RS etc.

But I wouldn't include a Boxster with a tin roof in that group. Still, maybe I'm wrong - I wouldn't buy one though.

blueg33

46,311 posts

253 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Phil Dicky said:
Most TVRs.... everyone I've had is worth 5K more than I paid.
In my experience they only go up after you have sold them and when you are looking to buy one...........


I see people mentioning cars that are likely to hold their value rather than cars that will appreciate.

There is a simple reason for this. If anyone could be sure which cars will appreciate then everyone would be buying them. The reality is that cars make a crap investment, especially as they need maintenance even just to hold their value., so you have to factor in maintenance as a cost, and deduct it from any growth in value

Edited by blueg33 on Tuesday 4th June 15:41

NorthernSky

1,071 posts

146 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Z4M Coupe will hold your money steady if you find a good one with around 50-60k miles inside your budget, it is a car you can and should use regularly, meaning best of both worlds. :-)

hyphen

26,262 posts

119 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
Buy something that needs work, then do the work over the few years and sell.


SWoll

22,762 posts

287 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
One of these may stand a chance of appreciating a little over the next few years will others getting into the wrong hands, knackered engines etc.

It's certainly the right spec and colour combination and the mileage is also good.

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201...

boobles said:
Good call. Will definitely stand a better chance than a Cayman/Boxster.

Edited by SWoll on Tuesday 4th June 18:56

Deep Thought

40,118 posts

226 months

Tuesday 4th June 2019
quotequote all
ZX10R NIN said:
Firstly you have to be prepared to lose money, the car market can be fickle & if you want to cash out at the wrong time you may take a bath so your 20k car may end up being worth 10-15k, if you cant afford to take that kind of hit then don't buy a car put it towards a deposit on a rental home.
I think thats exactly it. I see far too many cars that are supposedly "worth" this sort of money but sit and sit for months with no takers, only to have to be sold at some point for a knock down price if the person needs it away.