Selling US shares - US & UK tax situation
Selling US shares - US & UK tax situation
Author
Discussion

55palfers

Original Poster:

6,373 posts

193 months

Friday 7th June 2019
quotequote all
I have some shares in a US company bought via an employee share option scheme back in about 2000.

They are a long term rainy day fund, but YTD they are up some 40% (record high) and up about 300% in the last 10 years.

Therefore, I'm tempted to take a bit of profit whilst avoiding exceeding the UK CG threshold.

Does anyone know if I will I have to pay any tax on them in the US too?

On dividend income, Uncle Sam takes some 30% witholding tax, will this apply in this case?

Thanks.

bogie

17,079 posts

301 months

Friday 7th June 2019
quotequote all
Usually you have a W8BEN form filled out with the US tax office, maybe its in your scheme admin system.

Then when you sell the US tax authority just keep back tax at your tax rate as applicable (as they are informed by your employer). Nothing more to do than that.

sold all mine when I left a US company 18 months ago....

check in the details of your scheme. Maybe you have an online system for admin and can look in there and sell from there.


55palfers

Original Poster:

6,373 posts

193 months

Friday 7th June 2019
quotequote all
I fill out the W8-BEN every three years. However I left the US company about 12 years ago.

Bummer, have to pay US tax then?

Selling below UK CG threshold so no UK tax to pay here - hardly seems fair.

bogie

17,079 posts

301 months

Friday 7th June 2019
quotequote all
Depends, I seem to remember if you hold them for so many years then its less or no tax. I never held any over 5 years i kept selling along the way over 14 years of working for US company, always had the tax withheld.

Best check with the scheme administrator to be sure, although in my experience it was all automatic no chance to sell them and worry about tax later, its all done at source, automatically

mikef

6,158 posts

280 months

Friday 7th June 2019
quotequote all
It’s a while since I last did this, but I have a recollection of a mandatory non-resident withholding of 30%, regardless of the final tax owed in the US, then having to file a US tax return and finally getting some of the tax refunded a couple of years later

Edited to correct non-resident withholding to 30%. The last letter I had from IRS was that 1040-NR tax returns are taking around a year to deal with due to staff shortages

Edited by mikef on Sunday 9th June 17:24

supersport

4,631 posts

256 months

Friday 7th June 2019
quotequote all
If you have a current W8 Ben then they won’t withhold US tax, that’s the point. It is lodged with whoever holds your stock.


Clearly at 300% you need to be aware of uk cgt. You have a £12k allowance.

mikef

6,158 posts

280 months

Saturday 8th June 2019
quotequote all
supersport said:
If you have a current W8 Ben then they won’t withhold US tax
I did have. Try arguing that with Fidelity

GCH

4,140 posts

231 months

Sunday 9th June 2019
quotequote all
The good news is that as a non-resident (and presumably non-citizen/LPR) you are not subject to US CGT on this when you cash out.

However, as you note, standard withholding for non-residents is 30%.
But, as you have filed a W8BEN and are resident in the UK, they should have taken into account that the US and UK have a tax treaty at a lower withholding rate, which if I recall correctly, is 15% [EDIT - it has increased to 20% - http://taxsummaries.pwc.com/ID/Withholding-tax-(WH... ] and not been withholding 30%.

You can file a US tax return for any refund of overpayment / over-withholding, and you can also file tax returns for previous years for the same.

edit to add some light (!) reading: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p515.pdf



55palfers

Original Poster:

6,373 posts

193 months

Sunday 9th June 2019
quotequote all
Thanks for that GCH.

I have downloaded the document and can't wait to get stuck in!

How annoying it is that the US print it over three columns per page too.

I'll email the US brokers tomorrow.

55palfers

Original Poster:

6,373 posts

193 months

Wednesday 12th June 2019
quotequote all
Had a response from the US stockbrokers.
Seems there is no US tax to pay when you sell shares, only on share dividends
$15.00 to sell plus 10 cents per share brokerage fee.
Just need to post them my share cert and in a week or so I can trade them myself via their portal.

mikeiow

8,157 posts

159 months

Wednesday 12th June 2019
quotequote all
Depending on the sums & what your bank charge, you might want to look into using something like Transferwise for getting low cost transfers....I believe it can give decent savings if you are into the thousands.

supersport

4,631 posts

256 months

Thursday 13th June 2019
quotequote all
mikef said:
supersport said:
If you have a current W8 Ben then they won’t withhold US tax
I did have. Try arguing that with Fidelity
That’s a bit crap. Didn’t have that problem with mine, or us tax withheld.

The Leaper

5,701 posts

235 months

Thursday 13th June 2019
quotequote all
Recently I sold a tranche of shares in a USA company. Did this in March and May. I have filed an in force W8-BEN form so I am a non registered alien for USA tax purposes. On the sale of the shares there was no USA tax liability and I received the full proceeds gross, less dealing expenses which were minimal.

These transactions are liable for UK CGT so I ensured that (a) the CG was below the relevant thresholds for each tax year and also (b) the entire proceeds of each transaction was less than 4 times the thresholds so that there was no HMRC reporting requirements for each of the transactions.

I'd advise establishing and maintaining good records too, especially if, like me, the plan is to repeat the same procedures for a series of UK tax years. You need to create a "section 104 holding" , maintain the record, and update it for each transaction.

R.