Luxury car tax putting me off
Luxury car tax putting me off
Author
Discussion

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,019 posts

97 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
I've been looking at used cars, many less than a year old and want to pay low £20K s. I have seen some that appear very good value, BMWs etc. However, the 3 series is not what I would call a luxury car but many exceed the threshold of £40,000 when new. I asked about a couple of cars and their list price at Motorpoint and he knew I was asking about the luxury car tax. All exceeded the threshold. Whether he would have mentioned it to me voluntarily I'll never know. I suspect not until the paperwork had been signed. There is absolutely no way I'm paying an extra £1600 or so in tax over five years, it's never happening, so my choice is li ited to buying a cheaper list priced car or buying an older car that preceded the introduction of the tax. Please no comments about how insignificant the tax is in the scheme of things, it really isn't. I wouldn't buy a car that costs £500 a year to tax either
I just wonder how many car dealers are finding these "supertax" cars more difficult to sell

2 sMoKiN bArReLs

31,988 posts

264 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
Buy a cheaper car then. Simples

anonymous-user

83 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
Well the legislation is having an effect.

Quite simple either stump up the extra to buy the car you want or don't and have a car you don't really want but was 'forced' on you.

I suspect that cars affected by the extra tax have already taken a hit in their value and without it probably would not be in your price range.

Swings and roundabouts...

ZX10R NIN

30,523 posts

154 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
If you're looking for a well spec'd nearly new C Class/3 series etc then you'll be paying the tax if you don't want to pay then buy something older or buy a cheaper (as in list price) car.

Sheepshanks

40,877 posts

148 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
It does seem odd that there's a whole bunch of cars priced at slightly over £40,xxx new - you'd think they'd get the price to be slightly under.

I also expected more options to be included, but that doesn't seem to have happened either.

anonymous-user

83 months

Sunday 20th October 2019
quotequote all
I'm paying an extra £310 VED so.... £5.96 a week.on a car with a £47k list price.

I paid under £30K for it, pre reg and brand new. Its a farce but easily avoided - just ask for the list price, watch the salesman go quite vague and some colour drain from him slightly. Or look it up online. Some dealers are straight up.

Its a nice 3 litre, straight six that goes like snot with all the toys. I'd hate to pay that on a 2 litre diesel that snuck into that price range because of options. I disagree with it in principal as the list price is a manufactured figure that bears little resemblance to what people actually pay for a car.

I'll keep it three years, so thats £930 extra, I negotiated hard on the deal and saved far more than that on the screen price (not list). You could even factor that into a negotiating process.

Autotrader is littered with older average 2 litre cars that have a VED of £325/ £400 £555, I guess people avoid them in the same way that you can avoid the luxury tax.

kieranblenk

865 posts

163 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
My 66 plate A4 is £20 per year to tax, my mate at work has a 17 plate one the same but the 190 quattro with a few more options and pays the high rate. I couldn't justify paying £500 per year nearly for a 2.0 diesel personally, my dad wanted to replace his 14 plate Evoque with another one but will probably go for a Q3 now to avoid the luxury car tax as it sneaks just under the threshold in his desired spec.

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,019 posts

97 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
doog442 said:
I'm paying an extra £310 VED so.... £5.96 a week.on a car with a £47k list price.

I paid under £30K for it, pre reg and brand new. Its a farce but easily avoided - just ask for the list price, watch the salesman go quite vague and some colour drain from him slightly. Or look it up online. Some dealers are straight up.

Its a nice 3 litre, straight six that goes like snot with all the toys. I'd hate to pay that on a 2 litre diesel that snuck into that price range because of options. I disagree with it in principal as the list price is a manufactured figure that bears little resemblance to what people actually pay for a car.

I'll keep it three years, so thats £930 extra, I negotiated hard on the deal and saved far more than that on the screen price (not list). You could even factor that into a negotiating process.

Autotrader is littered with older average 2 litre cars that have a VED of £325/ £400 £555, I guess people avoid them in the same way that you can avoid the luxury tax.
That used to be a tactic employed by life insurance salesmen " it only costs £6 a week , or "so many cups of coffee". People with that attitude to money often struggle to manage money (not suggesting that you do at all, it doesn't sound like it). My take on it is that it's £310 out of annual income net of tax, so it's close to £400 out of a salary, or over £500 for a higher rate earner. It's not insignificant for an "extra" tax. These are not luxury cars either but what could be described as decent sales reps' cars. It's a personal thing and it won't bother everyone but for me, it really goes against the grain

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,019 posts

97 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
2 sMoKiN bArReLs said:
Buy a cheaper car then. Simples
Thanks for that. repeating a point I made is very constructive and helpful

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,019 posts

97 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
ZX10R NIN said:
If you're looking for a well spec'd nearly new C Class/3 series etc then you'll be paying the tax if you don't want to pay then buy something older or buy a cheaper (as in list price) car.
Yes thanks for that, repeating the points I've already made is really helpful

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,019 posts

97 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
gottans said:
Well the legislation is having an effect.

Quite simple either stump up the extra to buy the car you want or don't and have a car you don't really want but was 'forced' on you.

I suspect that cars affected by the extra tax have already taken a hit in their value and without it probably would not be in your price range.

Swings and roundabouts...
That is a good point, some of the cars at the car supermarkets seem really good value, although main dealers prices are still too high for this to be a possibility

2 sMoKiN bArReLs

31,988 posts

264 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
2 sMoKiN bArReLs said:
Buy a cheaper car then. Simples
Thanks for that. repeating a point I made is very constructive and helpful
We aim to please! But, if it bugs you that much, then that is the answer.

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

202 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
We've started similar threads albeit at different ends of the car buying spectrum.

I think if I was in your position I'd be tempted to go further upmarket but older. Doesn't this tax finish at 5 years? What about a 7 series in the same budget. Yes it might cost more to run and maintain but to me that's somehow more palatable.

sideways sid

1,462 posts

244 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
I just wonder how many car dealers are finding these "supertax" cars more difficult to sell
Dealers don't. They reduce the price of them so that people like you can buy a one-year old car for half of its list price!


ambuletz

11,733 posts

210 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
let me get this straight...you still pay this tax even if the car is used? so if a car cost over £40 new.. and you buy it used 4-5 years later when its under £20..you still pay it?

anonymous-user

83 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
ambuletz said:
let me get this straight...you still pay this tax even if the car is used? so if a car cost over £40 new.. and you buy it used 4-5 years later when its under £20..you still pay it?
Yes.

ATM

21,310 posts

248 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
gottans said:
ambuletz said:
let me get this straight...you still pay this tax even if the car is used? so if a car cost over £40 new.. and you buy it used 4-5 years later when its under £20..you still pay it?
Yes.
They tried taxing based on emissions so car manufacturers moved heaven and earth to get emissions down. So now they've moved the goal posts to retail price. I have so far avoided buying an older car with the higher rate tax based on emissions because I object to paying it. I have 3 cars right now and can only drive one at a time yet I have to pay for road tax on all 3. Its clearly nothing to do with roads now and just another way to tax people who happen to be car owners.

ambuletz

11,733 posts

210 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
gottans said:
ambuletz said:
let me get this straight...you still pay this tax even if the car is used? so if a car cost over £40 new.. and you buy it used 4-5 years later when its under £20..you still pay it?
Yes.
that's obsurd. the cars will only end up depriciating even further. to the point where nobody will want them. they'll only be useful to buy for engine swaps into other cars.

JohndoePH

23 posts

89 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
You pay it for 5 years after the initial year so essentially the car has to be 6 years old before the higher rate goes away. The initial year tax is also a sight to behold these days, maxes out at over £2k.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

227 months

Monday 21st October 2019
quotequote all
JohndoePH said:
You pay it for 5 years after the initial year so essentially the car has to be 6 years old before the higher rate goes away. The initial year tax is also a sight to behold these days, maxes out at over £2k.
It makes PCH really expensive and also for those asking where are these M5 etc stunning deals that used to happen.... well they never will again due to this tax change (unless it’s £39,999 optioned up and AT LIST price not what you haggle)