Buying booze in Europe
Author
Discussion

mattyn1

Original Poster:

7,048 posts

184 months

Monday 4th November 2019
quotequote all
Hopefully a quick one.... I am assuming the answer is no but if anyone knows otherwise I would appreciate a link.
If I went to France and bought a boot load of Pinot Grigio from a wine supermarket can I then use that wine at a dinner function for which I am selling tickets? Assume the tickets say wine is available.

Thanks in advance! I appreciate confirming my thoughts.

CarlosSainz100

721 posts

149 months

Monday 4th November 2019
quotequote all
Unless the rules have changed since I was last a customs officer/border force officer (in 2012) then you can bring back as much booze as you like from any EU country as long as it's for your own use

Were you to be stopped at the border and your boot searched you 'could' say it's for your own use and 'forget' the part with the party and the paying guests.....

Brexit may well change all that....

Mr Tidy

31,446 posts

156 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
You might want to plan your route though!

Back in the early 90s I lived in Sittingbourne when 6 bottles was the limit IIRC - but Dover was near enough for regular shopping trips!

Once the UK joined the EU there were no limits on duty-paid goods - so HMRC got pretty upset and just started pulling vans in on the A2 with a view to nicking them for being over-weight.

And in the early 90s they set up a site near Maidstone to test for red diesel!

Whatever you want, be careful and buy it before Brexit - if that ever happens. banghead


mattyn1

Original Poster:

7,048 posts

184 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Thanks both for the responses.

It was more the using it for the function where my question was aimed. The function is in a sports club (which is the host) - which has its own bar.

Can the host of the function give me the cash I would have paid for the wine and then offer it "on the tables" so to speak with the Xmas meal. Attendees are not buying the wine - "directly" and attendees are members of the sports club. They buy a ticket for the function - there will be an expectation wine is available with the meal.

I think the answer is no - but just want confirmation. I think it falls over when the club gives me the cash for the wine I would buy. Therefore it is not for personal consumption etc.

The counter to my "no" is along the lines of a wedding - the couple buy the wine from abroad and have it served at the wedding. The function host (lets say the sports club) charge no corkage. The only difference is who actually pays - the couple pay for the wedding meal per head - instead of the attendees paying. Or am i missing something?

To cover off another argument from the EU I assume it is "Duty Paid" not "Duty Free".


Taita

7,995 posts

232 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Once you've got it in the country, who cares tbh. Just say it's for a wedding.

mattyn1

Original Poster:

7,048 posts

184 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Taita said:
Once you've got it in the country, who cares tbh. Just say it's for a wedding.
I am concerned Customs and Excise might care, which might affect the business of the club.



Camelot1971

2,851 posts

195 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
I personally think you are on dodgy ground, especially as the wine is for a business (and not your business). Cash changing hands to buy it off you, regardless of what is happening to it afterwards, is an even bigger red flag.

I expect HMRC would have little interest if it was an actual car boot full. If you are filling a Transit, that would be very different.

Is wine actually that much cheaper in France? Depending on whether you care about the quality, there are loads of wines available for £5 or less in the supermarkets. If you went to a UK wine merchant you could probably get a good deal, or Costco is great if you want higher quality wine at a good price per case.

Dave Hedgehog

16,332 posts

233 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Camelot1971 said:
I personally think you are on dodgy ground, especially as the wine is for a business (and not your business). Cash changing hands to buy it off you, regardless of what is happening to it afterwards, is an even bigger red flag.

I expect HMRC would have little interest if it was an actual car boot full. If you are filling a Transit, that would be very different.

Is wine actually that much cheaper in France? Depending on whether you care about the quality, there are loads of wines available for £5 or less in the supermarkets. If you went to a UK wine merchant you could probably get a good deal, or Costco is great if you want higher quality wine at a good price per case.
Yep defiantly on dodgy ground if you sell it, I used to do a late night bargain Chunnel ticket once a month to stock up but I can’t see France being that much cheaper than the supermarket deals now?

Stuart70

4,163 posts

212 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Fx rates means the saving on wine on France - quality for quality is unlikely to justify the tunnel/ferry & fuel costs as well as your time.

Tongue in cheek - why would you go to France and buy Italian wine? The French do some pretty good white wine themselves smile

eybic

9,212 posts

203 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Certainly with Tobacco (I would think booze is the same) you can bring as much back as you like for your own personal use, my understanding is that you can gift some but as soon as money changes hands (even if it's cost price) then you're on dodgy ground and would need to pay the relevant duty.

Laurel Green

31,127 posts

261 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
One of the questions they might ask (if pulled) is where did the money come from - proof could be difficult.

Taita

7,995 posts

232 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Just say the money came from your bank account.

Money can change hands once it's in the country or before.

I think a lot of you are overestimating the capability / care levels of HMRC - they aren't going to follow you from the port to your house laugh

scoey1001

921 posts

110 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
How many cases are you planning on bringing in? As above if fits in a car boot then just say it's for parties over christmas etc. if you are stopped (which is very unlikely) and there won't be a problem. However if its a van load they may question you further.

Can recommend Calais wine superstore which is about 5 mins drive from the port, they have a tasting room and also if you spend a certain amount (think its about £250) they will pay for your crossing.

vaud

59,450 posts

184 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
If it's just a car's worth and a one off trip you will be fine. DON'T tell them you are selling in any form. House party/reception etc.

Graveworm

9,225 posts

100 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
vaud said:
If it's just a car's worth and a one off trip you will be fine. DON'T tell them you are selling in any form. House party/reception etc.
Is a lie OK if you don't get caught? Is it OK to encourage the commission of an offence?
Commercial use (Not just retail) attracts duty even on duty paid goods, within the EU. So to awswer the OP you were correct that the answer is no.

vaud

59,450 posts

184 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Graveworm said:
Is a lie OK if you don't get caught? Is it OK to encourage the commission of an offence?
Commercial use (Not just retail) attracts duty even on duty paid goods, within the EU. So to awswer the OP you were correct that the answer is no.
I'm being pragmatic. Should we speed? No. But even the guidelines are not to prosecute for minor speed offences.

I would not recommend it anyway as the logistics and time spent are must be too high for the return... Surely?

PAULJ5555

3,554 posts

205 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Someone will be along soon asking why were giving out tax dodging advice and will also provide a link about the OP moaning about public services not being funded enough because of tax dodgers

Popcorn anyone.

mattyn1

Original Poster:

7,048 posts

184 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
Thanks all. Confirmed what I was thinking!

IJWS15

2,220 posts

114 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
So the OP thinks it is OK to avoid tax - effectively stealing from the state (i.e. the rest of us)!

Camelot1971

2,851 posts

195 months

Tuesday 5th November 2019
quotequote all
IJWS15 said:
So the OP thinks it is OK to avoid tax - effectively stealing from the state (i.e. the rest of us)!
That's not true at all - re-read the OP. Some other posters are advocating that though.