991 Turbo or Turbo S
991 Turbo or Turbo S
Author
Discussion

GT Two

Original Poster:

3,070 posts

220 months

Thursday 21st November 2019
quotequote all
Looking to buy a Turbo Or Turbo S before Xmas, is there much benefit to having the S over a well specced Turbo?

My budget is 80k and that gives me access to a couple of S models or quite a few normal Turbos.

I will tune the car so the additional power not a concern.

Is an S much more easy to sell?

Any other reasons to get an S?

Thanks!

Koln-RS

4,116 posts

240 months

Thursday 21st November 2019
quotequote all
I think any ‘tuned’ car will be much more difficult to sell.

IMI A

9,959 posts

229 months

Thursday 21st November 2019
quotequote all
Gen 2 turbo s has bigger VTG turbos. Worth the extra money to me especially if tuning.

On gen 1 identical VTG turbos for both models so makes no difference but worth noting fuelling system not as good so gen 2 a bit quicker when tuned.

9e for £13k offer a power kit which turns these into ridiculous rocketships. 0-100mph in 4.7 secs. 225mph + VMAX

Taffy66

5,964 posts

130 months

Thursday 21st November 2019
quotequote all
I'd much rather have a 991.2 Turbo rather than a 991.1 Turbo S for the same money.

Gameface

16,565 posts

105 months

Thursday 21st November 2019
quotequote all
IMI A said:
9e for £13k offer a power kit which turns these into ridiculous rocketships. 0-100mph in 4.7 secs. 225mph + VMAX
Can you post a link to that please?

Never you mind

1,507 posts

140 months

Thursday 21st November 2019
quotequote all
Gameface said:
IMI A said:
9e for £13k offer a power kit which turns these into ridiculous rocketships. 0-100mph in 4.7 secs. 225mph + VMAX
Can you post a link to that please?
https://www.nineexcellence.com/upgrades/9e-packages/991g2-turbo-stage-3-9e20pdk.html

Headline figures.
0-60mph 2.2 seconds
0-100mph 5.0 seconds

0-150mph 10.9 seconds
60-130mph 5.9 seconds
0-186mph 20 seconds


13K plus VAT so 16K in total.

GuitarPlayer63

198 posts

177 months

Saturday 23rd November 2019
quotequote all
i had the same choice to make earlier this year, budget was a little higher and ended up going for a Turbo, not the S.
There was a better choice of options, features and colours to choose from.
The only thing I was a little more concerned about with the S were the PCCB's - I dont track the car and didnt see the benefit and didnt want to be landed with the cost if something went wrong with one of them.

Good luck in your search!

northpolar

137 posts

164 months

Saturday 23rd November 2019
quotequote all
This may be completely irrelevant for you but from a practical perspective, I would much prefer five stud wheels as turbo rather than centre locks as turbo s. However rare they may be, p*nctures do happen and centre locks can be a pig. Qualification - so I have read, not experienced!!

Peter

Cheib

25,326 posts

203 months

Saturday 23rd November 2019
quotequote all
northpolar said:
This may be completely irrelevant for you but from a practical perspective, I would much prefer five stud wheels as turbo rather than centre locks as turbo s. However rare they may be, p*nctures do happen and centre locks can be a pig. Qualification - so I have read, not experienced!!

Peter
Think that depends on the tyre places local to you...I am lucky enough to be close enough to a couple of good local options. 911’s have long since ceased to have a spare tyre so you’re looking at the compressor and chemical gunge/roadside recovery CL’s or not.

Koln-RS

4,116 posts

240 months

Saturday 23rd November 2019
quotequote all
GuitarPlayer63 said:
The only thing I was a little more concerned about with the S were the PCCB's - I dont track the car and didnt see the benefit and didnt want to be landed with the cost if something went wrong with one of them.

Good luck in your search!
PCCBs are generally regarded as more beneficial for road use - reduced unsprung weight (for improved ride, handling), no brake dust or corrosion, 100,000 mls + life expectancy, super consistent performance.
Never heard of anyone having to replace them in normal road use.



GuitarPlayer63

198 posts

177 months

Saturday 23rd November 2019
quotequote all
Koln-RS said:
GuitarPlayer63 said:
The only thing I was a little more concerned about with the S were the PCCB's - I dont track the car and didnt see the benefit and didnt want to be landed with the cost if something went wrong with one of them.

Good luck in your search!
PCCBs are generally regarded as more beneficial for road use - reduced unsprung weight (for improved ride, handling), no brake dust or corrosion, 100,000 mls + life expectancy, super consistent performance.
Never heard of anyone having to replace them in normal road use.
I actually got put off by a Porsche dealership who said if the tyre fitter is sloppy they can be chipped needing replacement: i'd like to believe I go to a decent tyre place btw.. Anyway, I love the Turbo and dont feel like I'm missing out.

ChrisW.

8,116 posts

283 months

Sunday 24th November 2019
quotequote all
Porsche used to supply two aluminium rods along which a wheel could be slid to ensure no damage to a PCCB disc.

They stopped this ... you now have to spend a very small sum buying them if you specify PCCB's.

Anybody would think that they like replacing expensive discs ?

But the latest PCCB's are pretty good and there are now options other than Porsche replacements if you do have a problem ...

Deep

2,534 posts

271 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
Taffy66 said:
I'd much rather have a 991.2 Turbo rather than a 991.1 Turbo S for the same money.
May I ask why?

Taffy66

5,964 posts

130 months

Sunday 1st December 2019
quotequote all
Deep said:
Taffy66 said:
I'd much rather have a 991.2 Turbo rather than a 991.1 Turbo S for the same money.
May I ask why?
Basically the power difference narrows to 20PS which is pretty insignificant when you already have 540PS..It'll be at least two years newer with all that entails..The PASM and steering software were noticeably improved over the 991.1..And last but not least the PCM is the much later version which adds to daily usage..
Another benefit is if you prefer steels then its available on the non S Turbo..The biggest advantage of the non S Turbo is you can avoid the extremely impractical centre locks and get the more sensible five nut alloys.All IMHO..

Bob997GT3

9 posts

88 months

Sunday 8th December 2019
quotequote all
The centre lock wheels really are not an issue. All Porsches with these wheels come with an adapter (hidden within the frunk) which are simply placed over the central nut and then a standard wrench with extender pole can be used to remove. There is also a small tool to flip out the small centre cap.
All you need to do is find a tyre fitter that has a torque wrench so on replacement they can be tightened to correct torque setting as it states in the manual.

I had no problem with my 997 GT3 nor with my current 991.2 C4 GTS. Lots of tyre dealers assume only Porsche can remove centre locks and this is not the case. Just show them your adapter and read the manual, it’s so easy.

Cheers

Nick

red997

1,304 posts

237 months

Monday 9th December 2019
quotequote all
its not an issue removing the wheels with centre locks, as you correctly state the removal tool is in the front boot.

However, the issue is when centre locks an PCCB collide !
It's all too easy when removing the wheels to clip the brake discs;
do this to a PCCB disc and you are likely to chip the edge ; result - new disc

There are aftermarket tools that screw into the hub to assist
https://www.suncoastparts.com/product/CLTOOL.html

I've just had 2 x alloys refurbed on my 991 GT3 - had the OPC remove the wheels and the repair guy did the job in their premises.
Minimises the risk.