Cheapest pay as you go sim (to give elderly parent a phone)

Cheapest pay as you go sim (to give elderly parent a phone)

Author
Discussion

strath44

Original Poster:

1,364 posts

160 months

Tuesday 10th December 2019
quotequote all
Hi folks,

I want to give my old iphone to my dad, he has an old Nokia but wants to try an iphone (he has an ipad so should be fine). He calls very little but would text and a tiny bit of data!

Anyway neither he nor I want to tie in to a contract, what is the cheapest sim I can get that he can just top up the old fashion way?

Vodafone have one but you have to pay in £10 a month which I'm sure he won't use (it does roll over but a lot could accumulate!).

Any help much appreciated!

Mammasaid

4,639 posts

109 months

Troubleatmill

10,210 posts

171 months

Tuesday 10th December 2019
quotequote all
strath44 said:
Hi folks,

I want to give my old iphone to my dad, he has an old Nokia but wants to try an iphone (he has an ipad so should be fine). He calls very little but would text and a tiny bit of data!

Anyway neither he nor I want to tie in to a contract, what is the cheapest sim I can get that he can just top up the old fashion way?

Vodafone have one but you have to pay in £10 a month which I'm sure he won't use (it does roll over but a lot could accumulate!).

Any help much appreciated!
Giff Gaff isn't really a contract - you can change how much you want to pay from month to month....
Have a read.

gashart

123 posts

87 months

Tuesday 10th December 2019
quotequote all
Penny mobile been good for my sons phone

MYOB

5,031 posts

150 months

Tuesday 10th December 2019
quotequote all
Troubleatmill said:
Giff Gaff isn't really a contract - you can change how much you want to pay from month to month....
Have a read.
Yes, bundles from giff gaff are great. You can set up auto renewal for monthly charge. You fav choose which bundle you want, and cancel anytime. Think I pay £10 for each of my children but you can pay more or less pending on data usage.

They use 02's infrastructure and works pretty well.

strath44

Original Poster:

1,364 posts

160 months

Wednesday 11th December 2019
quotequote all
Thanks folks I’ll have a look tomorrow sorry it’s a bit of a minefield!

stevoknevo

1,705 posts

202 months

Wednesday 11th December 2019
quotequote all
I used 3's 123 for a long time - provided you get service indoors and, you say he won't use it much, it's great. 1p per mb, 2p per text, 3p per minute - you can top up online or buy a voucher from just about any shop. PAYG so no contract, just buy a sim for a £1. I was only spending around £40-50pa as I was generally on wifi and used whatsapp etc for calls/messages, it was mainly data I used for light browsing at work - set everything up to only update on WiFi and stay away from streaming video on data and your credit lasts a long time indeed.
Or Giff Gaff starts at £6pm for 500mb/300 minutes/500 texts

Pothole

34,367 posts

294 months

Wednesday 11th December 2019
quotequote all
strath44 said:
Thanks folks I’ll have a look tomorrow sorry it’s a bit of a minefield!
It's only become that since you decided £10 a month was too much.

droopsnoot

13,193 posts

254 months

Wednesday 11th December 2019
quotequote all
Mammasaid said:
I'm on that as well, having switched from EE when I discovered how expensive it was. I use very little mobile, so having to pay something per month is wasteful, it's mainly with me in the car in case I need to summon the RAC. The only inconvenience (which is not 3, it's everyone now) is that it can't be topped up from an ATM any more.

stevoknevo

1,705 posts

202 months

Wednesday 11th December 2019
quotequote all
Pothole said:
strath44 said:
Thanks folks I’ll have a look tomorrow sorry it’s a bit of a minefield!
It's only become that since you decided £10 a month was too much.
It is too much if it's not going to be used much - there could easily be a £100pa saving on PAYG versus a rolling SIM contract.

shtu

3,865 posts

158 months

Wednesday 11th December 2019
quotequote all
Fiver a month contract, and save faffing with topups?

https://talkmobile.co.uk/

M4cruiser

4,351 posts

162 months

Tuesday 22nd April
quotequote all
PAYG is still a problem for keeping a backup phone in the car for emergencies. I ensure I do a text or call within 6 months, which used to be the rule for keeping the SIM active.

I've been on O2 but they've cut me off twice, and now they've revealed they've changed the rules, and you need to TOP UP within 6 months, not just use 10p worth.

£20 a year may not seem a lot, but as a phone which I hope I never have to use, it's s lot! More then the road tax (until this month redface )

So is "3" the only one now that doesn't cut you off with no top-ups?

O2 still aren't publicising their new rules. They still say "or" not "and".

vaud

54,143 posts

167 months

Tuesday 22nd April
quotequote all
Lebara have a contract for £5/month, reasonable usage, with a discount to £2.50 for the first x months. I know that is more than the PAYG but you will never be cut off.

Le Gavroche

144 posts

10 months

Tuesday 22nd April
quotequote all
M4cruiser said:
PAYG is still a problem for keeping a backup phone in the car for emergencies. I ensure I do a text or call within 6 months, which used to be the rule for keeping the SIM active.

I've been on O2 but they've cut me off twice, and now they've revealed they've changed the rules, and you need to TOP UP within 6 months, not just use 10p worth.

£20 a year may not seem a lot, but as a phone which I hope I never have to use, it's s lot! More then the road tax (until this month redface )

So is "3" the only one now that doesn't cut you off with no top-ups?

O2 still aren't publicising their new rules. They still say "or" not "and".
I'm probably missing something here, but why would you need a backup phone? Surely your usual phone will be fine in the case of an emergency?

Vasco

17,940 posts

117 months

Tuesday 22nd April
quotequote all
Le Gavroche said:
M4cruiser said:
PAYG is still a problem for keeping a backup phone in the car for emergencies. I ensure I do a text or call within 6 months, which used to be the rule for keeping the SIM active.

I've been on O2 but they've cut me off twice, and now they've revealed they've changed the rules, and you need to TOP UP within 6 months, not just use 10p worth.

£20 a year may not seem a lot, but as a phone which I hope I never have to use, it's s lot! More then the road tax (until this month redface )

So is "3" the only one now that doesn't cut you off with no top-ups?

O2 still aren't publicising their new rules. They still say "or" not "and".
I'm probably missing something here, but why would you need a backup phone? Surely your usual phone will be fine in the case of an emergency?
Phones get easily lost or mislaid, left at home etc. It's handy to have a back up.

vikingaero

11,755 posts

181 months

Tuesday 22nd April
quotequote all
vaud said:
Lebara have a contract for £5/month, reasonable usage, with a discount to £2.50 for the first x months. I know that is more than the PAYG but you will never be cut off.
I have a Lebara SIM for £4.95 with 1Gb of data, but unlimited calls for my Mum in her Nokia flip phone. She can gas for hours without incurring additional costs or the risk of the PAYG SIM being cut off. I chuckle inside when they email offering her a bonus 2Gb of data for being a loyal customer - data that she can't use!


Vasco said:
Le Gavroche said:
M4cruiser said:
PAYG is still a problem for keeping a backup phone in the car for emergencies. I ensure I do a text or call within 6 months, which used to be the rule for keeping the SIM active.

I've been on O2 but they've cut me off twice, and now they've revealed they've changed the rules, and you need to TOP UP within 6 months, not just use 10p worth.

£20 a year may not seem a lot, but as a phone which I hope I never have to use, it's s lot! More then the road tax (until this month redface )

So is "3" the only one now that doesn't cut you off with no top-ups?

O2 still aren't publicising their new rules. They still say "or" not "and".
I'm probably missing something here, but why would you need a backup phone? Surely your usual phone will be fine in the case of an emergency?
Phones get easily lost or mislaid, left at home etc. It's handy to have a back up.
It's quite easy to cane your smartphone so that the battery lasts barely a day. Or you forget a powerbank or charging cable. I carry a Nokia toughphone in my kit when I go caving, because even when underground there are places you can get a signal or send a text (under airshafts, near entrances). Add to that 3-5 day battery life and its a decent backup especially when you have it on a different network to your main phone.

Mr Pointy

12,371 posts

171 months

Tuesday 22nd April
quotequote all
This is a six year old necro thread.

richhead

2,138 posts

23 months

Tuesday 22nd April
quotequote all
vaud said:
Lebara have a contract for £5/month, reasonable usage, with a discount to £2.50 for the first x months. I know that is more than the PAYG but you will never be cut off.
This is what both me and my g/f use, ive had mine about 6 months now and its been good. I was on o2 on a sim only and it was 4 times as much, and it seems the lebara has better coverage in my area, i have no idea what network they use.

vaud

54,143 posts

167 months

Tuesday 22nd April
quotequote all
Vodafone.

It’s a perfect SIM for my 11 year old. The customer service is really good as well - the first sim didn’t get delivered and after a quick web chat they shipped one in 24 hours with special delivery .