Brake fade, any ideas?
Brake fade, any ideas?
Author
Discussion

jmct

Original Poster:

61 posts

137 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
After some spirited driving around Milton Keynes (long straights then roundabouts) the brakes faded and gave me a bit of a scare. Discs are standard size and not that old (drilled and grooved) and neither are the EBC red stuff pads. Car is a 500 and putting out just under 330bhp. Is it likely to be the brake fluid or just insufficient brakes or something else?

Classic Chim

12,424 posts

170 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
jmct said:
After some spirited driving around Milton Keynes (long straights then roundabouts) the brakes faded and gave me a bit of a scare. Discs are standard size and not that old (drilled and grooved) and neither are the EBC red stuff pads. Car is a 500 and putting out just under 330bhp. Is it likely to be the brake fluid or just insufficient brakes or something else?
Sounds like standard brakes getting to hot, suprised the red stuff can’t cope.
It does’nt take long or many emergency stops to overheat road brakes,
I found within 3 laps of a shortish race circuit my brakes were gone.
If there getting very hot you might have boiled the fluid a bit which adds to the problem.
Maybe try another type of pad and bleed front brakes with good new fluid.

magpies

5,190 posts

203 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
I'd also completely refresh the brake fluid to Dot 5.1 assuming you are on Dot 4 at the mo. 5.1 has a higher boiling point and is compatible with 4.

Do NOT use Dot 5 as that is completely different and non compatible.

jmct

Original Poster:

61 posts

137 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
I’ll give the TVR garage a call and see what fluid they used for the last 12k service.

leerdam23

606 posts

282 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
...any decent garage should have a brake fluid tester...?

jmct

Original Poster:

61 posts

137 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
So garage has confirmed DOT4 was used. Any brand better than others for 5.1. Also any top tips for flushing through and replacing the fluid.

Steve_D

13,801 posts

279 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
jmct said:
.............. Also any top tips for flushing through and replacing the fluid.
Depends how valuable your time is.
Empty the system with a pressure or vacuum bleeder. Then fill the system and bleed. Time consuming.

Or
Buy a bottle of fluid. Bleed around all four corners topping up with the new fluid as you go. When the bottle is empty you are done.

Steve

anonymous-user

75 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
Was it brake fade or excessive pedal travel?

Edited by anonymous-user on Monday 30th December 22:16

phillpot

17,436 posts

204 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
Dot 4 has a minimum standard, I don't profess to fully understand it all but I do know there are some very good Dot 4 brake fluids available that exceed the standard requirements, going to a dot 5.1 isn't necessarily the best solution?


A couple that get well recommended are Motul RBF 600.

Or AP Racing Radi-Cal R3

If you want to "push the boat out" there's Castrol SRF




Edited by phillpot on Monday 30th December 21:53

TwinKam

3,446 posts

116 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
Steve_D said:
jmct said:
.............. Also any top tips for flushing through and replacing the fluid.
Depends how valuable your time is.
Empty the system with a pressure or vacuum bleeder. Then fill the system and bleed. Time consuming.

Or
Buy a bottle of fluid. Bleed around all four corners topping up with the new fluid as you go. When the bottle is empty you are done.

Steve
Or, somewhere between, lies this method. It takes hardly any more time than method 'b' but has the advantage of method 'a', ie not mixing old and new fluids in the reservoir:
Get as much as possible out of the reservoir first, if you dont have a vacuum pump then a turkey baster will do fine. Then fill the reservoir with new fluid and bleed all corners, starting with the furthest, topping up as required. If you use a clear tube you will see when you're bleeding out the new fluid compared to the old. You'll probably use between 500ml and a litre bottle.

Macbags

119 posts

76 months

Monday 30th December 2019
quotequote all
JMCT I was having a good blast around MK today as well.......would have been fun to see you. No brake fade in my case but cold tyres and damp roads are not the best combination

magpies

5,190 posts

203 months

Tuesday 31st December 2019
quotequote all
Macbags said:
No brake fade in my case but cold tyres and damp roads are not the best combination
so you won't have gotten anywhere near the brake temperature to promote fade


As phillpot above has said buy a good quality brake fluid and not the cheapest from local trader, spec for 5.1 is higher than 4 anyway.

if cost is not a problem then SRF is the best way to go also does not mark paintwork, but is NOT to be mixed wit other fluids.

anonymous-user

75 months

Tuesday 31st December 2019
quotequote all
Before spending money, establish if its a pad issue or a fluid issue.

gruffalo

8,071 posts

247 months

Wednesday 1st January 2020
quotequote all
TVRMs said:
Before spending money, establish if its a pad issue or a fluid issue.
This all day long!

If the peddle travel got longer with little resistance then you boiled the fluid and so get a high temp fluid as mentioned above.

Keep it dot4 as that is the correct chemical make up for the car and moving to dot5 is on absolutely no benefit as the temp specs are much the same as standard dot4 but the dot5 could well dissolve seals in your braking system.

If the peddle was still firm then you melted the surface of the pad and you need better pads, I find Pagid RS14 absolutely brilliant on the Cerbera and normally use AP R4 brake fluid and never have braking issues on track or road.




jmct

Original Poster:

61 posts

137 months

Wednesday 1st January 2020
quotequote all
Pedal travel did not increase. Changing the pads may well lead me down the road to upgrading the calipers to WMS or Alcons since I fancy having a go at some track days.

Edited by jmct on Wednesday 1st January 13:27

GinG15

501 posts

192 months

Thursday 2nd January 2020
quotequote all
if pedal travel has not changed (increased) there isnt any air inside the system, nor you boiled the fluide....means you cancancel searching the problem at the brake-fluide.
might be that the pads became glazed, hence reduced friction.

get some decent brake pads like mintex, and throw away the EBC´s (never liked them, for me this brand is r*bbish)




mk1fan

10,827 posts

246 months

Thursday 2nd January 2020
quotequote all
gruffalo said:
This all day long!

If the peddle travel got longer with little resistance then you boiled the fluid and so get a high temp fluid as mentioned above.

Keep it dot4 as that is the correct chemical make up for the car and moving to dot5 is on absolutely no benefit as the temp specs are much the same as standard dot4 but the dot5 could well dissolve seals in your braking system.

If the peddle was still firm then you melted the surface of the pad and you need better pads, I find Pagid RS14 absolutely brilliant on the Cerbera and normally use AP R4 brake fluid and never have braking issues on track or road.
Do you mean DOT 5.0 - which is entirely different to DOT 4.0 and DOT 5.1?

O/T - as linked to above. A good quality DOT 4.0 fluid will be more than up to the job for road use unless you're driving really inappropriately on the 'road'.

Brake - and clutch - fluid is a service item so should be changed regularly. If I were changing the discs and pads alround, I would be changing the fluid as well.

The standard brake set up was designed for a much heavier car so is more than adequate.

anonymous-user

75 months

Thursday 2nd January 2020
quotequote all
GinG15 said:
if pedal travel has not changed (increased) there isnt any air inside the system, nor you boiled the fluide....means you cancancel searching the problem at the brake-fluide.
might be that the pads became glazed, hence reduced friction.

get some decent brake pads like mintex, and throw away the EBC´s (never liked them, for me this brand is r*bbish)
I agree with your thoughts on EBC.

Rubbish or not, I’ve never heard of anyone cooking pads on today’s roads. smile

leerdam23

606 posts

282 months

Thursday 2nd January 2020
quotequote all
I've driven on track both a chim 450 with standard 260mm discs (my first TVR) and a 4.3 precat griff with standard 240mm discs. I've never had brake fade from overheating. Pad glazing is more likely IMHO. Take out the pads and clean off the top layer with some wet&dry (rub the pad on the paper on a flat surface), put them back in and try to replicate the problem. Make sure the discs are not out of spec, ie thin and corroded or that if they are drilled, the holes full of crap. I find grooved discs are better nearer the heat limit.

Brake upgrades are often an unsprung weight downdgrade and the real problem is the discs or pads or calipers (could be a sticky caliper causing the pad to over heat) need servicing or replacing.

Just my humble opinion of course.

Edited by leerdam23 on Thursday 2nd January 18:07

QBee

22,026 posts

165 months

Thursday 2nd January 2020
quotequote all
I have done many track days. I use bigger brakes (324mm grooved disks) with Hawk pads, which are between road and race spec.
I also use dot 4 fluid, but a good quality one. I did use dot 5.1 for a while, but it is more hygroscopic, so needs to be changed more regularly

I have never suffered brake fade with that set up, but have on the one occasion I put a set of new Carbon Lorraine full race pads in without changing the fluid. After about 5 laps of hard braking on a twisty circuit I started to notice longer pedal travel, and at the end of a straight when i braked hard for a 90 left I lost the brakes completely at 120 mph and spun out.

Back to the pits, changed underwear and pads - the pads back to the worn Hawk pads, topped up the fluid and completed the track day with no further loss of brakes.

So, from my experience I would suggest you might be boiling the fluid, especially if it actually wasn't changed at the last service. But if you did, you should have seen some evidence of brake fluid spilling out of the reservoir. If you didn't, then you must suspect glazed pads or worn discs.