Advice please
Author
Discussion

piperdelux

Original Poster:

277 posts

156 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
Hi all,

Would really appreciate some advice regarding OH's motor. It's an X plate polo 1.4 petrol. Sailed through MOT last month, but just been told the clutch is knackered so wants replacing. They only want £200 so no biggy. But, it keeps throwing up little issues as I appreciate any car this age would.

I'm wondering whether best to suck up the £200, better the devil and all that, and hope for the best. Or save the £200, and chop it in against something else, as an example this:

https://www.ivybridgetradecentre.co.uk/used-toyota...

That purely on the basis that I've seen on here those yaris' are as 'bulletproof' as possible for this kind of price range? Although I do recall something about avoiding those with a certain type of gearbox?

The car is really only used as a daily commuter for about 10 miles a day. I'm fully aware that changing to something else is a risk at this price point as anything will likely throw up issues.

Apologies for the long winded question, any help appreciated as always.

designforlife

3,742 posts

192 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
£1500 will get you into a 1.5 Yaris T-sport with cash to spare in a private sale, the 1.3 is a bit asthmatic...and i would say the one you've posted is a little overpriced.

They like to eat front droplinks, and have a good poke about for rust, but that's about it... the engine is chain driven and generally very reliable if maintained.

Parts generally are cheap and plentiful, not sure about gearbox issues, most jap cars i've owned/driven are a bit notchy when cold.

However - all that said, I would stick with what you have and pony up the £200... it's almost always cheaper to stick with what you have unless something major goes wrong.

p4cks

7,479 posts

228 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
£200 for a clutch is peanuts.

That Yaris (or something of a similar age/price bracket) will throw up just as many little issues as the Polo.

I'd stick with what you know and keep the Polo.

kiethton

14,631 posts

209 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
I'd just get the clutch done, make friends with a mobile mechanic to minimise future ongoing costs and run the current car to the ground. Youd be paying £1k extra for no additional benefit and will likely see very similar ongoing costs

Olas

911 posts

86 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
If you can get a car for less than the 200quid to fix the polo then do so.

If you can fix the polo for
Less than the price of buying a new car then do so.
If you really want to change, the polo will sell for a lot more as a runner than a non runner.

Either way, do the clutch.

piperdelux

Original Poster:

277 posts

156 months

Tuesday 25th February 2020
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies, pretty much confirmed what I was thinking, thanks for taking the time to help.