Insurance for a new driver
Author
Discussion

Gweeds

Original Poster:

7,954 posts

81 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
So, my daughter turns 17 in a couple of months and we're now looking at cars (Hyundai i10 and the like).

What's the best way to get the insurance done? Her own policy? Me having a policy with her as a named driver? What happens with the change from a provisional to a full licence?

Stoofa

959 posts

197 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
Always best to get a driver onto their own policy asap - start building up the all important first 5yrs NCB.
With regards named drivers, please don't front - you can get into an awful lot of trouble for doing that.
Seriously consider "black box" insurance for the first couple of years.

Gweeds

Original Poster:

7,954 posts

81 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
Stoofa said:
Always best to get a driver onto their own policy asap - start building up the all important first 5yrs NCB.
With regards named drivers, please don't front - you can get into an awful lot of trouble for doing that.
Seriously consider "black box" insurance for the first couple of years.
I had a feeling that the whole named driver thing wasn't the best option - but it's a long time since I learned so wanted to check.

Definitely looking at a black box. She's fairly risk-averse anyway so I don't think she'll be at all bothered by that.

Thank you though - sort of confirmed my thinking.

sjc

16,416 posts

299 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
Tesco black box has been good for my daughter.
No driving restrictions, earn bonus miles for good driving, and you can top up the miles in segments if you require.
As above, get the policy in her name, and if you have a couple of adults with decent driving records add them as named drivers, that seems to bring the cost down.
And play around with things like excess/mileages etc, there’s no rhyme or reason as to what figures come back !
Oh and try and get the quotes with as far away from the proposed start date as well, that can sometimes help.

jondude

2,441 posts

246 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
As pointed out above, the idea is to make the insurers feel the risk is lessened.

Moving to the Scottish outback helps, rather than living in London. Not including commuting helps, low mileage and agreeing to the black box/dashcam.

But it seems the insurers work within the same very high premium band based on age alone for youngsters so there really is not much that can be done except bite the bullet and pay handsomely for the right to drive.

Another way to help is as I think she/you are doing, save loads in VED duty by getting a 30 quid a year or less in tax car. If it is a 60 mpg car too that claws back some decent money.

Maybe get a zero rated for tax group 1 car and fit LPG smile (Just kidding....most insurers add 30 odd quid if you convert to LPG)




Jamescrs

6,387 posts

94 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
You will find that insuring her as a learner driver will be pretty reasonable cost wise but don't let this fool you, as soon as she passes her test the premium will raise significantly, possibly by thousands so it's sensible to shop for policies both with her as a learner driver and as a newly licenced driver to give yourself an idea of what you're getting into.

Eyersey1234

3,084 posts

108 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
Another tip is to play around a bit with quotes for different cars and see what comes up cheapest

alscar

9,788 posts

242 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
Start with confused.com etc but I found Admiral relatively acceptable premium wise for my 3 children.
As others have said don't go the fronting route - both illegal and insurers wise to it.
Premium will increase once test passed but again I found Admiral didn't steal too much from me at that point - getting them to at least 1 year NCB is the bit to aim for.

anonymous-user

83 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
Collingwood do learner driver insurance which is what we used for my son to drive his own car. Good thing is when he passes they refund the unused months of the policy. It was £300 for him on his own Fiesta.

https://www.collingwood.co.uk/learner-driver-insur...

When he passes he’ll need a new policy and we expect that to he over a grand.

As above, simplest solution is to get your daughter her own insurance policy.

MellowshipSlinky

16,085 posts

218 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
My daughter was 17 last June and we bought a Vauxhall Adam 1.2 for her.
It’s registered in my wife’s name and she has her own insurance with me as named driver.
My daughter also has her own insurance on it which is pretty cheap (as one of us has to be with her when she drives it).
If daughter has an accident when driving (as a learner) it’s her insurance that takes the hit - not my wife’s.

When daughter passes her test (hopefully next week), the car will stay registered to my wife but my daughter will have her own very expensive insurance and will be classed as the main driver with me and the wife as named drivers.

Who me ?

7,455 posts

241 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
MS- I've always told my kids to add me as a driver on their cars. Don't know why , i don't even have to be in car, but it's always lopped a wedge of the premium.

Cyberprog

2,324 posts

212 months

Sunday 15th March 2020
quotequote all
[quote=Who me ?]MS- I've always told my kids to add me as a driver on their cars. Don't know why , i don't even have to be in car, but it's always lopped a wedge of the premium.
[/quote]

There can be a number of factors, when my partner passed her test, adding her as a named drive to my policy reduced my premium - even though she had bugger all experience and would be driving my Discovery! Bonkers.

RSTurboPaul

13,090 posts

287 months

Monday 16th March 2020
quotequote all
One note of caution re: black boxes is that, as I understand it, some companies keep note of any 'transgressions' and then load future premiums, even without a black box.

Or, if you're Carrot insurance, cancel a policy because it thinks you're driving while you're sitting on the sofa at home.

Drumroll

4,517 posts

149 months

Monday 16th March 2020
quotequote all
Another thing to remember with black boxes is they record all journeys, so if you took your daughters car for a drive "to try it out" that may adversely affect the black box data for her.

seyre1972

3,068 posts

172 months

Monday 16th March 2020
quotequote all
Went through this over Xmas when my daughter turned 17.

As others have said - try different cars, add yourself/wife as named drivers. For us it came out cheaper to have a policy with no black box weirdly. While she’s learning it was roughly £300. When she passes her test it’s approx £1200. But as on a multi-car policy, she’ll have earnt 1 years no claim by June when our policy renews.

Not that I enjoy taking the powder blue fiat 500 (nicknamed `Fifi) out at every opportunity ..... smile

sjc

16,416 posts

299 months

Monday 16th March 2020
quotequote all
seyre1972 said:
Went through this over Xmas when my daughter turned 17.

As others have said - try different cars, add yourself/wife as named drivers. For us it came out cheaper to have a policy with no black box weirdly. While she’s learning it was roughly £300. When she passes her test it’s approx £1200. But as on a multi-car policy, she’ll have earnt 1 years no claim by June when our policy renews.

Not that I enjoy taking the powder blue fiat 500 (nicknamed `Fifi) out at every opportunity ..... smile
Just be careful that the one year no claims earned is recognised by other insurers, as she will lose it if she swaps as they will say it’s not a full year.

chopper602

2,333 posts

252 months

Monday 16th March 2020
quotequote all
Admiral do a ten month policy (intrusive black box), which comes with 1 years no claims at end of term. Worth knowing. My son has his own insurance on a Twingo that I own. Year 1 was as a learner before passing test, which, as I'd shopped around didn't increase (Direct Line - terrible black box). Year 2 they wanted even more premium, even though 1 years no claims had accrued. Went with the above Admiral policy for half the Direct Line renewal. Onto year 4 soon and the renewal is just over £300. It makes quite a difference to use the actual mileage the car will be driven rather than 'average'.

Putting my daughter, currently a Learner, onto this policy as soon as she passes her theory, so expecting it to increase greatly.

fastbikes76

2,450 posts

151 months

Monday 16th March 2020
quotequote all
chopper602 said:
Admiral do a ten month policy (intrusive black box), which comes with 1 years no claims at end of term. Worth knowing..
Be very careful with this trap, my daughter did the 10months bonus accelerator with a supposed 1 year NCB at the end. What they don’t tell you is 99% of Ins companies don’t recognise the 10month policies NCB. My daughter had to shop around and start again !

Regards
Fb

sjc

16,416 posts

299 months

Monday 16th March 2020
quotequote all
fastbikes76 said:
chopper602 said:
Admiral do a ten month policy (intrusive black box), which comes with 1 years no claims at end of term. Worth knowing..
Be very careful with this trap, my daughter did the 10months bonus accelerator with a supposed 1 year NCB at the end. What they don’t tell you is 99% of Ins companies don’t recognise the 10month policies NCB. My daughter had to shop around and start again !

Regards
Fb
Indeed, as I also mentioned above.
There’s also some policies that morph into full license ones from provisional ones that have the same trap.

Somebody

1,756 posts

112 months

Monday 16th March 2020
quotequote all
Jamescrs said:
You will find that insuring her as a learner driver will be pretty reasonable cost wise but don't let this fool you, as soon as she passes her test the premium will raise significantly, possibly by thousands so it's sensible to shop for policies both with her as a learner driver and as a newly licenced driver to give yourself an idea of what you're getting into.
This ^

Went through this 3 years ago. Look at the cheapest to insure cars (we ended up with a 1 litre i10), then add both both parents as named drivers to the policy.


Edited by Somebody on Tuesday 17th March 13:57