Furlough Fraud
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

78 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Watching the news this morning a business owner said he has made the job safe yet people on furlough said they don't want to come back, he called it furlough fraud.. I also know a manufacturing company in same position. I thought furlough was to protect jobs, if there are jobs how can people still stay on fuirlough?

Greenie

1,850 posts

265 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
It's not up to employees if they are furloughed or not. The business decides.

kiethton

14,510 posts

204 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Greenie said:
It's not up to employees if they are furloughed or not. The business decides.
This, a P45 in the post would soon sharpen the mind

mondeoman

11,430 posts

290 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Surely its the business that decides furlough or not - if his business is safe and he tells them to get back to work, and they decide not to, then they are in breach of contract and he can quite legally not pay them anymore - they don't want the job any longer, obviously.

skinnyman

1,875 posts

117 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
My mothers company is having similar problems. They've introduced all the government safety recommendations, but there's still a few people that "don't feel safe", in other words, want to continue watching Netflix for a few months.

I've told her it now has to be a case of return to work, or leave the company.

V88Dicky

7,362 posts

207 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Yep, my wife's place is announcing redundancies today. Apparently some people's actions have made things a little easier.


anonymous-user

Original Poster:

78 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Greenie said:
It's not up to employees if they are furloughed or not. The business decides.
The way he spoke any the family friend it seems like the furlough staff could stay on furlough which i though was incorrect.

Condi

19,828 posts

195 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Greenie said:
It's not up to employees if they are furloughed or not. The business decides.
True, but there are a lot of people playing the 'I'm too scared' or 'I'm vulnerable' or 'Its not safe' cards, and putting obstacles in the way of going back to work. No doubt with the support of various unions or whatever.

For a lot of companies they are getting close to the 45 day cut off before they have to start paying 20% of the wages or make the staff redundant. Expect to hear a lot of people getting let go in the next couple of weeks.

chrispmartha

22,138 posts

153 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Any employee who has been working from home succesfully and requests that they keep doing that until they feel safer going into the office has IMO a good point and the employers should listen and try to respect that.

People on Furlough should be going back to work when their employer asks them to, no ifs or buts.

There is a middle ground to that though, what if they are on Furlough, the employer wants them to start work again in the office but they are perfectly capable of working from home?

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

78 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
it was pimlico plumbing, yes he is a bit of an idiot.

300sl-24

584 posts

118 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
The Spruce Goose said:
it was pimlico plumbing, yes he is a bit of an idiot.
Quite a wealthy idiot I would imagine......

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

78 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Condi said:
Greenie said:
It's not up to employees if they are furloughed or not. The business decides.
True, but there are a lot of people playing the 'I'm too scared' or 'I'm vulnerable' or 'Its not safe' cards, and putting obstacles in the way of going back to work. No doubt with the support of various unions or whatever.

For a lot of companies they are getting close to the 45 day cut off before they have to start paying 20% of the wages or make the staff redundant. Expect to hear a lot of people getting let go in the next couple of weeks.
I'm currently in that particular water tight vessel and am fully expecting to be let go as the industry i work in - Dental - is currently screwed. If they think they can weather the storm and ask me to go back, then go back i will. They will have to put something in place due to potential issues with life long ill health but i was working from home before being furloughed.
However, if they say wear a mask and come back, then off i go.

Greenie

1,850 posts

265 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Condi said:
Greenie said:
It's not up to employees if they are furloughed or not. The business decides.
True, but there are a lot of people playing the 'I'm too scared' or 'I'm vulnerable' or 'Its not safe' cards, and putting obstacles in the way of going back to work. No doubt with the support of various unions or whatever.

For a lot of companies they are getting close to the 45 day cut off before they have to start paying 20% of the wages or make the staff redundant. Expect to hear a lot of people getting let go in the next couple of weeks.
There are going to be enormous challenging coming out of lockdown and dealing with the virus - however the process of companies looking at what employees are productive and making the tough decisions that are needed is going to bring a large productivity increases. Some employees appear it be making that decision easier.

Difficult times ahead indeed.

PeteinSQ

2,346 posts

234 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
The Spruce Goose said:
it was pimlico plumbing, yes he is a bit of an idiot.
I thought all his staff were self employed? I'm sure there was a big court case around it a few years ago? I know they all earn a fortune anyway.

PeteinSQ

2,346 posts

234 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Condi said:
True, but there are a lot of people playing the 'I'm too scared' or 'I'm vulnerable' or 'Its not safe' cards, and putting obstacles in the way of going back to work. No doubt with the support of various unions or whatever.

For a lot of companies they are getting close to the 45 day cut off before they have to start paying 20% of the wages or make the staff redundant. Expect to hear a lot of people getting let go in the next couple of weeks.
I can see this being a real issue. I would imagine companies have to be incredibly careful around following government guidelines, you can get in enough hotwater if someone doesn't have an ergonomic office chair so I could see it being a lot worse if someone dies from Covid-19 that they contracted on site.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

78 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
PeteinSQ said:
I thought all his staff were self employed? I'm sure there was a big court case around it a few years ago? I know they all earn a fortune anyway.
he said some had been furloughed. the interesting part was he said he carried on the work without them.

bigandclever

14,227 posts

262 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
PeteinSQ said:
The Spruce Goose said:
it was pimlico plumbing, yes he is a bit of an idiot.
I thought all his staff were self employed? I'm sure there was a big court case around it a few years ago? I know they all earn a fortune anyway.
It’s the opposite. He said they were self-employed; the courts eventually decided they were workers with employment rights.

bigandclever

14,227 posts

262 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
His stance on it is pretty clear laugh

The furlough scheme is meant to protect businesses and people, but the concern is its being abused and we have first-hand experience with employees taking the piss.
...
Furlough, in some instances, has been used as an extended paid holiday, and quite frankly they can stay off for good – and that’s a promise, not a threat!

https://www.pimlicoplumbers.com/blog/if-you-ve-tak...

menousername

2,366 posts

166 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
Its an interesting topic and a thread I hope does not descend into calling people work shy etc. Genuinely interested in how this is going to be managed nationally.

As controversial as it is, even if the work site is safe, people might need to commute by public transport. I would not want people to feel forced to do something they are not comfortable doing through fear of losing their jobs. Behind each employee might be an elderly relative, or someone imuno-compromised, etc. Then there is the legal grey area if they do get ill going to the work site. Its tricky.

Having had tens of thousands of people out not socially distancing over the last few days, which was helpful, I think we also now have a 2 or 3 week wait and see situation now.


Eric Mc

124,958 posts

289 months

Monday 8th June 2020
quotequote all
300sl-24 said:
The Spruce Goose said:
it was pimlico plumbing, yes he is a bit of an idiot.
Quite a wealthy idiot I would imagine......
But he doesn't have any employees I thought?