Insurance - cancel or let it run?
Insurance - cancel or let it run?
Author
Discussion

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,890 posts

186 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
Ive just reinsured my weekend car as the limited 3000 miles on my current policy were about to run out.

My current policy is due to expire on 23rd August and my new policy is due to begin on 7th August (the day where i predict i will go over the miles limit).

If i cancel my current policy i will incur an admin charge and early cancelation fee.

I am really tempted to cancel the auto renewal and let the policy lapse.

WWYD?

Thanks

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,890 posts

186 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Not by a country mile. Paid £540 to start a new policy with 5000 miles. (Thank you Brentacre)

Previous insurer wanted £140 to add 1000 miles to policy (of which id have likely used only a few hundred).

anonymous-user

83 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
Two policies in force on the same car could get very murky in the event you did need to claim.

Depends how much the admin fee means to you really. Personally I’d probably cancel the old policy, but then I’m risk averse when it comes to this sort of thing.

MalcXFR

643 posts

77 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
Think one of the questions on the quote is usually something like:-

Is there any other insurance on the vehicle

anonymous-user

83 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
WWID?

Either not use it for a couple of weekends or do nothing at all. I’ve had limited mileage policies for decades and never had any serious query about the exact mileage the car’s have done.


Cliftonite

8,740 posts

167 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
REALIST123 said:
WWID?

Either not use it for a couple of weekends or do nothing at all. I’ve had limited mileage policies for decades and never had any serious query about the exact mileage the car’s have done.
The insurance company may well have taken a keen interest in possible excess mileage in the event of a claim, though?


Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,890 posts

186 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I did, they were last years (current) insurer, and although competitive, Brentacre blew them out the water (which i wasnt expecting, tbh).

catso

16,416 posts

296 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
I am really tempted to cancel the auto renewal and let the policy lapse.

WWYD?
Not use any company that insist on auto renewal...

BertBert

21,258 posts

240 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
Just out of interest, what does your insurance say about when you get to the miles specified? I have had several different variants over the years.
Bert

jondude

2,441 posts

246 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
Not sure if the other policy has NCD on it but if it does, you will lose this present year if you cancel I believe.

I would just let it lapse (again making sure you are not on recurring payments and all that).

As another has said, if it worries you just cut back on the use of the car over those two weeks between policies.

Another thing is the 'old' policy at least ensures the police won't pull you over as you are showing as insured, whereas the new policy might not do so for at least a few days.(I have found insurers getting quicker here, to be fair)

QuickQuack

2,811 posts

130 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
The renewal paperwork often states that it's proof of NCD which you probably already have, if not then will do soon, to be able to prove your NCD to next year's insurer. Personally, I'd cancel auto renewal and let it run out, and if I needed to make a claim in the crossover period, claim from the new insurer.

Rick101

7,189 posts

179 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
If you want the NCD, just let it run. It's only a few days.

I've left policies to run for several months as the benefit of cancelling was marginal if any.
Yes, no doubt someone will say their *could be a claim against you, but I think that's pretty unlikely.
Insurance, It's all about considering the risk.

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,890 posts

186 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
I discussed the NCB issue with the guy from Brentacre after he had already quoted using 1 yr ncb and he went back to the underwriter with 0 yrs ncb and the price stayed the same. smile

vikingaero

13,268 posts

198 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
The issue with dual insurance is thus:

In the event of a claim, the Insurer may find out that there is another policy in force. Sometimes they specifically ask this question in claim forms and telephone reporting. So both policies will cover the one loss. There will be TWO sets of excesses to pay for the TWO claims on ONE incident. When it comes to renewal, you will have to declare TWO claims.

Chance it? Up to you. If it were me I'd chance it.

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,890 posts

186 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
Purpose of this thread was really to check there were no major red flags.

To me at least, it seems there arent.

Im going for the chance it option.

Cheers all

TwigtheWonderkid

49,040 posts

179 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Not by a country mile. Paid £540 to start a new policy with 5000 miles. (Thank you Brentacre)

Previous insurer wanted £140 to add 1000 miles to policy (of which id have likely used only a few hundred).
If you declared a limit for the year, and had an accident just short of the year end and had done slightly over, 200 miles, there's no way the insurer could refuse cover. TCF regs just wouldn't allow it. At most, they could have asked you to pay the further £140, but they probably wouldn't even have done that.

You've completely wasted your money taking out the new policy.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,040 posts

179 months

Sunday 26th July 2020
quotequote all
vikingaero said:
The issue with dual insurance is thus:

In the event of a claim, the Insurer may find out that there is another policy in force. Sometimes they specifically ask this question in claim forms and telephone reporting. So both policies will cover the one loss. There will be TWO sets of excesses to pay for the TWO claims on ONE incident. When it comes to renewal, you will have to declare TWO claims.

Chance it? Up to you. If it were me I'd chance it.
That wouldn't happen in this case. 2 policies in force, the most relevant policy deals with the claim in full if one policy is more relevant than the other. If the OP claimed off the new policy, and says he took that out because he'd exceeded the mileage limit on his old policy so didn't think it was still valid, then the new insurer would be obliged to deal with the claim in full.

Benbay001

Original Poster:

5,890 posts

186 months

Monday 27th July 2020
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
If you declared a limit for the year, and had an accident just short of the year end and had done slightly over, 200 miles, there's no way the insurer could refuse cover. TCF regs just wouldn't allow it. At most, they could have asked you to pay the further £140, but they probably wouldn't even have done that.

You've completely wasted your money taking out the new policy.
If thats the case, its only 2 weeks of a 52 week policy thats been wasted.

Wasnt aware of TCF regs

BertBert

21,258 posts

240 months

Monday 27th July 2020
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
If thats the case, its only 2 weeks of a 52 week policy thats been wasted.

Wasnt aware of TCF regs
Also as mentioned before, I'm curious about what they policy said happened when you reach the max miles. IME, they take different approaches.
Bert

hotchy

4,829 posts

155 months

Monday 27th July 2020
quotequote all
Its 200 miles... they ask for approx miles. I would renew at end of term.