BMW dealer stripped sump threads
BMW dealer stripped sump threads
Author
Discussion

Navkaran-nq1ka

Original Poster:

10 posts

133 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
Hey all, went in for a vehicle inspection and engine oil change at a main BMW dealer today. After 1hr 20mins they rang to say when trying to reattach the sump plug it wasnt torquing because the sump was threaded. They continued to say that i would have to pay for a repair (hexicoil i believe) or replace the entire sump (at considerable cost).

As the car was out of warranty they would not cover any of the costs. I was told this was a 'common problem' and told to 'google it'. After doing so i can only conclude that this is indeed a common problem but caused by inexperienced technicians incorrectly tightening the plug and stripping the threads. The dealer insisted my 7 year old car with 33k miles (that has always been main dealer serviced) was to fault and that this was 'wear and tear'. I find it hard to believe a thread which is aluminum and steel and only had a handful of engine oil replacements would fail that quickly and this thinking was once again reinforced from what ive read online and from speaking to friends who are also mechanics.

I believe its only reasonable to conclude that the damage was done due to negligence from their side and not due to the part being 'old'. I understand it could have been threaded from the previous service but 1) id expect they would have let me know a lot earlier if this was the case instead of carrying out the entire service and 2) they did the last engine oil service anyway!

I've rang BMW customer complaints and they're siding with the garage and refuse to front any costs. The branch manager wasn't in so im hoping to speak to him at some point but in the mean time what do you think my options are?

Cheers!

loskie

7,150 posts

151 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
has been cross threaded or over tightened by the tech. I actually thought they pumped the oil out rather than drain out the sump.

Why should you pay? It's a bit like them scraping the door on a wall then expecting YOU to foot the bill.

dhutch

17,959 posts

228 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
Who did the previous oil change? If it was them, game set and match to you imo.

However if it was any other garage, it becomes very hard to establish if it was cross threaded or over tightening this time or last time. If the other garage was a different main dealer, them your on a half way house, messy but I would be pushing for BMW to cover it.


Daniel

Navkaran-nq1ka

Original Poster:

10 posts

133 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
dhutch said:
Who did the previous oil change? If it was them, game set and match to you imo.

However if it was any other garage, it becomes very hard to establish if it was cross threaded or over tightening this time or last time. If the other garage was a different main dealer, them your on a half way house, messy but I would be pushing for BMW to cover it.


Daniel
It was them - just found the invoice for my last engine oil service.

SuperPav

1,360 posts

156 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
If it’s only ever been serviced by the main dealers as you say then I would continue pressure on them and BMW head office, escalate to press/court action as poor design if it wasn’t their accident etc etc.

I’d expect them to cover this type of situation, after a few attempts to wash their hands as if it ever did get to court it’s likely to go in your favour here (i work for an OEM although not bmw!).

If car wasn’t always serviced by bmw dealers then all the above may not apply and it’s tough luck.


Navkaran-nq1ka

Original Poster:

10 posts

133 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
It's been serviced by BMW main dealers only its entire lifetime and the last 3 services (inc this one) were done by this particular dealer.

stinkyspanner

979 posts

108 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
If it's a common problem why didn't they warn you beforehand that it could strip? Get them to repair it then small claims court..

A1VDY

3,575 posts

158 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
If you do get persistent denial from the dealer its only a £20 job to replace with a helicoil and new sump plug.
The workshop I use keep a whole range of helicoils and although only charge me trade rates don't be fobbed off with an estimate of circa £100+ to do the job..

delta0

2,553 posts

137 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
I guess it is an aluminium sump. So easy to cross thread. I remember cross threading a spark plug the first time, or more I realised when I had to remove it. A helicoil will be an easy fix though.

Fastpedeller

4,386 posts

177 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
Probably used an air wrench on it - If only people (in full knowledge that these parts are likely to strip!) would use a bit of finesse and just use a hand tool all would be good. IMHO a heli-coil is a bit of a bodge and I'd want the real deal as well!

Navg

Original Poster:

10 posts

133 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice all. I’ll press for them to replace the sump under the grounds discussed here. My concern is if they persistently reject and I have to go through the legal system this will obviously take time. Am I within my rights to expect them to retain the car during this process at no additional cost to myself? I would think me taking the car could be considered some form of acceptance of work done.

A1VDY

3,575 posts

158 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
Fastpedeller said:
Probably used an air wrench on it - If only people (in full knowledge that these parts are likely to strip!) would use a bit of finesse and just use a hand tool all would be good. IMHO a heli-coil is a bit of a bodge and I'd want the real deal as well!
How is a helicoil a bodge?
Its a perfectly fine way to repair a stripped thread.
Only other way is a new sump pan which would be ridiculously expensive. No one would go to that expense versus a simple and easy repair..

Navg

Original Poster:

10 posts

133 months

Thursday 30th July 2020
quotequote all
A1VDY said:
How is a helicoil a bodge?
Its a perfectly fine way to repair a stripped thread.
Only other way is a new sump pan which would be ridiculously expensive. No one would go to that expense versus a simple and easy repair..
The service manager was actually telling me I should replace the sump if ‘I was you’ when he was expecting me to front the cost. So I’d expect them to do this if they are found to fault.

InitialDave

15,191 posts

150 months

Friday 31st July 2020
quotequote all
Is there enough meat to take it out to a larger thread sump plug (BMW are usually M12 IIRC, so maybe M14 - Vauxhall perhaps?).

That strikes me as the neatest solution.

thebraketester

15,846 posts

169 months

Friday 31st July 2020
quotequote all
delta0 said:
I guess it is an aluminium sump. So easy to cross thread. I remember cross threading a spark plug the first time, or more I realised when I had to remove it. A helicoil will be an easy fix though.
It’s not easy at all. More likely that it’s been over tightened at some point.

xjay1337

15,966 posts

149 months

Friday 31st July 2020
quotequote all
Navkaran-nq1ka said:
dhutch said:
Who did the previous oil change? If it was them, game set and match to you imo.

However if it was any other garage, it becomes very hard to establish if it was cross threaded or over tightening this time or last time. If the other garage was a different main dealer, them your on a half way house, messy but I would be pushing for BMW to cover it.


Daniel
It was them - just found the invoice for my last engine oil service.
HAHAHA

It was them?

Ok, fk them, obviously it's their mistake.

Stick to your guns, show them the invoice and date showing it was last serviced by them, and explain since they were the only people to have touched it how they wish to proceed.

I would always drop the sump to repair. Helicoil is OK, Timesert would be better, new sump would be best. Any thread repair job I'd want to be done with the sump removed anyway just incase any metal debris goes into the sump..

I'm an idiot and I've changed the oil on my own cars probably 20 times over the years and never cross threaded a sump plug, you really have to be in a rush or not paying attention, wouldn't surprise me if an apprentice got the jump and just whizzed it up with a gun to 15 ugga duggas when 1 would have been fine, or didn't hand thread it a bit before getting on the socket/ratchet spanner.

st happens but it's a case of he-said-she-said, but the fact they last serviced it is pretty damning. Of course, that's not to say you hadn't since had it done but I'd argue that's for them to prove, not you.

Good luck.


105.4

4,214 posts

102 months

Friday 31st July 2020
quotequote all
Fastpedeller said:
Probably used an air wrench on it IMHO a heli-coil is a bit of a bodge and I'd want the real deal as well!
yikes

Nothing further to add besides IMO this is entirely down to the dealer. I’d escalate it to the Servie Manager, then to the Dealer Principle, if still no joy then Small Claims, including the cost of a like-for-like rental whilst it’s all sorted out.

jamiem555

816 posts

242 months

Friday 31st July 2020
quotequote all
I would definitely say that they were at fault. Ask to see the torque wrench they used each time. I bet they didn't.

On a similar topic to stripped threads but not car related, we had a leaky valve on our copper water tank. Plumber was called, he changed the valve but stripped the thread on the tank. No quibbles, just an apology and a brand new tank was installed after a few days without hot water. About £1000 worth after I googled it.

105.4

4,214 posts

102 months

Friday 31st July 2020
quotequote all
My money is on an apprentice swinging a bar on the sump plug instead of finger tight then nipping up to 12lb/ft(?) with a 3/8s torque wrench.

Magnum 475

4,197 posts

163 months

Friday 31st July 2020
quotequote all
I went through this 20 years ago with my Alfa. Exactly the same problem, and a known issue at the time. I took the matter right up to Alfa UK after getting nowhere with dealer who had carried out every service on the car from new. Still got nowhere, and ended up having to pay for the new sump myself (I wasn’t willing to have it helicoiled on the car due to risk of metal particles getting into the oil).