Pension contributions on PILON
Pension contributions on PILON
Author
Discussion

oyster

Original Poster:

13,446 posts

271 months

Thursday 1st October 2020
quotequote all
I've recently been made redundant and been paid in lieu of notice. There is no provision in my employment contract for PILON.

My employer (ex-employer now) has not made any employer pension contributions on the PILON amount (nor indeed have they deducted any employee contributions either).

Is this normal?


Sy1441

1,283 posts

183 months

Thursday 1st October 2020
quotequote all
Yes, it's non-pensionable.

parabolica

6,955 posts

207 months

Thursday 1st October 2020
quotequote all
Did your package include provisions for Loss of Benefits? It's usually a standard part of the package and increases your package to cover the cost of company benefits, such as employer pension, car allowance, PILON vacation accrual etc.

oyster

Original Poster:

13,446 posts

271 months

Friday 2nd October 2020
quotequote all
Sy1441 said:
Yes, it's non-pensionable.
Perhaps I'm misreading it, but the below text taken from the ACAS website seems at odds with your view.
https://www.acas.org.uk/dismissals/notice-periods-...

ACAS website said:
It might say in the person's contract what the payment should be, for example if they should get any work benefits they'd normally get, such as pension contributions.

An employer can still offer payment in lieu of notice if it's not in the contract. It should be agreed between the employer and employee in writing.

When it's not in the contract, it's a good idea for the employer to offer full pay including any usual work benefits. If the employer does not do this it could be seen as a breach of contract.
Given the value of the contributions here is sub £1k I'm loathe to spend £300+ on engaging an employment lawyer, hence why I've asked the good folk of PH. biggrin

WhiskyDisco

1,201 posts

97 months

Friday 2nd October 2020
quotequote all
It's an interesting question. On the one hand I would say that you should be paid your full package, including pension contributions - and that you should have the option of making contributions to a pension to avoid tax. However, I don't think an employer is obliged to pay pension contributions on PILON.

On the other hand, I would consider it a bonus to receive PILON, rather than having to work out notice period in the garden.

I would like to see some clarity in this, especially with regard to salary sacrifice. I'm sacrificing quite a bit of my salary into a pension. I suspect that if I were offered PILON, then this sacrificed salary would not be paid to me - neither would it go into my pension. I think that my redundancy would also be calculating on my "net income before tax" too. In this case I would be better off not taking PILON and receiving the full package.

oyster

Original Poster:

13,446 posts

271 months

Friday 2nd October 2020
quotequote all
WhiskyDisco said:
It's an interesting question. On the one hand I would say that you should be paid your full package, including pension contributions - and that you should have the option of making contributions to a pension to avoid tax. However, I don't think an employer is obliged to pay pension contributions on PILON.

On the other hand, I would consider it a bonus to receive PILON, rather than having to work out notice period in the garden.

I would like to see some clarity in this, especially with regard to salary sacrifice. I'm sacrificing quite a bit of my salary into a pension. I suspect that if I were offered PILON, then this sacrificed salary would not be paid to me - neither would it go into my pension. I think that my redundancy would also be calculating on my "net income before tax" too. In this case I would be better off not taking PILON and receiving the full package.
There are a couple of benefits of PILON to the employee worth considering though.
1. You could 'double-dip' by getting a new job within the 'notice' period and so gain financially.
2. You could benefit from saved employee NICs as all the payment is made within a single pay run and more salary will be captured within the 2% NIC band.

Jasandjules

71,909 posts

252 months

Friday 2nd October 2020
quotequote all
Sy1441 said:
Yes, it's non-pensionable.
What makes you say that?

OP if there is no Pilon clause I presume there is also no clause which says your benefits will not be paid during this period (is there a Garden Leave clause?)

oyster

Original Poster:

13,446 posts

271 months

Friday 2nd October 2020
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Sy1441 said:
Yes, it's non-pensionable.
What makes you say that?

OP if there is no Pilon clause I presume there is also no clause which says your benefits will not be paid during this period (is there a Garden Leave clause?)
Correct, there is no clause relating to PILON. There is a garden leave clause stating all benefits will continue to be paid.

Jasandjules

71,909 posts

252 months

Friday 2nd October 2020
quotequote all
oyster said:
Correct, there is no clause relating to PILON. There is a garden leave clause stating all benefits will continue to be paid.
Then you need to refer HR to this clause and invite them to ensure your pension payments are made up to EDT.

Countdown

47,139 posts

219 months

Friday 2nd October 2020
quotequote all
oyster said:
There are a couple of benefits of PILON to the employee worth considering though.
1. You could 'double-dip' by getting a new job within the 'notice' period and so gain financially.
2. You could benefit from saved employee NICs as all the payment is made within a single pay run and more salary will be captured within the 2% NIC band.
Isn't the fall in the EEs NI rate more than offset by the increase in Income tax rate from 20% to 40%?

WhiskyDisco

1,201 posts

97 months

Friday 2nd October 2020
quotequote all
oyster said:
Correct, there is no clause relating to PILON. There is a garden leave clause stating all benefits will continue to be paid.
If the pension/benefits were large enough I would be pressing for gardening leave rather than PILON.

oyster

Original Poster:

13,446 posts

271 months

Saturday 3rd October 2020
quotequote all
Countdown said:
oyster said:
There are a couple of benefits of PILON to the employee worth considering though.
1. You could 'double-dip' by getting a new job within the 'notice' period and so gain financially.
2. You could benefit from saved employee NICs as all the payment is made within a single pay run and more salary will be captured within the 2% NIC band.
Isn't the fall in the EEs NI rate more than offset by the increase in Income tax rate from 20% to 40%?
Not necessarily. Income tax can be reclaimed if it's overpaid. AIUI, NICs are not repayable if they are underpaid on a monthly basis.
Income tax is based on income over the whole tax year, national insurance is based on the pay period.

Countdown

47,139 posts

219 months

Saturday 3rd October 2020
quotequote all
oyster said:
Not necessarily. Income tax can be reclaimed if it's overpaid. AIUI, NICs are not repayable if they are underpaid on a monthly basis.
Income tax is based on income over the whole tax year, national insurance is based on the pay period.
Fair point.