Powerline adaptor advice...please.
Powerline adaptor advice...please.
Author
Discussion

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,600 posts

270 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
Situation > 3 story house with VM router in the front room downstairs. 2 kids on floors 1 and 2 increasingly wanting internet connectivity. Daughter in 2nd floor attic has a laptop which seems "ok" connection wirelessly. Son on 1st floor has an inherited desktop I'd like to connect.

So....can anyone recommend a set up/product where the main unit is in the front room next to the router and I get two add ons with both wired and wireless connections please?

Are the TP units wireless and wired or just wired?

Any help would be appreciated.

joshleb

1,550 posts

174 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
So you want a wired connection for your sons desktop PC?

Wireless adapter not satisfy? Would be cheaper than powerlines

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,600 posts

270 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
joshleb said:
So you want a wired connection for your sons desktop PC?

Wireless adapter not satisfy? Would be cheaper than powerlines
Ideally wired. There's obviously power sockets next to each appliance so easy to get network cables to.

DocJock

8,722 posts

270 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
Devolo Magic for wired and wireless.

gus607

997 posts

166 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
I bought expensive TP Link powerline adaptors & were complete rubbish. The only way to get good internet is with ethernet.

gregs656

12,390 posts

211 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
A mesh system might be better?

I’ve used power line adapters for the last decade in multiple settings and been happy with them, but I think mesh is the way to go if you’re not invested already.

sgrimshaw

7,587 posts

280 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
Never had an issue with TP Link stuff.

OP - this gives you both wired and wireless. I've been using these since March 2018 and they have been faultless. They're running across two consumer units as well, something which a lot of people suggest is not even possible. Have recommended them to many people and no-one has been disappointed.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B07349P1TX/ref...

wiggy001

7,384 posts

301 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
sgrimshaw said:
Never had an issue with TP Link stuff.

OP - this gives you both wired and wireless. I've been using these since March 2018 and they have been faultless. They're running across two consumer units as well, something which a lot of people suggest is not even possible. Have recommended them to many people and no-one has been disappointed.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B07349P1TX/ref...
I was using an older version of these with no issue until recently. I only stopped when I got a Sky Q Mini box on the first floor which doubles as a repeater giving wifi in our loft.

mmm-five

12,392 posts

314 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
DocJock said:
Devolo Magic for wired and wireless.
Ditto.

We have some odd interference here (not an old TV), and wifi is intermittent (sometimes 1mbps, sometimes 500mbps).

With the Magic 2 Next ones we've recently fitted (replaced ethernet only 500AV ones), they put out a strong enough signal that we don't have to use the ethernet ports at all.

blackscooby

423 posts

310 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
I use some old Devolo ones from the hub to a Raspberry Pi in the garage. Not massively fast but as its just a backup server in the garage it doesn't need to be particularly quick. Haven't powered them off in a long long time. (Possibly years)

Marlin45

1,334 posts

194 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
All of the powerline adaptors I have encountered are a) limiting on bandwidth, b) cause wide spectrum interference. TBH avoid at all costs.

If you can then fit wired, or if not then WiFi boosted connections via an access point or WiFi plug-in boosters. For a teenage son and his probable desire for UHD video 'needs' - go for wired!

TameRacingDriver

20,599 posts

302 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
Marlin45 said:
All of the powerline adaptors I have encountered are a) limiting on bandwidth, b) cause wide spectrum interference. TBH avoid at all costs.

If you can then fit wired, or if not then WiFi boosted connections via an access point or WiFi plug-in boosters. For a teenage son and his probable desire for UHD video 'needs' - go for wired!
This was my experience as well. The network ran at half the speed and dropped out regularly. Just got a decent WiFi adapter instead (was a desktop machine with no WiFi), problem solved.

deckster

9,631 posts

285 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Marlin45 said:
All of the powerline adaptors I have encountered are a) limiting on bandwidth, b) cause wide spectrum interference. TBH avoid at all costs.

If you can then fit wired, or if not then WiFi boosted connections via an access point or WiFi plug-in boosters. For a teenage son and his probable desire for UHD video 'needs' - go for wired!
This was my experience as well. The network ran at half the speed and dropped out regularly. Just got a decent WiFi adapter instead (was a desktop machine with no WiFi), problem solved.
Thirded. Don't waste your money on powerline stuff, invest in a decent Wifi infrastructure instead.

xeny

5,516 posts

108 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
You've presumably looked if there is any boxed in central heating pipework between floors to let you run actual network cable?

Condi

20,480 posts

201 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
sgrimshaw said:
Never had an issue with TP Link stuff.
Me neither, I get the same speeds at both ends of the adaptors, albeit only on a 36Mbs connection.

The only thing which does make it more complicated is if the 2 "ends" are on different circuits. If so, its far more likely you will have issues and problems as the signal has to go via the circuit board, but if its one circuit and your wiring is in good condition then I've never had any problems like other people say.

If you have an old router then you can plug that in the to the powerline adapter and with some settings changes have the same Wifi username and password across the house, and also get the advantage of some ethernet ports all for free.

OnaRoll

3,703 posts

221 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
cobra kid said:
Situation > 3 story house with VM router in the front room downstairs. 2 kids on floors 1 and 2 increasingly wanting internet connectivity. Daughter in 2nd floor attic has a laptop which seems "ok" connection wirelessly. Son on 1st floor has an inherited desktop I'd like to connect.

So....can anyone recommend a set up/product where the main unit is in the front room next to the router and I get two add ons with both wired and wireless connections please?

Are the TP units wireless and wired or just wired?

Any help would be appreciated.
Any TV COAX going to these rooms?

Devolo has been very reliable for me as well.

Emeye

9,781 posts

253 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
I work with WiFi - I have worked with expensive Meshed wifi such as Meraki, Cisco and Mojo/Arista, but for home I took a chance with white BT Whole Home meshed Wifi.

For the money I have been seriously impressed - once setup it has just worked. I got the large white discs, one plugged into the router then you use the mobile App and it helps you find the location for the other ones. One on each floor should do the job you can always buy individual ones and add them on if required.

Obviously you need a half decent internet connection too.There are 6 of us and the internet gets battered with working from home, 4K Netflix and youtube etc - I hardly ever have to reboot it and it is very rare we see buffering. When you work in IT the last thing you want is to spend your evenings sorting out the Wifi at home.

They are regularly on offer - there is a cheaper mini version but I have never tried it. there is a black version that works with BT routers.

Avoid the Google meshed system, my bro had a nightmare with it. Google released a firmware update that stopped it working and refused to take responsibility, luckily Amazon refunded.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/BT-seamless-connection-ev...

Buy from amazon and you may get decent support if it doesn't work for you.

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,600 posts

270 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
Marlin45 said:
All of the powerline adaptors I have encountered are a) limiting on bandwidth, b) cause wide spectrum interference. TBH avoid at all costs.

If you can then fit wired, or if not then WiFi boosted connections via an access point or WiFi plug-in boosters. For a teenage son and his probable desire for UHD video 'needs' - go for wired!
He's 10!

deckster

9,631 posts

285 months

Monday 5th October 2020
quotequote all
cobra kid said:
Marlin45 said:
All of the powerline adaptors I have encountered are a) limiting on bandwidth, b) cause wide spectrum interference. TBH avoid at all costs.

If you can then fit wired, or if not then WiFi boosted connections via an access point or WiFi plug-in boosters. For a teenage son and his probable desire for UHD video 'needs' - go for wired!
He's 10!
Not for long wink

xeny

5,516 posts

108 months

Tuesday 6th October 2020
quotequote all
ash73 said:
Why on earth have they started putting the ports on the top? rolleyes
Better ergonomics for people plugging things into them and CBA to pick them up?

ports on the top of what?