ferries - EU question
Author
Discussion

Armchair Expert

Original Poster:

3,097 posts

98 months

Friday 4th December 2020
quotequote all
Not really sure where to post this but was wondering...

If after UK has properly left the EU and a country maybe france was being difficult can ferries be diverted to run to Holland for example or Spain?

TriumphStag3.0V8

5,138 posts

105 months

Friday 4th December 2020
quotequote all
France? Being difficult? Surely not!

We already have Ferries travelling to Spain, Belgium and Holland, so im sure it could be done if needed.

greygoose

9,395 posts

219 months

Friday 4th December 2020
quotequote all
It would be problematic for the Dover-Calais ferries as the immigration controls for the UK are in Calais, unless they have some emergency controls they can put in at Dover at short notice, but I think they demolished them all some years ago.

Earthdweller

17,928 posts

150 months

Friday 4th December 2020
quotequote all
greygoose said:
It would be problematic for the Dover-Calais ferries as the immigration controls for the UK are in Calais, unless they have some emergency controls they can put in at Dover at short notice, but I think they demolished them all some years ago.
That’s due to a bilateral agreement between France and the U.K. iirc

Nothing to do with the EU so shouldn’t change

Simpo Two

91,424 posts

289 months

Friday 4th December 2020
quotequote all
Earthdweller said:
That’s due to a bilateral agreement between France and the U.K. iirc

Nothing to do with the EU so shouldn’t change
In theory, but that's not allowing for the 'Gallic shrug' aka Macron, and French workers will strike at the drop of a hat.

4F6

156 posts

219 months

Saturday 5th December 2020
quotequote all
In theory, P&O could run two of their older / smaller vessels to Ostend (they did berthing trials there a couple of years or so back) or Zeebrugge as they were designed to operate to there originally. I think there are still immigration controls in Zeebrugge although Ostend hasn't seen any ferries for a few years now so that wouldn't be viable without significant issues.

In reality, probably not though.

But Dover - Spain is somewhat unlikely.

Edited by 4F6 on Saturday 5th December 12:00

Armchair Expert

Original Poster:

3,097 posts

98 months

Sunday 6th December 2020
quotequote all
4F6 said:
In reality, probably not though.

But Dover - Spain is somewhat unlikely.

Edited by 4F6 on Saturday 5th December 12:00
why?

I believe ferries leave from Portmouth for example to Spain as well as France, could the ferries on the French route not be used to go to Spain instead?

4F6

156 posts

219 months

Sunday 6th December 2020
quotequote all
Largely that the current P&O / DFDS Dover fleet was purpose built for the Dover - Calais route which makes them largely unsuitable.

There's no cabin capacity of any significance on the Dover fleet and as Dover is mainly accompanied freight and car/passengers (rather than unaccompanied trailers) and for a 30 hour sailing from Dover - Bilbao or similar you'd be wanting a good amount of cabins.

They were also designed to fit the berth / linkspans at Dover and for double deck loading without internal ramps whereas (I think) the Spanish ports use single deck loading meaning that freight could only load onto the main deck.

All that could be modified - they could have internal ramps fitted and additional cabins but it seems very unlikely, not to mention expensive.

Brittany Ferries could operate some of their Portsmouth / France fleet to Spain instead but given the nature of their ownership structure, to move away from serving Normandy / Breton ports would be unlikely as anything much more than a one off.

Plus, given that this is largely driven by freight operators, how many would actually want to have to sail via Spain with the extra expense in fuel / drivers hours / ferry cost that would entail.

Edited by 4F6 on Sunday 6th December 08:24

Armchair Expert

Original Poster:

3,097 posts

98 months

Monday 7th December 2020
quotequote all
4F6 said:
Plus, given that this is largely driven by freight operators, how many would actually want to have to sail via Spain with the extra expense in fuel / drivers hours / ferry cost that would entail.

Edited by 4F6 on Sunday 6th December 08:24
Much of the French ferry traffic is transit freight traffic n the way to Spain, Portugal, Italy, Germany and so on.

If there are problems at some ports as was wondering how easily it would be to switch to other gateways to and from Europe.