Top three performances at Live 8

[srebbe64]

For me, I'll go for:

1. Pink Floyd
2. The Who
3. Robbie Williams

(PS, I thought the UK gig was far better than the US one).

[interloper]

1. The Who
2. Pink Floyd
3. Roxy Music (Berlin)
4. Robbie

[RichUK]

1. Pink Floyd
2. The Who
3. Annie Lennox

[dazren]

1 - The Who
2 - Robbie Williams
3 - Velvet Revolver

[RichUK]

I did enjoy Velvet Revolver, took me right back to Guns 'n Roses days.

[Scooby_snax]

1 Pink Floyd
2 Velvet Revolver
3 Razorlight

[GCerbera]

The Who
Paul McCartney
Pink Floyd

[v8 westy]

the who
annie lennox
pink floyd
robbie williams

[srebbe64]

interloper said:

1. The Who 2. Pink Floyd 3. Roxy Music (Berlin) 4. Robbie

Sorry that's four. And I think we'll all agree that Roxy Music had something of a 'singing in tune problem'.

[interloper]

I'm sorry, I can't count!

[R TOY]

1 Pink Floyd
2 Dido.. 7 seconds brilliant!
3 stereophonics/keane/coldplay all superb.
What a fantastic concert, London loads better than Philli.

[GCerbera]

srebbe64 said:

interloper said: 1. The Who 2. Pink Floyd 3. Roxy Music (Berlin) 4. Robbie Sorry that's four. And I think we'll all agree that Roxy Music had something of a 'singing in tune problem'.

As did Roger Waters, but hey, Dave Gilmour more than made up with his vocal and guitar performance.

[srebbe64]

GCerbera said:

srebbe64 said: interloper said: 1. The Who 2. Pink Floyd 3. Roxy Music (Berlin) 4. Robbie Sorry that's four. And I think we'll all agree that Roxy Music had something of a 'singing in tune problem'. As did Roger Waters, but hey, Dave Gilmour more than made up with his vocal and guitar performance.

Fair enough. That eliminates the 'singing' issue, but try and get out of the 'numerical' issue!

[GCerbera]

srebbe64 said:

GCerbera said: srebbe64 said: interloper said: 1. The Who 2. Pink Floyd 3. Roxy Music (Berlin) 4. Robbie Sorry that's four. And I think we'll all agree that Roxy Music had something of a 'singing in tune problem'. As did Roger Waters, but hey, Dave Gilmour more than made up with his vocal and guitar performance. Fair enough. That eliminates the 'singing' issue, but try and get out of the 'numerical' issue!

Hmmm, how about...

Dave Gilmour played on White City by Pete Townsend so the Who & the Floyd are really one band?

[foster3jd]

1. Velvet Revolver
2. The Who
3. Pink Floyd

special commendation to:
Stereophonics (first band to really give it some)
Dido & Youssou N'dour ("7 seconds"... it was emotional)
Sir Bob ("Don't Like Mondays"... got the crowd involved)
Robbie Williams (what a showman?!!... the crowd was like putty in his hands)

ps. The Cure in Paris looked good too!!

[Kinky]

1. Pink Floyd
2. Annie Lennox
3 Robbie Williams

[LuS1fer]

Well it wasn't Pete Docherty who has been charged with Murder of Bolan's Children Of The Revolution. My guess is that Elton will have been sorely p*ssed at that drugged up rendition. Completely talentless.

[up-the-dubs]

U2
Ummmm.... U2 with Macca
And..... Floyd.

[FourWheelDrift]

1) The Who
2) Robbie Wiliams
3) Keane


Plus a huge missed opportunity for someone to have done Queen's Radio Ga Ga.

[kippax]

1. Robbie (fantastic showman)
2. Keane (unfazed & excellent)
3. Madonna (better than i have ever heard her sound live before)


H