Collapse of Football Index
Author
Discussion

PeteinSQ

Original Poster:

2,346 posts

234 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
How was Football Index anything other than a Ponzi scheme?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-56401707

"Some critics argue Football Index was akin to a Ponzi scheme. "To pay out dividends, it required more customers to deposit money. When that dried up, the problems started", said Matt Zarb-Cousin, of the Campaign for Fairer Gambling and a former gambling addict.

"Football Index is an unsustainable business model. They created a stock market out of assets they themselves created. The football players on the market had no underlying value," he said."

PH_77

1,393 posts

117 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
A fool and their money.....

greygoose

9,404 posts

219 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
The massive amount of betting sponsorship in sport now does point to a potential gambling problem building up in the population, some of the amounts people have lost in that story are pretty high, the internet makes it very easy for people to gamble away their cash whilst just seeing it as a game.

PeteinSQ

Original Poster:

2,346 posts

234 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
PH_77 said:
A fool and their money.....
Yes I did think something similar. But as some of the comments in that BBC link say - how on earth did they ever get a license with this business model?

PeteinSQ

Original Poster:

2,346 posts

234 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
greygoose said:
The massive amount of betting sponsorship in sport now does point to a potential gambling problem building up in the population, some of the amounts people have lost in that story are pretty high, the internet makes it very easy for people to gamble away their cash whilst just seeing it as a game.
I see this with my colleagues, a lot of them are having several bets every single day. I don't think they necessarily have a problem as I'm sure they only gamble small amounts and sometimes they win and mostly they lose and it balances itself out when you factor in the entertainment they're getting. But with gambling becoming more and more normalised it must increase the numbers of people that become problem gamblers.

untakenname

5,273 posts

216 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
Have no experience of this particular firm but imo gambling companies should be banned from sports advertising like cigarette companies, they are no better than drug pushers judging by the sort of people you see loitering outside the betting shops awaiting their next fix.

anonymous-user

78 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
PeteinSQ said:
"Football Index is an unsustainable business model. They created a stock market out of assets they themselves created. The football players on the market had no underlying value," he said."
Hmmmm, that sounds a little bit like Crypto to me.

Mastodon2

14,181 posts

189 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
When you read the article, it is clear from the way the marks talk that they felt like they were investors and not fools being drained of their money. I suppose that was probably their angle all along, to get people feeling like their "portfolio" had some value and was worth growing and holding on to, when in truth it was just a financial liability.

Andy 308GTB

3,020 posts

245 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
If this was simply an index, provided the business took a small commission on each transaction & the punters were correctly margined, the business cannot lose.

The funding of the 'dividend' seems to be the problem. Other than taking it out of their profits, how else can they pay one (other than creating a Ponzi scheme).

Ziplobb

1,539 posts

308 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
just been reading the sobstories in the BBC article - are people really this daft with money they have had to earn ?

Andy 308GTB

3,020 posts

245 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
Ziplobb said:
just been reading the sobstories in the BBC article - are people really this daft with money they have had to earn ?
It's an addiction. Cynically marketed.

PeteinSQ

Original Poster:

2,346 posts

234 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
Joey Deacon said:
Hmmmm, that sounds a little bit like Crypto to me.
It does a bit, that's another area I don't understand.

Matt p

1,113 posts

232 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
It was advertised extremely heavily on TalkSport. Every ad break it was on.

Personally I really despise advertising for gambling/bookmakers. A YouTube channel that both my son and I love (Carl and Alex fishing) unfortunately have bookmaker ads prior to the video starting. It’s now at the point where I’ll not let him watch the channel. He’s only 7.

JeffreyD

6,155 posts

64 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
Matt p said:
It was advertised extremely heavily on TalkSport. Every ad break it was on.

Personally I really despise advertising for gambling/bookmakers. A YouTube channel that both my son and I love (Carl and Alex fishing) unfortunately have bookmaker ads prior to the video starting. It’s now at the point where I’ll not let him watch the channel. He’s only 7.
Here's something I never thought I'd say - I now watch the football on the American channels for precisely this reason, as they don't advertise gambling. It seems like every second advert is for gambling on UK sports TV. It really is everywhere if you have any interest in sport on watch or listen.

TwigtheWonderkid

48,051 posts

174 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
PH_77 said:
A fool and their money.....
......rarely get together in the first place.

Dr Doofenshmirtz

16,688 posts

224 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
Two adverts in this thread for gambling!

Sadly, a lot of those sob stories are young 20 something lads, no doubt trying to be like their favourite Youtuber, but not realising the massive debt they're usually in.

Edited by Dr Doofenshmirtz on Tuesday 16th March 12:52

7n8n

839 posts

214 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
Matt p said:
It was advertised extremely heavily on TalkSport. Every ad break it was on.

Personally I really despise advertising for gambling/bookmakers. A YouTube channel that both my son and I love (Carl and Alex fishing) unfortunately have bookmaker ads prior to the video starting. It’s now at the point where I’ll not let him watch the channel. He’s only 7.
How are you watching? There are various means to remove ads (some free) depending on how you're accessing YouTube.

Ian Geary

5,386 posts

216 months

Tuesday 16th March 2021
quotequote all
greygoose said:
The massive amount of betting sponsorship in sport now does point to a potential gambling problem building up in the population, some of the amounts people have lost in that story are pretty high, the internet makes it very easy for people to gamble away their cash whilst just seeing it as a game.
The lobbyists working on behalf of the gambling industry are clearly earning their money.

Didn't it take an absolute ststorm to get high payout fruit machines removed from betting shops?

The sad truth though is that vice is profitable, both for companies and in terms of taxation.