This or a Carrera GT...
This or a Carrera GT...
Author
Discussion

browngt3

Original Poster:

1,431 posts

232 months

Thursday 13th May 2021
quotequote all
... or a 918?

The ultimate car let alone the ultimate Porsche!

https://youtu.be/QAxxJ2i28PQ

TDT

6,062 posts

140 months

Friday 14th May 2021
quotequote all
I appreciate the details, of the history of the GT1 and the advancements in the 918 … but anytime the question is something or Carrera GT… there is only ever one winner for me...

Carrera GT.

RDMcG

20,314 posts

228 months

Friday 14th May 2021
quotequote all
The CGT remains the greatest car I have ever driven. Doubtless others have had different experiences but if it were my choice...CGT.

IMI A

9,913 posts

222 months

Friday 14th May 2021
quotequote all
haha you know you're a fantasist when you think about these cars (at least if you're me). CGT but if for a collection and maybe you have your own race track GT1. One day Rodney! 918 your dd smile

Cheib

24,887 posts

196 months

Friday 14th May 2021
quotequote all
3.0 RS road car....way cooler, much easier to use and can be driven and enjoyed to the max on public roads.

https://www.tomhartleyjnr.com/car/previously-sold/...

Twinfan

10,125 posts

125 months

Friday 14th May 2021
quotequote all
918 please...

WCZ

11,245 posts

215 months

Friday 14th May 2021
quotequote all
gt1 every time, love the looks and rarity over the CGT

matrignano

4,671 posts

231 months

Friday 14th May 2021
quotequote all
Love the GT1!
This era of cars is fantastic, I wonder if anyone has the holy trinity of late 90s GT1s: Mercedes CLK GTR, Porsche GT1, McLaren F1
And then the super rare/oddbals like the Lotus Elise GT1, Nissan R390, Toyota GT One, Panoz, Lister, Venturi etc

Twinfan

10,125 posts

125 months

Monday 17th May 2021
quotequote all
matrignano said:
Love the GT1!
This era of cars is fantastic, I wonder if anyone has the holy trinity of late 90s GT1s: Mercedes CLK GTR, Porsche GT1, McLaren F1
And then the super rare/oddbals like the Lotus Elise GT1, Nissan R390, Toyota GT One, Panoz, Lister, Venturi etc
Did you know this was coming?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AIqANh0vraU

Cheib

24,887 posts

196 months

Monday 17th May 2021
quotequote all
Twinfan said:
Did you know this was coming?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AIqANh0vraU
They’ve been trailing that on social media

browngt3

Original Poster:

1,431 posts

232 months

Monday 17th May 2021
quotequote all
Looks like a nice series of videos. HC is a lucky man to get to drive all three.

Perhaps a forgotten car from the era is the Panoz. Always remember that ear splitting V8 tearing around Tertre Rouge.

isaldiri

23,164 posts

189 months

Monday 17th May 2021
quotequote all
Might sound heretical here but am still not at all convinced that the gt1 or clk gtr would be any good to drive on the road at all. As objects of significance, they are obviously historic but for the actual use ie driving, the F1 (for all that car I'm told has some unusual handling quirks) would be incomparably superior. Possibly different on track for those 2 cars but again on road tyres at road legal ride height, you're pretty much missing most of what made the 96/97 race cars special.

MDL111

8,368 posts

198 months

Tuesday 18th May 2021
quotequote all
isaldiri said:
Might sound heretical here but am still not at all convinced that the gt1 or clk gtr would be any good to drive on the road at all. As objects of significance, they are obviously historic but for the actual use ie driving, the F1 (for all that car I'm told has some unusual handling quirks) would be incomparably superior. Possibly different on track for those 2 cars but again on road tyres at road legal ride height, you're pretty much missing most of what made the 96/97 race cars special.
you might well be right about that - they do not really look like road cars - but god would I love to have a CLK GTR in my garage to take to a few track days a year ....

PushedDover

6,901 posts

74 months

Tuesday 18th May 2021
quotequote all
After we learn how a dipstick works, he finally drives it in the video - does not look very comfortable or happy doing so !
I suspect a nightmare on the road for the width, ride, and lack of usability across the rev range ?

browngt3

Original Poster:

1,431 posts

232 months

Wednesday 19th May 2021
quotequote all
Part 2 has just gone live

https://youtu.be/JIBhLba0RRI

Proper supercar!

LM240

5,336 posts

239 months

Thursday 20th May 2021
quotequote all
Tricky question.

As nice as the 918 is, it would be the last pic of the three for me.

I think the GT1 would trump the CGT from a purely ‘special event’ type car every time you approached it. The direct link to an actual Le Mans race car is a strong appeal. Just imagine a road trip to Le Mans each year in that!

But the CGT is very special also. Probably more useable and practical for road driving. Links with Le Mans also, but not the same as the GT1.

I think I’d have to hope the euro millions win was big enough to buy both!

WCZ

11,245 posts

215 months

Thursday 20th May 2021
quotequote all
LM240 said:
Tricky question.

As nice as the 918 is, it would be the last pic of the three for me.

I think the GT1 would trump the CGT from a purely ‘special event’ type car every time you approached it. The direct link to an actual Le Mans race car is a strong appeal. Just imagine a road trip to Le Mans each year in that!

But the CGT is very special also. Probably more useable and practical for road driving. Links with Le Mans also, but not the same as the GT1.

I think I’d have to hope the euro millions win was big enough to buy both!
I think in reality the 918 would probably be the best if you were doing lots of miles, esp driving around europe etc

mat205125

17,790 posts

234 months

Thursday 20th May 2021
quotequote all
GT1 is just infinitely more special than either the GT or 918 can ever be.

GT has more chance to be remembered as a high water mark for analogue super cars, than the 918 has for being special at what it does amazingly.


mat205125

17,790 posts

234 months

Thursday 20th May 2021
quotequote all
isaldiri said:
Might sound heretical here but am still not at all convinced that the gt1 or clk gtr would be any good to drive on the road at all. As objects of significance, they are obviously historic but for the actual use ie driving, the F1 (for all that car I'm told has some unusual handling quirks) would be incomparably superior. Possibly different on track for those 2 cars but again on road tyres at road legal ride height, you're pretty much missing most of what made the 96/97 race cars special.
Let's be honest, a 992 gt3 is a far better, accessible and ultimately a faster real world car.

A gt1 owner probably has a gt3 for fun and thrills. Gt1 is ultimate speedy cars and coffee car

ChrisW.

7,926 posts

276 months

Thursday 20th May 2021
quotequote all
Wow ... just watched the first two videos and so great to see these cars being described as-if to a prospective owner, and then driven.

Tough question for the dream machine .. I might try to persuade myself that my 996.1 GT3 CS is a continuation of the GT1 DNA (996 version) at relative pocket money cost .. but I would really like one of the 2 RHD 964RS 3.8's .... (in the world).

Small, exclusive, a piece of engineering innovation and jewellery ... so understated and so useable.

Which is why of the three I would go for the McLaren F1. The nearest I've got is the engine in my BMW 850 CSi ...