Discussion
Silver membership - up from £186 to £240.
Partly this seems to be because it's paying for loads of special offers I don't want, eg 20% off travel insurance, an AA ISA, £5 off a car wash, 10% off at Halfords, 30% off at Vision Express, European breakdown cover. I just want a decent value efficient UK breakdown service.
Are all breakdown companies the same? Or is £240 the going rate for Roadside Assistance + National Recovery + Home Start + Onward Travel?
Partly this seems to be because it's paying for loads of special offers I don't want, eg 20% off travel insurance, an AA ISA, £5 off a car wash, 10% off at Halfords, 30% off at Vision Express, European breakdown cover. I just want a decent value efficient UK breakdown service.
Are all breakdown companies the same? Or is £240 the going rate for Roadside Assistance + National Recovery + Home Start + Onward Travel?
There was a similar thread on here a month or two ago. Mine went up to £240 as well and I ended up cancelling it after 25+ years with them. They wouldn't even entertain trying to keep my business, the best they could offer was a 5% discount! My car insurance was up for renewal and adding Green Flag cover onto that only cost me an extra £70 so it was a no brainer.
They tried to convince me to stay, saying they guarantee that it is always an AA engineer that attends call-outs, which is complete BS as the last 2 times I had used them they contracted the work to a local garage and they attended. Nothing wrong with the service provided, just no need to lie about it to try and retain people.
They tried to convince me to stay, saying they guarantee that it is always an AA engineer that attends call-outs, which is complete BS as the last 2 times I had used them they contracted the work to a local garage and they attended. Nothing wrong with the service provided, just no need to lie about it to try and retain people.
The Spruce Goose said:
My all inclusive breakdown cover cost 25 quid for whole year, so no, all breakdown covers aren't the same, some people pay X10 more for the brand.
That seems too good to be true - mind my asking who it is? Have you needed to call them out?Slightly in the AA's defence, when I've needed to call them out they've been very good - so I'm not looking to save money if the service isn't there.
Edited by Simpo Two on Tuesday 10th August 10:48
Simpo Two said:
That seems too good to be true - mind my asking who it is? Have you needed to call them out?
Slightly in the AA's defence, when I've needed to call them out they've been very good - so I'm not looking to save money if the service isn't there.
I bought it off Groupon, the reviews are very good. Not had to use them yet, but was a RAC member, paid 100+ plus a year and they took 6 hours to get to me when I broke down. So has to be better. Slightly in the AA's defence, when I've needed to call them out they've been very good - so I'm not looking to save money if the service isn't there.
Edited by Simpo Two on Tuesday 10th August 10:48
JmatthewB said:
AutoAid
That. No need to pay more.In the AA's defence, that advert with the record-playing dog is excellent.
It's real joy compared to the usual cliche - dark, rainy, hazard lights, lone woman on phone, baby crying, looks scared, yellow flashy lights arrive, everyone smiling and waving.I could be in advertising, me.
I have RAC cover for my Wife and I (personal), with all the bells and whistles (home start, nationwide recovery, replacement car blah blah).
I think we pay £11 a month for this, although in reality, like most people, we never use it.
However, every year, they put the premium up by around 30% without any explanation.
I call them every year, and without really saying much more than "i've had my renewal through and i'm not happy", the price reverts to about 20/30p less a month than I currently pay.
What a game to play. Just like Car Insurance, Home Insurance, Gas, Electric, Virgin Media etc etc etc
I think we pay £11 a month for this, although in reality, like most people, we never use it.
However, every year, they put the premium up by around 30% without any explanation.
I call them every year, and without really saying much more than "i've had my renewal through and i'm not happy", the price reverts to about 20/30p less a month than I currently pay.
What a game to play. Just like Car Insurance, Home Insurance, Gas, Electric, Virgin Media etc etc etc

From another thread:
If you have to go AA/RAC then go with a cashback site to make it roughly half price:
For example: https://www.quidco.com/rac-uk-breakdown-cover/
NEVER renew. Just switch from the AA to the RAC or vice versa each year using a cashback site. Forget AA Bronze/Silver/Gold wk.
Or:
(1) If you're tight then Auto Aid is perfectly fine. It depends on what you want from breakdown cover.
(2) Pay £16-19 per month with a packaged bank account and get breakdown cover, mobile phone cover and worldwide travel insurance.
If you have to go AA/RAC then go with a cashback site to make it roughly half price:
For example: https://www.quidco.com/rac-uk-breakdown-cover/
NEVER renew. Just switch from the AA to the RAC or vice versa each year using a cashback site. Forget AA Bronze/Silver/Gold wk.
Or:
(1) If you're tight then Auto Aid is perfectly fine. It depends on what you want from breakdown cover.
(2) Pay £16-19 per month with a packaged bank account and get breakdown cover, mobile phone cover and worldwide travel insurance.
I feel AA and RAC will make more effort to repair at the roadside so tend to stick with them.
With any renewal now I ask them to match new sign up prices and I usually get a quick negative response. I then ask them to cancel and just see who out of the 2 is offering the best cashback deal and sign up as a new user.
With any renewal now I ask them to match new sign up prices and I usually get a quick negative response. I then ask them to cancel and just see who out of the 2 is offering the best cashback deal and sign up as a new user.
The Spruce Goose said:
My all inclusive breakdown cover cost 25 quid for whole year, so no, all breakdown covers aren't the same, some people pay X10 more for the brand.
That doesn't seem like a sustainable business model unless they're supported by a much bigger company. AA and RAC are both loss making, partially due to the prices that they offer. Baldchap said:
ApexCult said:
Call them up, I had the same on renewal and got the/a cheaper price by having a wee moan about the increase.
This. They'll knock it back down to last year's price if you ring and whinge. voram said:
Baldchap said:
ApexCult said:
Call them up, I had the same on renewal and got the/a cheaper price by having a wee moan about the increase.
This. They'll knock it back down to last year's price if you ring and whinge. I've used GEM motoring Assist for the last 5 or 6 years after being with the AA since the late 80's. The cost just kept increasing.
Have had to use GEM once, the rad on my E39 530i popped in a queue an the A417 after RIAT one year. It took a while for the truck to get to me but it was a Sunday night in fairness. Recovery back to Stafford was fine. No complaints from me at all.
I think this year it was about £120 for me and the wife for personal cover.
Have had to use GEM once, the rad on my E39 530i popped in a queue an the A417 after RIAT one year. It took a while for the truck to get to me but it was a Sunday night in fairness. Recovery back to Stafford was fine. No complaints from me at all.
I think this year it was about £120 for me and the wife for personal cover.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


