Failing to comply with restrict on vech entering a ped zone
Failing to comply with restrict on vech entering a ped zone
Author
Discussion

citychap26

Original Poster:

1,307 posts

259 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
Hi All,

Thanks for responses in advance.

I’ve been a victim of Croydon Council’s stty way of raising revenue.

I got ticket for driving down the one way part of Hailing Road at 15:54, the advance signage was obscured by a tree and is also at the height of double decker bus.

.

I did appeal against the PCN however they rejected it, stating that they did not have to give prior warning and that was not an excuse

I have driven back along the road and have noticed that they have trimmed back the tree



They claim below is the sign which states the rules, but once you turn on here it's too late they have snapped you!



I am going to appeal, Is there anything else I could add to support my appeal?

Cheers

Sunil

loskie

7,091 posts

149 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
maybe in whatever regs or bylaw there will be a spec of the required signage. Height and how much prior warning perhaps. The fact the tree is now trimmed back is an admission of failure on the council's behalf.

citychap26

Original Poster:

1,307 posts

259 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
loskie said:
maybe in whatever regs or bylaw there will be a spec of the required signage. Height and how much prior warning perhaps. The fact the tree is now trimmed back is an admission of failure on the council's behalf.
smile indeed

RSTurboPaul

13,084 posts

287 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
Is the first picture your picture? Your dash cam video? Google Streetmaps?

The first two would seem pretty strong in terms of evidence, and the latter if it is a recent drive-by.

You could FOI the council to ask for a record of tree cutting work that has taken place in the street/area, on the basis it might prove it was only recently cut back.

Edited by RSTurboPaul on Sunday 29th August 09:32

citychap26

Original Poster:

1,307 posts

259 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
RSTurboPaul said:
Is the first picture your picture? Your dash cam video? Google Streetmaps?

The first two would seem pretty strong in terms of evidence, and the latter if it is a recent drive-by.

You could FOI the council to ask for a record of tree cutting work that has taken place in the street/area, on the basis it might prove it was only recently cut back.

Edited by RSTurboPaul on Sunday 29th August 09:32
Hi,

First two pictures taken by myself on iPhone.

First picture after receiving the original PCN, second picture taken post their notice of rejection!

Third picture is from their rejection letter.

Cheers

Sunil

Greenmantle

2,154 posts

137 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
surely this is one example of many that should indicate to everyone that the best policy is to totally ignore the FPN. Let the council jog on. Just imagine if the tables were turned. The council would be jumping up and down highlighting the hypocrisy of the action of pruning the tree. Where is the justice in all of this. The simple answer is justice doesn’t play any part in this process. This is simply a money making process and given that I certainly won’t play any part of it.

danashby

425 posts

76 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
loskie said:
maybe in whatever regs or bylaw there will be a spec of the required signage. Height and how much prior warning perhaps. The fact the tree is now trimmed back is an admission of failure on the council's behalf.
+1

How much is the fine OP?

Countdown

49,340 posts

225 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
Greenmantle said:
surely this is one example of many that should indicate to everyone that the best policy is to totally ignore the FPN. Let the council jog on. Just imagine if the tables were turned. The council would be jumping up and down highlighting the hypocrisy of the action of pruning the tree. Where is the justice in all of this. The simple answer is justice doesn’t play any part in this process. This is simply a money making process and given that I certainly won’t play any part of it.
I think ignoring FPNs from the Council is significantly more risky than ignoring FPNs from PPCs.

citychap26

Original Poster:

1,307 posts

259 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
danashby said:
+1

How much is the fine OP?
The fine is £65 if paid in 14 days or £130 after



vonhosen

40,597 posts

246 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
So they are saying
The 'no left turn' sign isn't a requirement & you haven't been given a PCN for a no left turn.
And that the PCN you have been given is for transgressing the properly signed 'no motor vehicles' contravention, you committing the offence when you pass them?

MDUBZ

1,174 posts

129 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
Bit harsh, but then the restriction sign is visible in your before photo. Chalk it up as a mistake, pay the £65 and move on..

danashby

425 posts

76 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
citychap26 said:
The fine is £65 if paid in 14 days or £130 after
That sucks, but if I were you I would pay that £65 now. On a paper you are right, the sign was obstructed and it would be very hard to read unless you were standing right next to it. However you're dealing with council and from my personal experience I know that they will do everything they can to frustrate you and make you pay.
65 squids are not worth your time and stress.

Edited by danashby on Sunday 29th August 17:40

Greenmantle

2,154 posts

137 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Greenmantle said:
surely this is one example of many that should indicate to everyone that the best policy is to totally ignore the FPN. Let the council jog on. Just imagine if the tables were turned. The council would be jumping up and down highlighting the hypocrisy of the action of pruning the tree. Where is the justice in all of this. The simple answer is justice doesn’t play any part in this process. This is simply a money making process and given that I certainly won’t play any part of it.
I think ignoring FPNs from the Council is significantly more risky than ignoring FPNs from PPCs.
totally disagree. Councils are issuing significantly more tickets year on year. This leads them to allow for a certain amount of loss as long as they see an increase in total revenue.

Psycho Warren

3,087 posts

142 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
they will just take you to court and win by default if you dont pay.

Getragdogleg

10,202 posts

212 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
It's funny isn't it, there is a no motor vehicles sign with a "except for access" exclusion under it at the end of my parents cul-de-sac.

It is utterly unenforced by either the police or council.

It's a parking free for all with commuters parking on verges and over people's drives.

No amount of complaints have ever seen action in the 30+ years they have been there.

I was told by one copper the sign means nothing.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

246 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
Getragdogleg said:
It's funny isn't it, there is a no motor vehicles sign with a "except for access" exclusion under it at the end of my parents cul-de-sac.

It is utterly unenforced by either the police or council.

It's a parking free for all with commuters parking on verges and over people's drives.

No amount of complaints have ever seen action in the 30+ years they have been there.

I was told by one copper the sign means nothing.
Well the sign doesn't mean nothing, if the proper stages have been completed for it to be there.
Whether the council choose to enforce it or not is down to them.

SmoothCriminal

5,938 posts

228 months

Sunday 29th August 2021
quotequote all
Can't see how you can have any defence for that you can see the no motor vehicles sign clearly in your picture before you turn into the road so even if the no left turn sign was obscured you should have seen the restriction anyway and they've even angled the sign towards your direction of travel

citychap26

Original Poster:

1,307 posts

259 months

Tuesday 19th October 2021
quotequote all
Hi All,

Just to update you I won my appeal and the PCN has been overturned.

Very happy with the outcome and just shows your how terrible Croydon Council are in their endeavours to raise capital.

Cheers

Sunil

anonymous-user

83 months

Tuesday 19th October 2021
quotequote all
Nice one on winning.

Danashboys answer isn't great really. I wonder if the same action would be taken/said about a private parking invoice?