Discriminatory Job Advert
Author
Discussion

Countdown

Original Poster:

47,478 posts

219 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lancashire-5...

is it not better if potential applicants know exactly what the working culture is likely to be before they apply?

Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
it is unfortunate that some employers do not consider that an applicant can still be a tremendous asset to their organisation without adhering to a 0900-1730 routine.

A GM role will contain enough report writing, financial stuff and other general communication that can be carried out outside normal office hours to find a workaround.

Of course it could be read as being sexist as mostly women do the school run. Now if only it was mandated such things had to be shared equally.

irc

9,378 posts

159 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Not every job can be family friendly.

Bet Alec Ferguson wasn't at the school gates twice a week.

Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
irc said:
Not every job can be family friendly.

Bet Alec Ferguson wasn't at the school gates twice a week.
Why not?

So what?

Prefer wifey to be in her place?



bitchstewie

64,412 posts

233 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
I saw this on another thread and commented that I wonder if sometimes it's an attempt to be "motivational" that just goes really badly wrong.

Would someone really want to work somewhere that openly says "don't work for us if you want a life"?

Dromedary66

1,924 posts

161 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Imagine a 6th division club taking themselves that seriously.

Probably pays £8 /hr

Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
I saw this on another thread and commented that I wonder if sometimes it's an attempt to be "motivational" that just goes really badly wrong.

Would someone really want to work somewhere that openly says "don't work for us if you want a life"?
Excellent point and a resounding No.


Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

284 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
I don't see a problem with that. It'll weed out all of those who think the weekend is 'family time'. To be honest, is anyone really going to apply who doesn't understand the needs of a football club?

Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Dromedary66 said:
Countdown said:
Imagine a 6th division club taking themselves that seriously.

Probably pays £8 /hr
Self motivated people with drive and energy do not need regimented hours to function effectively. I've had some work for me that were decidedly flaky hours wise but never failed to deliver.

Companies should endeavour to work with staff as they will see much better outcomes and staff retention.





take-good-care-of-the-forest-dewey

7,346 posts

78 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Nickgnome said:
irc said:
Not every job can be family friendly.

Bet Alec Ferguson wasn't at the school gates twice a week.
Why not?

So what?

Prefer wifey to be in her place?
Why does it have to be a male manager?

Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
I don't see a problem with that. It'll weed out all of those who think the weekend is 'family time'. To be honest, is anyone really going to apply who doesn't understand the needs of a football club?
I wonder what the actual job description included as obligations and deliverables.

We have a GM at our sailing club but they are not required to work every weekend. Obviously weekends are when most activity occurs and World and National Championships of course



Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
take-good-care-of-the-forest-dewey said:
Why does it have to be a male manager?
It doesn't but one could be forgiven if one interpreted the advert as discriminatory

bitchstewie

64,412 posts

233 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Nickgnome said:
bhstewie said:
I saw this on another thread and commented that I wonder if sometimes it's an attempt to be "motivational" that just goes really badly wrong.

Would someone really want to work somewhere that openly says "don't work for us if you want a life"?
Excellent point and a resounding No.
I'm just thinking what a few of my "dream jobs" would be and what my reaction would be if one came up but they basically said "you belong to us" I guess.

Can't say I know the football industry well enough but is a GM role at a minor club that much of a prestigious position I wonder?

Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
I'm just thinking what a few of my "dream jobs" would be and what my reaction would be if one came up but they basically said "you belong to us" I guess.

Can't say I know the football industry well enough but is a GM role at a minor club that much of a prestigious position I wonder?
I know absolutely nothing of the soccer industry but expect the salary could still be £80K or so.

take-good-care-of-the-forest-dewey

7,346 posts

78 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Nickgnome said:
take-good-care-of-the-forest-dewey said:
Why does it have to be a male manager?
It doesn't but one could be forgiven if one interpreted the advert as discriminatory
I was tongue in cheek there... But there are just some jobs that require a flexible approach to hours. It's just the way it is. And you think about the suitability of that career path if you want kids.

My wife is more high flying than I am. I do the majority of school runs as there is no way she could and do her job. Works for both of us.

Countdown

Original Poster:

47,478 posts

219 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Nickgnome said:
it is unfortunate that some employers do not consider that an applicant can still be a tremendous asset to their organisation without adhering to a 0900-1730 routine.

A GM role will contain enough report writing, financial stuff and other general communication that can be carried out outside normal office hours to find a workaround.

Of course it could be read as being sexist as mostly women do the school run. Now if only it was mandated such things had to be shared equally.
I think the Employer should be given the right to decide what hours they expect somebody to be available and not have to change the job requirements to fit the needs of an Applicant.

Gareth79

8,741 posts

269 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
It reads very much like a classic "(we) work harder, not smarter" job description.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

284 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Nickgnome said:
Tyre Smoke said:
I don't see a problem with that. It'll weed out all of those who think the weekend is 'family time'. To be honest, is anyone really going to apply who doesn't understand the needs of a football club?
I wonder what the actual job description included as obligations and deliverables.

We have a GM at our sailing club but they are not required to work every weekend. Obviously weekends are when most activity occurs and World and National Championships of course
Slightly different at a football club. A sailing club has all the competitors a distance away on water with virtually no spectators generating income. A football club needs as many fans through the gate as possible each Saturday. I spoke once to a former GM of Plymouth Argyle who made a valid point of gate receipts and merchandise sales are a large part of a lower league club's income. Not so much the club the size of Manchester United where it is far more corporate. So yes, they'd definitely expect their GM to be at the club on a home Saturday.

Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Nickgnome said:
it is unfortunate that some employers do not consider that an applicant can still be a tremendous asset to their organisation without adhering to a 0900-1730 routine.

A GM role will contain enough report writing, financial stuff and other general communication that can be carried out outside normal office hours to find a workaround.

Of course it could be read as being sexist as mostly women do the school run. Now if only it was mandated such things had to be shared equally.
I think the Employer should be given the right to decide what hours they expect somebody to be available and not have to change the job requirements to fit the needs of an Applicant.
Rigid working hours are not necessary to achieve deliverables.

The job description should be able to stipulate requirements. Too many employers still think that a rigd hour policy means the staff will deliver. In fact it can cause resentment and clock watching.

That employer will reduce the potential applicant pool enormously and entrench an outdated attitude to achieving success.

I speak as an now ex employer with several thousand staff across the UK and globally. Company now over 50,000 strong. We had basic core hours but still flexible but i still found sometimes I was telling staff to go home as they were working too late. If staff are engaged and happy they deliver so much more and make the company more profitable.

Nickgnome

8,277 posts

112 months

Monday 13th September 2021
quotequote all
take-good-care-of-the-forest-dewey said:
I was tongue in cheek there... But there are just some jobs that require a flexible approach to hours. It's just the way it is. And you think about the suitability of that career path if you want kids.

My wife is more high flying than I am. I do the majority of school runs as there is no way she could and do her job. Works for both of us.
That is great and as it should be. You get the benefit of more time with kids as well. Something I sadly missed.