So many jobs…
Author
Discussion

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,123 posts

284 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all

With this news. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58543554

Of over 1m job vacancies, is this the right time to scrap unemployment benefit, working tax credits and the minimum wage?

We could re introduce the 10% tax bracket for every one for the first 25,000 of income (first 5k exempt)

A proper bit of free market economics would be very welcome and significantly reduce the Government deficit.

Wages are going to have to rise, so why not reform now.

[/Friedman]

Rivenink

4,292 posts

129 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Gargamel said:
With this news. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58543554

Of over 1m job vacancies, is this the right time to scrap unemployment benefit, working tax credits and the minimum wage?

We could re introduce the 10% tax bracket for every one for the first 25,000 of income (first 5k exempt)

A proper bit of free market economics would be very welcome and significantly reduce the Government deficit.

Wages are going to have to rise, so why not reform now.

[/Friedman]
You know inflation is going to go up, too, right?

People will be earning more, but things are going to cost more too. How much peoples wages rise vs how much price rises is for economic bods to model and predict.

But you're being ignorant if you think wages rising automatically means that everyone is going to be relatively richer than they were, and that they can start to be taxed more.

Besdies, they'd get more tax money closing all those loopholes and tax dodges the rich use.

Unless of course, one is more interested in reducing taxes for the rich.

46and2

834 posts

56 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
We have 12 open positions in our dept alone. Impossible to fill at the moment, no idea why. I don't think scrapping benefits overnight would be a great idea though.

Mr E

22,710 posts

282 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
46and2 said:
, no idea why.
My standard answer to this is usually “you’re not offering enough as compensation”

Jim the Sunderer

3,261 posts

205 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Care home, factory, bars/restaurants roles near the top.

I'd rather stay on the dole than do those whip crack jobs, not that I'm on the dole.

ARHarh

4,892 posts

130 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Mr E said:
46and2 said:
, no idea why.
My standard answer to this is usually “you’re not offering enough as compensation”
I was going to say that, a lot of companies expect a lot for minimum wage.

BabySharkDooDooDooDooDooDoo

15,078 posts

192 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
ARHarh said:
I was going to say that, a lot of companies expect a lot for minimum wage.
yes

And areas such as manufacturing are paying pathetic wages for highly skilled workers.

Healthcare sector - who wants to clean arses for minimum wage?

Hospitality- getting spoke to like st while working unsociable hours for less than minimum wage


Getragdogleg

9,861 posts

206 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Mr E said:
46and2 said:
, no idea why.
My standard answer to this is usually “you’re not offering enough as compensation”
A lot of the trouble is the applicant, rare to find anyone who can actually work and do a good job consistently now, timekeeping is another area younger workers struggle with, sometimes even turning up at all is hard and often you don't even get so much as a message that they won't be in.

The work ethic today is poor.

romeogolf

2,112 posts

142 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
46and2 said:
We have 12 open positions in our dept alone. Impossible to fill at the moment, no idea why. I don't think scrapping benefits overnight would be a great idea though.
No idea at all? Really?

What's the role and what's the salary being offered?

John145

2,729 posts

179 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Getragdogleg said:
A lot of the trouble is the applicant, rare to find anyone who can actually work and do a good job consistently now, timekeeping is another area younger workers struggle with, sometimes even turning up at all is hard and often you don't even get so much as a message that they won't be in.

The work ethic today is poor.
Lazy workers exist and this hasn’t changed generationally.

The reason lazy workers allow themselves to be is they don’t respect the mission of their employment or their terms and conditions.

If you fix one of those you’ll have productive employees.

People will work for pittance if they are motivated by the job they’re doing.

People will work hard for a good salary where there would be a genuinely felt loss if the job was lost.

Doesn’t seem like rocket science to me...

okgo

41,523 posts

221 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
romeogolf said:
No idea at all? Really?

What's the role and what's the salary being offered?
If it is so simple then why does any company have open roles? Amazon right now have 1800 roles in London?

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

196 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
100's of thousands of those jobs will be poor quality, part time or seasonal jobs for a start.

There's also millions of people in this country who are unemployable through fecklessness and that's before you get to the genuine people who can't work.

As much as I agree with the sentiment it would never work. Although work should always pay, even if it's 1hr a week.

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,123 posts

284 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Rivenink said:
You know inflation is going to go up, too, right?

People will be earning more, but things are going to cost more too. How much peoples wages rise vs how much price rises is for economic bods to model and predict.

But you're being ignorant if you think wages rising automatically means that everyone is going to be relatively richer than they were, and that they can start to be taxed more.

Besdies, they'd get more tax money closing all those loopholes and tax dodges the rich use.

Unless of course, one is more interested in reducing taxes for the rich.
I think you are being naive if you think closing loop holes for the rich ever raises any more actual revenue.

We have so many people paying little or no tax, that they have no stake in society anymore. Their view of tax is that it is soemthing other people should pay.

As to all the whining about the quality of the jobs. fk Off. why should I work to pay dole money to scroungers who don't like getting up in the morning. You don't like work ? Tough st. No one owes you a living.


Scrap long term dole (say any support above two years of transition payments. Scrap WTC. This would make employers have to raise wages to get the staff.


PH User

22,154 posts

131 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Jim the Sunderer said:
Care home, factory, bars/restaurants roles near the top.

I'd rather stay on the dole than do those whip crack jobs, not that I'm on the dole.
Which suggests that the dole is the problem.

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,123 posts

284 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
ChocolateFrog said:
and that's before you get to the genuine people who can't work.
Society should always provide a good safety net to those who cannot work, good point.


tangerine_sedge

6,184 posts

241 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
I'm currently trying to manage churn through my teams. Most are moving on and upwards, but it's a struggle to find experienced people with the right skills to replace them. We are paying well above industry rate, but the candidates just don't have the skills required...

hotchy

4,789 posts

149 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Jim the Sunderer said:
Care home, factory, bars/restaurants roles near the top.

I'd rather stay on the dole than do those whip crack jobs, not that I'm on the dole.
I bet you would do those jobs to feed your family, not be homeless and not die? So remove the dole so ones with your attitude can get back to work.

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

196 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
46and2 said:
We have 12 open positions in our dept alone. Impossible to fill at the moment, no idea why. I don't think scrapping benefits overnight would be a great idea though.
It's always the pay.

You can bh and moan about there not being enough talent around aka HGV drivers but if the average salary is £30-35k and you offer more than that then the relative shortage is irrelevant to you.

The same with pubs. Moaning because they can't fill a zero hour contract position at £9.50hr, can't think why that would be.

ARHarh

4,892 posts

130 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
okgo said:
romeogolf said:
No idea at all? Really?

What's the role and what's the salary being offered?
If it is so simple then why does any company have open roles? Amazon right now have 1800 roles in London?
Because £11.40 an hour is probably not enough to live on in London. Much easier to get benefits and your house paid for, than work your ass off for Amazon.

Electro1980

8,921 posts

162 months

Tuesday 14th September 2021
quotequote all
Low wages are a huge issue. Minimum wage for minimum, basic job is fine. 9-5 pushing a broom round or handing out post? Fine. Minimum wage for caring for people, wiping bums, working shifts and travelling all over? Not fine. Many minimum wage jobs are vastly under paid.