Age or Millage
Author
Discussion

Armchair Expert

Original Poster:

3,102 posts

102 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
Would you buy an older car with lower millage or a newer car with higher millage

Monkeylegend

29,041 posts

259 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
Sorry but it should be mileage paperbag

I have had 3 Mercs all did over 300k in less than 5 years from new with no issues so mileage would not bother me if the car has a verifiable service history and is well looked after and all the normal checks seem ok.


georgeyboy12345

4,580 posts

63 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
Having tried both, I'd definitely go for a newer car with higher mileage.

Cars that have accrued many miles in a shorter period are more likely to have done those miles on the motorway, which is less stressful on practically every component of the car.

Older cars may not have many miles on them because they have done only short journeys or have been sat for extended periods, neither of which are good for them.

Plus, the car will be newer, so will have newer tech, a more efficient/powerful engine, etc.

Edit: also, just thought - with so many cars being clocked these days, or having mileage blockers installed, it's a better strategy to go for a more "honest" car with plenty of miles on.

ZX10R NIN

30,460 posts

153 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
Neither would get the outright vote I buy on condition/receipts/age/mileage/spec & of course price, that's what makes up my mind.

Lincsls1

4,037 posts

168 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
I'd agree with the above. I'd buy on condition as seen and tested along with history and evidence of good maintenance.
Age and mileage less relevant.

rotaryjam

735 posts

129 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
Assuming you are talking about a comparison of the same make, model and model version then...

Always mileage unless there is a tangible beenfit to a newer car e.g. facelift version

Otherwise what does it matter if you go for a 2015 instead of a 2017?

In some cases older is better for example for tax, e.g. cars that were produced from say 2004-2008 you want a pre-2006 or you get destroyed on tax

Also for things like emission controls older cars can be more desirable for sound/performance

Lincsls1

4,037 posts

168 months

Thursday 11th November 2021
quotequote all
^^^ Quite right. I've just replaced a 2015 VW Caddy for a 2016 VW Caddy, and by God is the newer van more annoying.
More bongs, needs AdBlue and a bloody start-stop function that auto reset every restart! Grrr.

Mr Tidy

31,013 posts

155 months

Friday 12th November 2021
quotequote all
ZX10R NIN said:
Neither would get the outright vote I buy on condition/receipts/age/mileage/spec & of course price, that's what makes up my mind.
That would be my list too. thumbup

Wagonwheel555

909 posts

84 months

Friday 12th November 2021
quotequote all
I tend to find the model I want and look for the lowest mile example within my budget which also has the spec I want.

Unless you have an unlimited budget and are prepared to travel, there is often a compromise when buying a used car. Cars often vary in mileage for the same budget but its usually not buy much.

As an example, I would choose a car which had done 10k more miles if it had heated seats vs one that didn't, all else being equal.



ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

201 months

Friday 12th November 2021
quotequote all
3. Condition.

That said usually mileage as I prefer working on mechanicals over bodywork.