Plant Based
Author
Discussion

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

63,202 posts

231 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
I'm not vegetarian or vegan and don't intend becoming on but if I'm eating a Chilli or a Curry or lasagne or something similar I probably don't care what's in it too much so long as it tastes nice.

Ocado has lots and it isn't always obvious what's plant/not-meat.

Any suggestions on what might be worth trying please?

sherman

14,799 posts

236 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
If you dont plan on being veggie why bother?
Beyond meat products seem to get good reviews.

essayer

10,318 posts

215 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
I just had a taste of McPlant burger and I couldn’t tell the difference

Ouroboros

2,371 posts

60 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
A natural products or something made in factories with 20+ different ingredients(McPlant)?

rjfp1962

9,018 posts

94 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
I like my cooked meats like many, but these are quite tasty....... smile


hoagypubdog

756 posts

165 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
Ouroboros said:
A natural products or something made in factories with 20+ different ingredients(McPlant)?
My OH works in the food industry as a spec writer, many of the vegan stuff has up to 80 ingredients in the product with many more that don't need declaring. The meat based are usually about 15.

sherman

14,799 posts

236 months

Friday 14th January 2022
quotequote all
hoagypubdog said:
Ouroboros said:
A natural products or something made in factories with 20+ different ingredients(McPlant)?
My OH works in the food industry as a spec writer, many of the vegan stuff has up to 80 ingredients in the product with many more that don't need declaring. The meat based are usually about 15.
Used to sell a fake fish thing for vegan fish and chips in the pub I work in. The best way we came up with to describe it was a blend of 32 ingredients that somehow comes out smelling and tasting fishy. It looked like a grey lump of wet frozen cardboard before it was battered and fried.
We didnt sell a lot and now just sell fried haloumi instead.

Truckosaurus

12,839 posts

305 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
hoagypubdog said:
My OH works in the food industry as a spec writer, many of the vegan stuff has up to 80 ingredients in the product with many more that don't need declaring. The meat based are usually about 15.
Indeed, these 'fake meat' products are so processed, and full of calories, they are no way a healthy alternative to actual fresh meat.

(See also: a lot of the 'alcohol free' beers that have similar calories real beer)

Kaptain slow

87 posts

48 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
I don’t think these are meant to be a “healthy “ alternative to meat , just imo a way to still enjoy snack/takeaway food without killing animals.

Still high in calories and or additives (as in animal products)

otolith

64,786 posts

225 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
It’s possible to mimic low quality highly processed meat products using highly processed plant products.

ade73

465 posts

130 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
essayer said:
I just had a taste of McPlant burger and I couldn’t tell the difference
Because they both tasted rank and nothing like a "real burger"? biggrin

Kaptain slow

87 posts

48 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
ade73 said:
essayer said:
I just had a taste of McPlant burger and I couldn’t tell the difference
Because they both tasted rank and nothing like a "real burger"? biggrin
Had one yesterday and it’s really good (for being a processed fast food ) takeaway meal.

sherman

14,799 posts

236 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
Truckosaurus said:
(See also: a lot of the 'alcohol free' beers that have similar calories real beer)
They still make the beer properly with all the sugars etc The alcohol is stripped out after fermintation.

captain.scarlet

1,891 posts

55 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
In another thread I recommended The Vegetarian Butcher's Chickened Out burgers.

I tend to go for plant-based as something a bit different but usually if it's in the reduced aisle or there's an okay-ish deal.

Quorn mini cocktail sausages were okay until they noticeably changed the recipe.

However, things that put me off anything plant-based are the high salt and chemical/additive content that I've had no control over as opposed to buying some meat from the butcher, the fact that I'm effectively eating something developed and manufactured in a factory and therefore not really natural, and the price tag.

I can't justify on health or financial grounds eating more of a man-made laboratory product that works out far more expensive per weight unit than not only lamb, but some more fine and exotic types of meat. Plus I know I'm getting more natural proteins and other minerals from pure meat and not a frozen Linda McCartney sausage (again, they used to taste okay but nowadays they taste as though the recipe has been tinkered with for the worst).

Truckosaurus

12,839 posts

305 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
sherman said:
They still make the beer properly with all the sugars etc The alcohol is stripped out after fermentation.
And add all sorts of things like lactose to make it taste less watery. The 0% Hoegaarden has apple puree in it.

anonymous-user

75 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
essayer said:
I just had a taste of McPlant burger and I couldn’t tell the difference
I think that speaks volumes about the poor quality of McDonalds food than anything else!

I stepped inside my local one for the first time in this week after going veggie a few years back - thought it was the worst meat-alternative burger I've had, anywhere.

They use the beyond meat burger but so do many other places that manage to make a much better job of putting it together into something semi-edible - Brewdog for example.

As a veggie I have to agree though, many of the processed meat alternative products are utter garbage and contain a ridiculous amount of ingredients, and taste nothing like what they are trying to replicate. We tend to avoid 'cheeze', 'chickn', 'sosij' etc unless out and about with little other alternatives. When cooking at home and making chilli for example we'll substitute a variety of beans for protein and add a load of chopped mushrooms for texture, rather than use the processed mince alternatives.

For me these products defeat the purpose of why many go veggie - to try and eat a healthier diet.

FredericRobinson

4,639 posts

253 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
There's nothing inherently wrong in having lots of ingredients (apart from it making life bloody difficult for the poor sod writing the spec)

cml24

1,545 posts

168 months

Sunday 16th January 2022
quotequote all
sherman said:
If you dont plan on being veggie why bother?
Beyond meat products seem to get good reviews.
The only reasons I occasionally have a meat free alternative, is if we have guests round who are vegetarian, or for a lower environmental impact.

Beyond meat burgers are quite good. I don't mind the Richmond meat free sausages, which is surprising as the Richmond sausages that claim to actually have meat in aren't that nice! Both better for the environment.

Local wild deer also has a very low environmental impact and tastes much nicer though.

Resolutionary

1,462 posts

192 months

Monday 17th January 2022
quotequote all
A plant based diet and plant based alternatives to meat are two different things. One can consume a veritable plethora of meals made with real plant based and natural ingredients, just as one can also delve into the quite astonishing array of plant based alternatives to satisfy meaty flavours, textures etc etc (with admittedly mixed results!).

OP - I've tended to find places like Aldi and Lidl are at the forefront of the current consumer market for veggie / vegan stuff - on price point, ingredients, and introduction of additional items. I am always interested in trying out the off-the-shelf plant based alternative meat things, but that probably accounts for 10-20% of my intake as opposed to cooking and preparing meals with established recipes and real, unprocessed foodstuffs.

Most high street chains now have a dedicated section for vegetarian and vegan bits. Won't lie to you - it is a bit hit and miss, I've found some brands can really help sooth any cravings (I quite like the 'This Isn't Bacon' stuff, for example - especially when reduced!) but there is a lot of crap out there too.

If you're looking at lasagne or chilli, and the only real meaty thing in a regular one is.. well the meat.. then a simple switch would be plant based mince, and maybe cheese if you want to go the vegan route. Linda McCartney Vegemince is bang on for price and taste / texture.

blue_haddock

4,783 posts

88 months

Monday 17th January 2022
quotequote all
Truckosaurus said:
hoagypubdog said:
My OH works in the food industry as a spec writer, many of the vegan stuff has up to 80 ingredients in the product with many more that don't need declaring. The meat based are usually about 15.
Indeed, these 'fake meat' products are so processed, and full of calories, they are no way a healthy alternative to actual fresh meat.

(See also: a lot of the 'alcohol free' beers that have similar calories real beer)
This is my main issue with 'plant based' foods, we are forever being told that processed foods are the spawn of the devil and will ensure we die from cancer whereas plant based stuff is just as processed if not more but are held up to be the future of humanity.


As an example lets look at a Mcdonalds burgr comparison

Plant Based Burger
Water, Pea Protein (16%), Rapeseed Oil, Coconut Oil, Flavouring, Rice Protein, Stabiliser (Methyl Cellulose), Potato Starch, Apple Extract, Salt, Pomegranate Extract, Potassium Chloride, Concentrated Lemon Juice, Maize Vinegar, Yeast Extract, Carrot Powder, Emulsifier (Sunflower Lecithin), Colour (Beetroot Red), Maltodextrin


Beef Patty
100% Pure Beef.
No additives, fillers, binders, preservatives or flavour enhancers. Just pure forequarter and flank. A little salt and pepper is added to season after cooking


Can someone please tell me how the plant based burger is better for me or the environment?