Does anyone understand NCAP ratings?
Does anyone understand NCAP ratings?
Author
Discussion

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,335 posts

99 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
Does anyone look into NCAP crash results, or do you take the star rating as read? I'm replacing my wife's Citigo and safety is my top priority, as my wife and daughter use the car. I looked at a 2020 Honda Jazz. It has a 5 star rating, so I thought that's great. When I looked closer, ( here - https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/honda/jazz/412... ) , the results of crash test impacts are colour coded rating from best to worst green, yellow, orange, brown, red. For the Jazz, it all looks good except for the driver's chest area, which is coloured brown and protection is described as weak. How in hell does a car that provides weak protection for the chest (where the most vital organs are) get a five star rating? It has put me off the car, and cast doubt on the NCAP process. I am also highly skeptical about the kudos NCAP gives to cars with dubious accident prevention technology, which doesn't work in many circumstances and can be actively dangerous in others

Edited by lornemalvo on Friday 21st January 13:45

kambites

71,755 posts

252 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
You can easily ignore the active safety features entirely by simply looking at the full results, as it sounds like you are.

Regarding the way they come up with their final star rating, it's obviously a compromise of all of the results from all of the various sensors they have spread across all of the tests. Every car is going to have some marginal results somewhere.

Worth noting that that "brown" chest score in 2020 would probably have been green in 2015 because they're constantly moving the goal posts. With a small number of notable exceptions, the least safe car on sale now is going to be safer than the safest car was 10 years ago.

Edited by kambites on Friday 21st January 13:56

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
It's all a compromise, and a 5-star car isn't perfect. The star ratings are within a class too, a supermini isn't expected to be as good as a large saloon car to get 5 stars.

NCAP do quite thoroughly test accident prevention tech like AEB, some works better than others.

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

5,335 posts

99 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
kambites said:
You can easily ignore the active safety features entirely by simply looking at the full results, as it sounds like you are.

Regarding the way they come up with their final star rating, it's obviously a compromise of all of the results from all of the various sensors they have spread across all of the tests. Every car is going to have some marginal results somewhere.

Worth noting that that "brown" chest score in 2020 would probably have been green in 2015 because they're constantly moving the goal posts. With a small number of notable exceptions, the least safe car on sale now is going to be safer than the safest car was 10 years ago.

Edited by kambites on Friday 21st January 13:56
I get that, I'm sure that all the scores are taken into account for an overall star rating, but I would have thought that a single area described as weak (the second worst category), especially in a crucial area like chest protection, would prevent a 5 star rating. It's not a great analogy, but you can make a lot of mistakes in a driving test, but if you make one "serious" error it's a fail

swisstoni

24,257 posts

310 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
Sounds like they need a new rating system.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
You know a small lightweight car like that, even with a top safety rating will be seriously disadvantaged in a crash with a larger, heavier car, especially a big SUV?

If safety is a top priority, can she drive something bigger and heavier, in the class above?

Mr E

23,112 posts

290 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
wyson said:
If safety is a top priority, can she drive something bigger and heavier, in the class above?
This.
If safety of your family is the only concern, buy the biggest most massive thing you can.
Probably a Volvo.

Dr Interceptor

8,183 posts

227 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
Every car now will be safer than the equivalent of 10 or 20 years ago. Go and look at the car in the metal, and decide whether it’s right for you.

I had a mk7 Fiesta, and if you flung the door open on its hinges, the panel it bolted to (the a pillar) would flex, and that car had a good safety rating.

Crashed a 2018 Mustang quite hard (non fault) which had a poor safety rating, and didn’t have a scratch on me, despite having destroyed the front of the car and a Renault Clio.

hyphen

26,262 posts

121 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
and safety is my top priority,
Its the top priority of Volvo too. Get a Volvo?

Mr Tidy

31,953 posts

158 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
So long as the Volvo is new!

They seem to get good NCAP scores for things like lane awareness, blind-spot cameras, adaptive cruise control, autonomous braking, etc. which is always going to work every time when they are new as tested.

My current Dell laptop worked perfectly when I bought it in 2017, but now it is really random. Features that worked last week don't work this week or even from day to day, especially after a Windows 10 update.

I wouldn't rely on software for safety if it can't run a PC properly.

Anyway got to go, my printer is offline - again!

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
Dr Interceptor said:
Every car now will be safer than the equivalent of 10 or 20 years ago. Go and look at the car in the metal, and decide whether it’s right for you.

I had a mk7 Fiesta, and if you flung the door open on its hinges, the panel it bolted to (the a pillar) would flex, and that car had a good safety rating.

Crashed a 2018 Mustang quite hard (non fault) which had a poor safety rating, and didn’t have a scratch on me, despite having destroyed the front of the car and a Renault Clio.
Door flexing doesn’t have much to do with safety. They put reinforcement and energy absorbing structures inside the car and chassis.

https://media.ford.com/content/fordmedia/fna/us/en...

jamei303

3,084 posts

187 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I'm sure the majority of single-vehicle crashes are committed by people who thought they were at one with the vehicle.

colin79666

2,228 posts

144 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
Another thing to be aware of is most crash tests are of left hand drive vehicles. It might say valid for all examples of model xyz but there have been issues in the past with cars not standing up so well that have been converted to rhd.

The Suzuki Swift might not have got a full 5 stars but it did pretty well for a small car and I’m happy in the knowledge it was a rhd example used in the testing.

CoolHands

23,736 posts

226 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
I don’t think it matters now. Years ago cars were terrible and footwell ingress etc was bad. Now it’s understood snd been designed out by manufacturers so there’s not much more to be done. I wouldn’t even consider it with modern cars.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
CoolHands said:
I don’t think it matters now. Years ago cars were terrible and footwell ingress etc was bad. Now it’s understood snd been designed out by manufacturers so there’s not much more to be done. I wouldn’t even consider it with modern cars.
This is patently untrue. When the IIHS introduce new tests, recently the small overlap crash test and a new more forceful side impact test based on ever evolving real world crash, injury and fatality data, it painfully bears out the fact that is safety is a moving target and there is always more to do. The recent trend of people buying large SUV’s made them introduce the new side impact test to better reflect the mix of vehicles on the road, for instance. Heavy electric cars with a dense, thin, low down reinforced battery pack will bring their own challenges as they increase in popularity.

I would always prioritise a newer model that scored well in a whole suite of tests and would look up IIHS data as well. Their tests are really comprehensive, although as another poster mentioned, I doubt their scores will exactly translate across to RHD drive UK cars, with the possible exception of Volvo, who have proved time and again that they take safety really seriously.

Edited by anonymous-user on Saturday 22 January 08:59

Baldchap

9,639 posts

123 months

Sunday 23rd January 2022
quotequote all
There's a video somewhere online of a newish (at the time) Smart car literally cutting through the middle an old Range Rover.

Modern cars are spectacularly safe compared to old ones.

kambites

71,755 posts

252 months

Sunday 23rd January 2022
quotequote all
CoolHands said:
I don’t think it matters now. Years ago cars were terrible and footwell ingress etc was bad. Now it’s understood snd been designed out by manufacturers so there’s not much more to be done. I wouldn’t even consider it with modern cars.
It may have got to the point where you personally are happy with any new car, but the rate of increase of safety of cars has not slowed.

Even only looking at structural integrity cars are still improving at a phenomenal rate; a 2020 designed car which has a 50mph collision will have similar safety cell intrusion to a 2010 designed on in a 50mph collision and that could easily make the difference between surviving or not in a 60mph collision.

Personally I'm not a big one for safety - I daily drive an MGB for a while and my current Elise is appalling compared to anything modern, but for those who do care about crash safety, todays cars are far, far better than yesterdays and tomorrow's will no doubt be better again.

Edited by kambites on Sunday 23 January 14:52

Panamax

10,134 posts

65 months

Sunday 23rd January 2022
quotequote all
....which is why I won't go in old cars.

On the other hand it strikes me as bizarre the number of people who want a roadgoing battleship.

Some people just don't understand statistics. For instance, those who worry about their 'plane crashing but think nothing of driving to the airport.

Automaton

147 posts

72 months

Sunday 23rd January 2022
quotequote all
Baldchap said:
There's a video somewhere online of a newish (at the time) Smart car literally cutting through the middle an old Range Rover.

Modern cars are spectacularly safe compared to old ones.
There's also a video somewhere of a new-at-the-time Renault modus doing an overlap crash against a big old Volvo. The driver of the Volvo would have had a very bad time. Renault at the time were doing a very good job of "passive safety" and around that time I think everyone got a lot better at it.

I'm not convinced that newer cars have significantly better passive safety than those early 2000s cars, although there was a rule change for rollover strength not too long ago.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/driver-death-rate...

The stats I saw leading me to recommend a bigger car. ‘Mini’ cars have almost twice as high fatality rate compared to other car sizes.

The statistics show getting into something modern and Golf size or bigger has a significantly protective effect.

Real world data like this is also worth looking at, as it can capture information that isn’t present in isolated ‘lab’ type conditions used by Euroncap et al.

Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 25th January 06:03