AA won't prioritise rescuing women over men
AA won't prioritise rescuing women over men
Author
Discussion

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
AA won't prioritise women simply because they are female, makes sense to me. Breakdowns should be prioritised based on location. What do you think?

https://metro.co.uk/2022/01/20/aa-wont-prioritise-...

DonkeyApple

70,922 posts

200 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
Within reason, it should have some form of priority. Logically behind danger of situation re traffic and then young children but is blokes don't need any special attention. Besides, needing to call the AA is a fundamental failure of manhood. wink

bitchstewie

68,665 posts

241 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
I expect the comms has gone wrong somewhere because I doubt it's as simple as "that's equality" or location there will be other factors.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,309 posts

181 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
I think the AA are wrong. There's nothing wrong with using discriminatory policies to address ongoing inequality. Hence female only shortlists for prospective MPs and similar things. There isn't equality at the moment in the vulnerability between men and women alone in a broken down car.

I'm quite happy to wait longer so my female family members and female friends can be got to quicker.

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

204 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
aturnick54 said:
AA won't prioritise women simply because they are female, makes sense to me. Breakdowns should be prioritised based on location. What do you think?

https://metro.co.uk/2022/01/20/aa-wont-prioritise-...
They've back tracked since the Twitter backlash.

I agree with the AA, they should prioritise things like motorway breakdowns but prioritising based on sex seems a bit anathema to 2022.

I fairly sure more lone men are attacked than lone women.

liner33

10,861 posts

233 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
No location makes more sense, is a woman at more risk in a supermarket car park than a man is on a motorway? Gender should not come into it

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
I think the AA are wrong. There's nothing wrong with using discriminatory policies to address ongoing inequality. Hence female only shortlists for prospective MPs and similar things. There isn't equality at the moment in the vulnerability between men and women alone in a broken down car.

I'm quite happy to wait longer so my female family members and female friends can be got to quicker.
So what you're saying is that your nephew and brother should be left to wait for longer just so that a woman who has no particular vulnerability can be attended to first?

bitchstewie

68,665 posts

241 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
liner33 said:
No location makes more sense, is a woman at more risk in a supermarket car park than a man is on a motorway? Gender should not come into it
Not sure how that would work if a man and a woman both call saying they've broken down in a rough area or the middle of nowhere etc and you only have one rescue truck available.

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
Not sure how that would work if a man and a woman both call saying they've broken down in a rough area or the middle of nowhere etc and you only have one rescue truck available.
Attend to the nearest one first, the same as if two men are broken down in the middle of nowhere.

Ardennes92

720 posts

111 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
Would hope algorithm on call desk would prioritise call on circumstance not just gender, also no mention of reaching woman in about 20mins and car fixed and on the way again within another 20mins; wouldn’t want to spoil a good headline though.

DonkeyApple

70,922 posts

200 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
ChocolateFrog said:
I fairly sure more lone men are attacked than lone women.
That's probably true in statistical terms but when we're attacked it's normally just a battering to get our phone or wallet and while that's never going to pleasant it is infinitely preferable to the kind of attack we associate with being levied on lone women.

bitchstewie

68,665 posts

241 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
aturnick54 said:
Attend to the nearest one first, the same as if two men are broken down in the middle of nowhere.
If you had a brother and a sister and both called asking for help I'd guess most people would still prioritise their sister.

I don't think it's as black and white as "but equality" but I also don't think it's as black and white as women always being the priority.

That's probably the point that there's no absolutely consistent right way to do it that won't upset or annoy someone IMO.

DonkeyApple

70,922 posts

200 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
Isn't this ultimately a backlash to the marketing policy some time back where they stated that they prioritised women? Was that the AA?

Hoofy

80,190 posts

313 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
I think it is more a grey area. Agree with the supermarket argument but then it is about allocating resources and considering the overall risk. Two identical situations (two cars stuck in the New Forest for instance), if it was between me and a woman, then ladies first. Mind you, I am a powerfully built company director who knows how to write a stern email...

liner33

10,861 posts

233 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
That's probably the point that there's no absolutely consistent right way to do it that won't upset or annoy someone IMO.
Yep that's a reflection of the times we live in logic and common sense out of the window in favour of white knighting

Lexington59

974 posts

96 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
Why not just implement membership tiers like a frequent flyer programme. Platinum members pay more but can expect faster recovery priority than gold.

Muzzer79

13,266 posts

218 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
DonkeyApple said:
ChocolateFrog said:
I fairly sure more lone men are attacked than lone women.
That's probably true in statistical terms but when we're attacked it's normally just a battering to get our phone or wallet and while that's never going to pleasant it is infinitely preferable to the kind of attack we associate with being levied on lone women.
Tricky territory.

I'm sure if your son was killed whilst waiting for recovery during a breakdown on a smart motorway whilst a prioritised lone woman was having a flat tyre dealt with in a well lit 24hr supermarket car park, you may think differently.

Women are undoubtedly more vulnerable, but I think it needs more factors to assess priority other than just gender.

Hoofy

80,190 posts

313 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
Lexington59 said:
Why not just implement membership tiers like a frequent flyer programme. Platinum members pay more but can expect faster recovery priority than gold.
Wonder how much that would come to? biggrin

They already have a variety of rates and full cover is probably £220 a year?

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
If you had a brother and a sister and both called asking for help I'd guess most people would still prioritise their sister.

I don't think it's as black and white as "but equality" but I also don't think it's as black and white as women always being the priority.

That's probably the point that there's no absolutely consistent right way to do it that won't upset or annoy someone IMO.
I wouldn't, I'd prioritise whoever is nearest. If one is more vulnerable due to a disability for example, then yes they would take priority.

bitchstewie

68,665 posts

241 months

Friday 21st January 2022
quotequote all
And sometimes that'll be the right answer and sometimes it won't.

Like I said no easy answers and no absolutes IMO and very difficult for the poor sods who do have to prioritise.