RE: BMW 335i Touring (F31) | PH Fleet
RE: BMW 335i Touring (F31) | PH Fleet
Saturday 22nd January 2022

BMW 335i Touring (F31) | PH Fleet

Sick and tyred of rubber trouble...



That Christmas Sunday Service was fun, wasn't it? Seems ages ago now already, but it was so nice to see cars and PHers in real life once more. Hope you all enjoyed the stickers! It was on my way home from Caffeine & Machine, though, that I noticed a problem with the 335i. Parked up to take some photos in the sunshine that had replaced the showers, something caught my eye: on the nice new front Michelins, it said 'Primacy 4', where it should have said 'Pilot Sport 4'. Kwik Fit had put the wrong tyres on. Having charged me for the right ones. D'oh.

Now, it turns out there's not a great deal of price difference between Pilot Sport and Primacy, and it's hardly like the car was an undrivable mess as a result of a slightly less expensive Michelin. I must be honest, given the whole brake and wheel fiasco, I was content just to leave it and hope for better luck in future. I whinged on Twitter and thought little more of it. Even when Kwik Fit Customer Service got in contact, I said the tyres were fine, really - I just couldn't be bothered.

It was only when Michelin's UK PR Conor Twomey messaged that I changed my mind. He made some calls, Customer Service were back in touch very quickly, the correct Pilot Sport 4s were dispatched and... they were for the rear axle. Then the correct tyres were in stock, ready to be fitted... but having said I'd be there at lunchtime, I arrived to be told they were going to call to book an appointment. Finally, the front PS4s were fitted last weekend, and some Kwik Fit vouchers are on the way as an apology. Probably I'm still not going to rush back.



Speaking of apologies (and not rushing back anywhere), it should be noted that the dealer principal of North Oxford rang before Christmas and contributed £400 to the bill, which was very much appreciated. Park Royal offered to pay another £200 but, quite frankly, I felt awkward accepting any more. Instead I have the equivalent of store credit there, which, given the price of official BMW bits and bobs, will probably buy some floormats and an air freshener. But it was a nice gesture at least. Obviously I'd have preferred a properly prepared BMW Approved Used car and none of the inconvenience, but there we go. The money can go towards a spare wheel now the tyres aren't run-flat. And I can stop thinking about it.

Happily, when it isn't at Kwik Fit, the 335i is a dream. It was our transport for Christmas - the first time I've used my own car over the festive period - and the big(ish) BMW was ideal for everything. It was sufficiently commodious to carry all the Christmas clobber, mature enough to ferry family around without drawing attention - yet still quick enough to be fun on rare solo drives. Naturally I'm already craving a little more performance; it's strong enough, with 295lb ft from the N55 straight-six, but the 335i weighs 1,650kg before it has people, wine, and shower gel gift sets in. It never struggled, but nor did the BMW feel as effortlessly quick as it does without ballast. Almost certainly a 335d - with a chunky 465lb ft - wouldn't have felt the impact so much. A bit of research suggests an ECU tickle and some intake work could get both power and torque nearer 400 points, which sounds nice. Especially with the tyres to now make the most of it!

We'll see - as usual, I'm getting a little ahead of myself on car plans. For the moment I'm content just to keep it running; a 3.0-litre 3 Series was pushing the budget somewhat in August. With the rise in price of everything since then - I saw a similar one for sale recently at £6k more than we paid - plus the costs of both a house move and imminent baby arrival, modifications really will have to take a back seat for a while. The occasional top up of super unleaded has been ditched as well. There's nothing I want more than to ferry my first child around in the Touring - and don't want to sell having endured this hassle - so perhaps it'll just have to be used a little more frugally in the coming weeks. Which is probably why everyone bought an xDrive 335d...


FACT SHEET

Car: 2014 BMW 335i M Sport Touring (F31)
Run by: Matt
Bought: August 2021
Mileage: 44,526
Purchase price: £19,500
Last month at a glance: Michelin Matt gets Michelin mad

Previous reports









Author
Discussion

Miserablegit

Original Poster:

4,449 posts

140 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
Good to hear your troubles seem resolved - a benefit of being a motoring journalist.

You can bet none of the above entities would have given two hoots had you been Joe public.


Andrewph75

54 posts

182 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
What a hassle with the tyres, I wonder what help being a journalist was with the aftercare compared to being Joe Public. I haven't been back to a Kwik Fit since the early 90s when they claimed my tyres were on the limit when no such thing, sorry to say but last place I would trust. Black circles and local or a mobile fitter every time for past 15 years and no reason to change

S600BSB

8,615 posts

137 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
Miserablegit said:
Good to hear your troubles seem resolved - a benefit of being a motoring journalist.

You can bet none of the above entities would have given two hoots had you been Joe public.
I thought the same thing!

RyCliff

64 posts

153 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
I've been pleasantly surprised with my first experience of main dealer aftersales. My RS Megane 250 is back at the dealer with a full gearbox swap (noisy bearings), new door mechanism (no keyless on driver door) and brake line work all FOC. I've had a courtesy car for the full time too (since Christmas).

After reading this maybe I should be looking to get some sort of compensation having only actually driven the car 1 week since start of December. Though as per #1 don't think there's much of a care for Joe public without the platform.

JackReacher

2,293 posts

246 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
I've just ordered some Michelin PS4S tyres for my m340i touring, hoping its a big improvment over the Goodyear run flats.

cerb4.5lee

45,351 posts

211 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
You sound very similar to me Matt when it comes to the cars weight and how much torque it has. I also had a bit(a lot!) of a moan about the E92 M3 I had with 295 torque mated to 1650kg. I also occasionally moan about the 270 torque in the 370Z because that weighs 1650kg as well.

I do think that when a car is relatively heavy it is nice to have a bit more torque to fall back on, and I've never moaned about the torque in the 330d/640d/GLC350d for example. Plus I absolutely love the torque in the M4 too.

Pleased to hear that your tyres got sorted etc too. I'm a big fan of the Michelin PS4, and I have those on the 370.

samoht

7,325 posts

177 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all

It seems that tyre people have trouble distinguishing Michelins - I ordered a full set of 18" MPS4 for my 350Z a couple of years back, and Blackcircles sent three of those, and one 17" Primacy. In this case at least I wasn't sent away with the wrong tyres, the garage realised when they opened the box. The hassle is annoying though.

I'm glad you got the right tyres sorted, I'd be a lot more bothered personally, don't want Prius tyres on something like this!

ratty6464

637 posts

241 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
JackReacher said:
I've just ordered some Michelin PS4S tyres for my m340i touring, hoping its a big improvment over the Goodyear run flats.
Once they have bedded in (500+ Miles) it will be a measure improvement. I’ve had them on my M3and now M340i and they are supreme to push really hard in the dry and give loads more confidence in wet and greasy conditions.

You’re ride will be way better than run flats too

spikyone

1,922 posts

131 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
samoht said:
I'm glad you got the right tyres sorted, I'd be a lot more bothered personally, don't want Prius tyres on something like this!
I'm very surprised Matt was happy with the Primacy tyres too, especially as a car journalist. Unlike many on PH I'll confess to not being a driving god, but when it was cold or wet - this time of year, basically - I found them absolutely hopeless on the GT86. They were terrible for traction and would lose grip on a wet roundabout without anything I'd describe as provocation. Worse than that, when they did lose grip in cold and wet conditions there was no communication, just an instant switch from grip to sliding.

Needless to say I changed to PS4, and the difference is night and day in both wet/cold grip and communication.

cerb4.5lee

45,351 posts

211 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
spikyone said:
samoht said:
I'm glad you got the right tyres sorted, I'd be a lot more bothered personally, don't want Prius tyres on something like this!
I'm very surprised Matt was happy with the Primacy tyres too, especially as a car journalist. Unlike many on PH I'll confess to not being a driving god, but when it was cold or wet - this time of year, basically - I found them absolutely hopeless on the GT86. They were terrible for traction and would lose grip on a wet roundabout without anything I'd describe as provocation. Worse than that, when they did lose grip in cold and wet conditions there was no communication, just an instant switch from grip to sliding.

Needless to say I changed to PS4, and the difference is night and day in both wet/cold grip and communication.
I echo this as well. I had Primacy 3 on the Cooper S and they were nothing short of terrible for me. I swapped them for PS4 and it not only improved the grip, but they also gave me much more confidence under braking too.

leef44

5,229 posts

184 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
Wow that is a nice looking BMW. The last of the breed before the ugly grills came in.

TheMachMan

1,029 posts

253 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
I’ve got a 320d. Touring in same colour and wheels. What’s the problem with run flats? Car handles and drives well and have the comfort of not worrying if I get a puncture. In fact best handling German estate I’ve had after many A4’s & a C class.

Motormatt

508 posts

249 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
samoht said:
It seems that tyre people have trouble distinguishing Michelins - I ordered a full set of 18" MPS4 for my 350Z a couple of years back, and Blackcircles sent three of those, and one 17" Primacy. In this case at least I wasn't sent away with the wrong tyres, the garage realised when they opened the box. The hassle is annoying though.

I'm glad you got the right tyres sorted, I'd be a lot more bothered personally, don't want Prius tyres on something like this!
Similar happened to me a few years back.
A well known tyre fitting outfit put 4 new tyres my 1 series, (oem RFT Pirelli’s as it was a company lease car) it had staggered wheels so rears wider than fronts. Both rears were fine but one of the fronts was wrong, narrower and had a different, lower profile. I noticed it straight away as the car wasn’t ‘sitting right’. To be fair they showed me the label which didn’t match the sidewall so appeared to be an error by Pirelli.
They ordered the correct one and fitted the next day. Couldn’t help thinking that a less observant customer would have driven off wondering why the front end felt worse with its brand new tyres than it did before!

Andrewph75

54 posts

182 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
I’ve run a F31 330D since 2014 and when i ditched the original Bridgestone run flats ride was better, quieter and Michelin Pilot Sports lasting way longer too. Agree with the puncture point but they only last 50 miles anyway.

Pistonheader101

2,206 posts

138 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
runflats are dreadful

Court_S

14,831 posts

208 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
spikyone said:
I'm very surprised Matt was happy with the Primacy tyres too, especially as a car journalist. Unlike many on PH I'll confess to not being a driving god, but when it was cold or wet - this time of year, basically - I found them absolutely hopeless on the GT86. They were terrible for traction and would lose grip on a wet roundabout without anything I'd describe as provocation. Worse than that, when they did lose grip in cold and wet conditions there was no communication, just an instant switch from grip to sliding.

Needless to say I changed to PS4, and the difference is night and day in both wet/cold grip and communication.
Same here. My other half’s old F56 MINI came with Primacy tyres and I thought they were bloody terrible.

The PS4’s on my car are very good though and feel like an improvement on the Super Sports that my old car had (which I didn’t mind in all fairness).

It does sound like a ball ache though. I’m not sure I’d have been quite so calm / understanding.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
Miserablegit said:
Good to hear your troubles seem resolved - a benefit of being a motoring journalist.

You can bet none of the above entities would have given two hoots had you been Joe public.
100% this.

BimmerRossay

65 posts

139 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
Fairly amusing, how can you not check your tyres after being installed?

Anyways MPS4s really do make a difference, was amazing when fitted onto my Z4 35i.

Recently went for MPS4 zero pressure on my wife’s 1 series so she can have the safety net of runflats. Have to say it’s almost 80-90% ride improvement and noise as the non-run flats and feels just as good in wet/dry etc.

I’d recommend either for BMW owners, they last ages too, much more than all the other brands I’ve been stuck with on my previous 3 BMWs. BMW should use Michelin tyres across all their models for all cars sold - as it makes a huge difference and whole point of driving a BMW vs other brands is the way it drives.

Shame they’re using mini platform and not sticking with RWD - the love of cars is fading…..recently got new 1 series as courtesy car for service, such a dull FWD drive.

Not driven a front wheel drive car since I first passed my test, over a decade and you can’t beat RWD. I have no idea why some of the reviews gloss over it, like they’re trying to stay in BMWs good books.

Don’t even start me on the looks - BMW has lost their way.

The irony is the SUV lineup for BMW is probably the best bit about them these days, but it shows how they won’t tamper with what makes the money.

NGK210

5,186 posts

176 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
Definitely check tyres before paying.
Had similar problem with current car when I first drove it after delivery (lockdown rules).
The front-end felt odd when cornering, even at town speeds, with alarming understeer on roundabouts.
Long story short: not only had the previous owner been ripped off – £170 per 18in tyre – but the rears were Goodyear Eagle F1s, the fronts Goodyear Efficient Grips. Which kinda explained the understeer irked

Sion111R

425 posts

123 months

Saturday 22nd January 2022
quotequote all
I’ve had directional tyres fitted the wrong way on my Elise.
I spotted them immediately and i’m no expert. Doh!