your future transport policy
your future transport policy
Author
Discussion

A500leroy

Original Poster:

8,628 posts

149 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
So what would you like to see?

Mine is to simplify everything.

So no petrol/hybrid/ev nonsense, only hybrid with a few design must haves, ie:
The motor must power the vehicle upto 28mph and have a range in ANY weather upto 50miles
The (lpg) powered engine must be no more than 875cc and have a top speed of 80mph

Speed limits
Simple, All single carriageways 25mph max, all dual carriageways (inc m ways) 65mph for all vehicles (cars,bikes,vand,hgv etc)

Then all taxs gone. If you activate the (lpg) motor a simple day rate of £1 this would allow local travel for free.

Objections?


GT9

9,104 posts

203 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
LPG produces both CO2 and NOx, admittedly less NOx per mile than diesel.

Basing a long-term road transport policy on the combustion of fossil fuels is, well, not very forward thinking wouldn't you say?

rampageturke

2,625 posts

193 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
all cars aged 40 or older must be converted to EV

hehe

JAMSXR

1,854 posts

78 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
Don’t tax my V8 off the road.

Huge investment in the U.K. cycle network, with a particular focus around schools. Make use of the barley used pavements and miles of unused grass verges, canal, and rivers towpaths to create half decent cycle network. Put incentives in place to make eBikes more accessible.

Whilst I appreciate it’s not possible for everyone, the focus should be on getting people out of their cars where possible. The school run is a great example, I would love to send my kids to school on a bike but it’s simply not safe.

Total pipe dream.

Dog Star

17,650 posts

199 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
A500leroy said:
So what would you like to see?
I'd like to see all this green hysteria and nonsense just stop - it's all getting out of control.
We are going absolutely bonkers in the UK and for some reason we seem to be wanting to be at the forefront of a "green revolution" when the reality is that the differences we make to anything on this planet is basically a percentage rounding error. It's nuts.

Yet some hand wringer will say, as we all get taxed to oblivion, "well we have to be SEEN to be doing something", or the absolutely corking argument I saw for decimating economy and industry was our "old colonial past, the industrial revolution so we need to pay back for it now". Eh? confused

It really has got to stop. There's not much needed to change policy in the UK - no more than a guiding hand. EVs are taking over and will continue to do so as long as they offer a product THAT PEOPLE WANT TO BUY, this on it's own will achieve huge reductions in carbon, NO2 etc. No need to force us all to get the bus and sit in some chav's piss

That's my transport policy.

A500leroy

Original Poster:

8,628 posts

149 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
GT9 said:
LPG produces both CO2 and NOx, admittedly less NOx per mile than diesel.

Basing a long-term road transport policy on the combustion of fossil fuels is, well, not very forward thinking wouldn't you say?
Im aiming at somewhere between being as green,affordable and useable as we can be, ie a compromise

GT9

9,104 posts

203 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
A500leroy said:
GT9 said:
LPG produces both CO2 and NOx, admittedly less NOx per mile than diesel.

Basing a long-term road transport policy on the combustion of fossil fuels is, well, not very forward thinking wouldn't you say?
Im aiming at somewhere between being as green,affordable and useable as we can be, ie a compromise
Do you live in an urban or rural environment?

There is simply no way you can now pursue a long term fossil fuel based option for urban environments. That ship sailed long ago.

slipknotted

258 posts

68 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
I'd ban most ICE vehicles from city and maybe even large town centres, except ambulances, necessary commercial vehicles, public transport and motability cars. London has already banned new ICE taxis so you wouldn't have a problem there plus with the reduced traffic you could pedestrianise large areas and promote vast cycle infastructure (can you tell I've been paying attention to Netherlands?)

I'd give large government grants and offers of lucrative contracts to companies who can develop and test/prove clean HGVs/trains as I'd guess commercial haulage is responsible for a large percentage of pollution nowadays and there simply must be a better solution.

As price and range are the main barriers to electric car ownership right now I'd heavily incentivise electric car ownership; subsidise EV purchases and give companies tax benefits if they install chargers, etc. As much as I love ICE cars, they should be for enthusiasts and the few people who need to do hundreds of miles daily, so a 1400cc cap on new diesel engines and 1000cc cap on new petrol engines (for normal cars, excluding HGVs, etc) would mean the people whose mileage needs exceed the capabilities of EVs can drive around barely polluting and getting 80+mpg. Older cars should require an 'enthusiast permit' to drive on public roads which would allow a max of a few thousand miles (if that) per year to enjoy their cars but not club the baby seals.

I hope I haven't alienated myself too much but tbh EVs are just better in almost every way then ICEVs and if you really want to go for a sunday drive in your MGB then you should be allowed to occasional as long as you don't take the piss. Of course racetracks are a different ball game, getting the absolute better from an ICEV is an art and should be preserved. Most people will make the switch to EVs in the next few years won't look back honestly, I can't wait!

Now, onto all those corporations who feel they can haphazardly and disproportionately pollute our planet in the name of shareholder wealth!

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

292 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
A transport policy should be about allowing people to get from place to place, not obstructing them at every opportunity.

Even in urban areas air is cleaner than it's been for centuries so existing emissions laws are sufficient. No need to ban ICE, if electric vehicles really are better for everything people will switch to them anyway.

Put a written element in the driving test to prevent stupid people from driving.

Change the new driver 6 point rule from 'if you get 6 points you go back to a provisional UNLESS you pass your test again' to if you get 3 points you go back to a provision licence UNLESS you pass a test again within a certain period', say 6 months'.
There is a definite correlation between inexperience and accidents so taking young drivers off the road is almost guaranteed to make them worse.




JAMSXR

1,854 posts

78 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
EVs seem like a great excuse to fuel even more consumerism, dressed up as saving the planet. It’s a feel good a middle class solution. Maybe we should also put a quota on air miles or buying habits?

Unless you’ve got 100k to spend on a Taycan they’re as dull as dishwater. Fine if you want an A to B mode of transportation, but I’m guessing most people on here want a little more than that.

I’ve no doubt EVs will improve and take over our roads, so I don’t think we need to get all ‘ban everything’ as it will happen naturally over the next 10 years and beyond.

Edited by JAMSXR on Wednesday 26th January 13:15

A500leroy

Original Poster:

8,628 posts

149 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
GT9 said:
A500leroy said:
GT9 said:
LPG produces both CO2 and NOx, admittedly less NOx per mile than diesel.

Basing a long-term road transport policy on the combustion of fossil fuels is, well, not very forward thinking wouldn't you say?
Im aiming at somewhere between being as green,affordable and useable as we can be, ie a compromise
Do you live in an urban or rural environment?

There is simply no way you can now pursue a long term fossil fuel based option for urban environments. That ship sailed long ago.
Rural, which is why i said all urban speed limits would be cut to 28mph and a hybrid car would have to run on pure electric at that speed.

768

20,873 posts

127 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
Build nuclear power stations to give us cheap and reliable electricity.
120mph motorway speed limit. All the 50s back up to 60.
Ditch speed cameras.
Update road markings to make it easier for vehicles to self navigate autonomously.
Buses mandated as driverless by 2025, taxis by 2030.
Assemble a crack team of engineers to improve accident black spots.
Pave the railway lines outside the M25.

Roger Irrelevant

3,402 posts

144 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
I'd take more of a carrot than stick approach; make it easier to run an EV as opposed to more difficult to run an ICE. Thinking of my own situation, I'd really like to run an EV but I have the usual problems of no off-street parking, do long journeys quite often, and live in a bit of a public charger desert. I'd aim to build lots of charging hubs - basically small car parks with 5, 10 fast (or rapid or whatever) chargers, with a view to having one within (say) half a mile of 95% of the population. Use brownfield sites, bits of village hall/church car parks etc if they're already there. No apps or anything like that necessary to use them, just a bank card. And the other thing is I'd try to enforce some sort of standardisation - so any EV sold in the UK must be compatible with those public chargers. Once EVs are in the majority then if there is to be VED then base it on size and weight; clobber anything bigger/heavier than a decent sized estate.

Maybe some sort of means-tested scrappage scheme to help owners of older ICE cars to make the changeover - doling out thousands of pounds to already wealthy people who are buying new cars every three years anyway seems mad to me. Hopefully with that you wouldn't need to go too far down the route of banning stuff as you'll bring people along with you.

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

292 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
A500leroy said:
Rural, which is why i said all urban speed limits would be cut to 28mph and a hybrid car would have to run on pure electric at that speed.
You said all single carriageways 25MPH.

kiethton

14,672 posts

211 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
Permit and encourage some "green" private urban transport methods - e-scooters, ebikes and normal bikes while continuing to build-out the network. This should ease pressure on public transport which is often over-crowded and reduce reliance on cars.

Take a top-down view on long-distance, rural/suburban public transport to work out why it doesn't work (cost/timings) and see how that can be fixed.

Take a proper look at traffic light phasing and re-program lights to make traffic flow more efficiently

Revert a lot of the universal lowering of speed limits in both rural and urban areas to make limits appropriate for the road - the 85% rule

Focus on driver education to improve driving standards - more draconian DWDC penalties to include re-tests etc.

Subsidise the roll-out of both electric charging (more urban) and hydrogen refulling infrastructure in the knowledge that BEV's work well in urban areas they are less-good for larger/rural users. This investment will pay for itself in time.

Encourage edge-of-town last mile delivery hubs, making it feasible to have electric/cycle ultra-urban delivery fleets to remove a significant proportion of traffic.

Pedestrianise large tracts of ultra-urban areas unless direct access to buildings.

Encourage the adoption of Kei car rules (or similar) which focus on the footprint of a vehicle


GT9

9,104 posts

203 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
A500leroy said:
GT9 said:
A500leroy said:
GT9 said:
LPG produces both CO2 and NOx, admittedly less NOx per mile than diesel.

Basing a long-term road transport policy on the combustion of fossil fuels is, well, not very forward thinking wouldn't you say?
Im aiming at somewhere between being as green,affordable and useable as we can be, ie a compromise
Do you live in an urban or rural environment?

There is simply no way you can now pursue a long term fossil fuel based option for urban environments. That ship sailed long ago.
Rural, which is why i said all urban speed limits would be cut to 28mph and a hybrid car would have to run on pure electric at that speed.
Ah I see, so the thread is about a policy that would suit me best and sod everyone else smile

In that case.

Access:
All diesels banned from urban environments.

National speed limits including motorways:
Diesels cannot exceed 50 mph, no exceptions.
EV & petrol cannot exceed 70 mph unless 8 cylinders or more, then 100 mph.

Free pass (no speed limit, no access restrictions): Normally-aspirated petrol V8.


bigothunter

13,594 posts

91 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
Segregate pedestrians and cyclists (the most vulnerable road users) from motorised vehicles across all cities, towns and urban conurbations

Dave Hedgehog

16,398 posts

235 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
all fuel types and emission outputs will be allowed

however there is a £5 per litre pollution tax, all proceeds from which is used to heavily subsides EVs and keep them tax free.

There is a £10 per mile tax on PHEV as punishment for being scammed


Dave Hedgehog

16,398 posts

235 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
768 said:
Build nuclear power stations to give us cheap and reliable electricity.
.
that's a contradiction in terms nuclear is the most expensive by a mile because of the decade and 10s of billions construction time, the decade and 10s of billions decommissioning time, and the infinite waste storage problem

Dynion Araf Uchaf

5,203 posts

254 months

Wednesday 26th January 2022
quotequote all
my policies would be:

legislation to ban fully autonomous drive, at best maybe some motorway legislation to allow some lane keep assist/reactive cruise control.

Zero emission zones in urban centres, but the removal of traffic calming measures or other restrictions to allow for ease of movement.

No ban on petrol or diesel however heavier taxation.

Government funded comprehensive charging network that can then be floated to the private investor/utility companies

Speed limits to increase in all but the busiest or most dangerous areas. Assumption that the speed travelled is safe unless you are in an accident in which case it is automatically unsafe

Better driving training including compulsory motorway training. Limits on car performance for those that don't want to improve beyond the basic test

Additional driving tests including, defensive driving, skid control

Business and or individual 'encouraged' to allow work from home 60% of the week ( where possible) to reduce traffic/pollution

The cessation of any new road or public transport building, however improved maintenance of the existing infrastructure.

for starters.... biggrin